Danny Stanley Vs Beau Muston

[daics cousin]

Danny Stanley has been with pies for 3 seasons.This season has to be the defining season for him.
Get ready to see a super player emerge this year,via the hawks......Beau Muston is the player the pies should have picked up .
However the pies opted for Stanley over Muston,we could have had Muston,only time will tell who becomes the better player.
Any comments appreciated.

Last year dermie was asked "who is or will be your favorite player at hawthorn,and he replied, i love watching Beau Muston,he will become a champion,i just love the way he goes about his footy"
Rumoured to win the rising star this year,muston is ready to explode on the AFL in 2008.
Nothing against stanley but i wished we picked up muston instead.

 

[Kirby]

Dermie also called Aaron james the new Wayne Carey so i wouldn't get too worked up about it.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Clubs were worried about muston when he did his knee pretty badly in the TAC cup, and it looked like one of those career threatening ones, reason he didnt play last year is because the Knee Reco. was a failure and had to go under the knife again. But was rated top 5 earlier in the year before that happened.

 

[3066]

Rumoured to win the rising star this year,muston is ready to explode on the AFL in 2008.
Nothing against stanley but i wished we picked up muston instead.

Wow!! That's pretty impressive .... considering the season hasn't started or anything.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Danny Stanley has been with pies for 3 seasons..

He's been with us two seasons.

 

[Murray]

Danny Stanley has been with pies for 3 seasons.This season has to be the defining season for him.
Get ready to see a super player emerge this year,via the hawks......Beau Muston is the player the pies should have picked up .
However the pies opted for Stanley over Muston,we could have had Muston,only time will tell who becomes the better player.
Any comments appreciated.

Last year dermie was asked "who is or will be your favorite player at hawthorn,and he replied, i love watching Beau Muston,he will become a champion,i just love the way he goes about his footy"
Rumoured to win the rising star this year,muston is ready to explode on the AFL in 2008.
Nothing against stanley but i wished we picked up muston instead.

This is a piss take on all those Player X V Player Y threads isn't it?

 

[Us3]

This is a piss take on all those Player X V Player Y threads isn't it?

it's a piss take on something, probably a considered and educated statement.

i cant believe the amount of tripe that goes around at this time of the year.

 

[daics cousin]

Wow!! That's pretty impressive .... considering the season hasn't started or anything.

Sorry guys your right,what i meant to say is that the hawks will debut Muston this year,and if he plays regularly he could win the Rising Star Award.

 

[Skade]

Four years down the track. Stanley a very good player, Muston retires after his third knee

 

[Murray]

it's a piss take on something, probably a considered and educated statement.

i cant believe the amount of tripe that goes around at this time of the year.

BigFooty never ceases to amaze me

 

[3066]

BigFooty never ceases to amaze me

I'm waiting for the "Buckley to return playing for the Pies" thread.

 

[Murray]

I'm waiting for the "Buckley to return playing for the Pies" thread.

It'll turn up eventually

 

[The Royal Sampler]

If Muston's the player we should have taken instead of Stanley, then surely Warnock is the player we should have taken instead of Cook.

 

[Skade]

If Muston's the player we should have taken instead of Stanley, then surely Warnock is the player we should have taken instead of Cook.

Hopefully we have more Hinesight now

 

[pipeline]

Last year dermie was asked "who is or will be your favorite player at hawthorn,and he replied, i love watching Beau Muston,he will become a champion,i just love the way he goes about his footy"
Rumoured to win the rising star this year,muston is ready to explode on the AFL in 2008.
Nothing against stanley but i wished we picked up muston instead.

Hmmm, let's see - Hine vs Dermie, that's a hard one. Oh wait, no it's not - Hine by a mile.

Go Danny, stick it up 'em!

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Beau Muston would have been a Top 3 pick if not for his injury, and that is without any of the usual crap that is spunnby recruiters.

He is unbelievably talented, but he also came with the package of an extremely serious knee injury, and when he had to have a second bone graft in his knee after being drafted, few were questioning Collingwood's caution at that time. Likewise, if his knee goes again (hopefully it doesn't), nobody will be criticising Collingwood's recruiting. 2005 was a crucial year in our rebuilding process, and Muston represented a risk that we simply couldn't afford at the time.

Sure, if Muston is able to stay healthy, he will be a very good player for Hawthorn, but even they passed on him 4 times before eventually drafting him with their 5th pick in the 2005 draft.

It's too easy to take pot shots at recruiters when you're using the benefit of hindsight and ignoring the context in which the draft actually took place.

 

[JesusHcrikey]

Mick Malthouse actually came out in the papers a week before the draft and stated we would not be taking any players under injury clouds

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Mick Malthouse actually came out in the papers a week before the draft and stated we would not be taking any players under injury clouds

Rules are made to be broken.

We took Dawes the next year.

 

[zorbadunde]

yeah but its chrise Dawesome i mean come on

 

[itsacakewalk]

Beau Muston would have been a Top 3 pick if not for his injury, and that is without any of the usual crap that is spunnby recruiters.

He is unbelievably talented, but he also came with the package of an extremely serious knee injury, and when he had to have a second bone graft in his knee after being drafted, few were questioning Collingwood's caution at that time. Likewise, if his knee goes again (hopefully it doesn't), nobody will be criticising Collingwood's recruiting. 2005 was a crucial year in our rebuilding process, and Muston represented a risk that we simply couldn't afford at the time.

Sure, if Muston is able to stay healthy, he will be a very good player for Hawthorn, but even they passed on him 4 times before eventually drafting him with their 5th pick in the 2005 draft.

It's too easy to take pot shots at recruiters when you're using the benefit of hindsight and ignoring the context in which the draft actually took place.

D.Stanley the new D. Millane.