If it was me i would go option B at least you will have pavlich back next week and the rucks are hard to predict, probably have similar scores.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
DT Trading Discussion 2010 (Part 6)
- Thread starter BACCS
- Start date
- Tagged users None
If it was me i would go option B at least you will have pavlich back next week and the rucks are hard to predict, probably have similar scores.
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #629
I did Sandi to Cox
He's in form so it was worth a punt.
He's in form so it was worth a punt.
Rioli could have a big game against Freo B side, but will most likely score poorly the following week against the pies.
I would go waite has been scoring well except for the game against the pies couple weeks ago
I would think he would do bad against Geelong the same way he did bad against Collingwood though.
Im down to
Option 1: Pav -> Morton, Higgins to Roo, 0 trades left
Option 2: Higgins -> Thomas/Rockliff
Any last thoughts? Would help.
Thinking surely option 2 now.
If you choose option 2 thomas has been more consistent then rockliff
Cant believe I just did it but went Pav to Morton and Higgins to Riewoldt. Was against all my normal strategy but went with my last minute gut. Which is probably pure evil. Morton's playing us as well dont know why I did. Ah well could become my hero yet.
80% sure I will be regretting it come next week. At least next thursday.
But for now I can just enjoy having Roo
80% sure I will be regretting it come next week. At least next thursday.
But for now I can just enjoy having Roo
TedDougChris
🏆 🦍
- Mar 10, 2007
- 52,545
- 98,136
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Charlton Athletic, Roys FFC
Thanks mate, that's actually how I ended up trading....
Not convinced it's worth it and I may still end up losing tonight, but thanks anyway...
Noobz0r
Tom Jonas Fan Club Junior VP
- Aug 18, 2009
- 30,325
- 40,078
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Boy, being out of trades sure is a weird feeling!
stoja
Team Captain
yep sure is.. especially with pods set to miss
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #637
The 50 from Warnock just isn't good enough in a crunch prelim.
C'mon Big Coxy!!! Rip it up!!
C'mon Big Coxy!!! Rip it up!!
yep sure is.. especially with pods set to miss
I actually did Higgins to Pods today and it was looking pretty good. Would've been nice if he did something in the last quarter to make up for missing next week
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Fortunately I have Pav coming off the bench next week so I don't have to use my last trade on replacing Pods.
Cant believe I just did it but went Pav to Morton and Higgins to Riewoldt. Was against all my normal strategy but went with my last minute gut. Which is probably pure evil. Morton's playing us as well dont know why I did. Ah well could become my hero yet.
80% sure I will be regretting it come next week. At least next thursday.
But for now I can just enjoy having Roo
I Quite like these trades mate.
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Can afford any defender up to 378 to replace Josh Hunt. The question is, punt on Lake regaining form, or Gilbert, Scotland, Waite or other?
My situation is -
Sandi, Clark (Tippett, x)
JB, Pav, ROK, Pods (TDL, Lobbe)
Assuming ROK, Pav and Sandi play this week, i'm looking at trading Pods out and keeping Tippett as cover just in case Sandi is a late withdrawal.
I've narrowed it down to -
JRoo v Port at Etihad
BBBH v Ess at Etihad
Or anyone under 287,400?
Thoughts?
Sandi, Clark (Tippett, x)
JB, Pav, ROK, Pods (TDL, Lobbe)
Assuming ROK, Pav and Sandi play this week, i'm looking at trading Pods out and keeping Tippett as cover just in case Sandi is a late withdrawal.
I've narrowed it down to -
JRoo v Port at Etihad
BBBH v Ess at Etihad
Or anyone under 287,400?
Thoughts?
Pods playing against WCE and it's at the cattery. He should explode. (Obviously i know you're probably expecting him to be sidelined due to suspension [as i do too], but you should still wait in hope as umpires have been completely all over the place in terms of what is and what isn't suspendable. And geelong may try to argue it down so that he is available for the GF).
bombermick
Norm Smith Medallist
2 trades left and need to replace Mumford who will miss. Any ideas of how to replace him and hopefully improve the side. In the GF of a public league.
This is the side:
B-Gilbert, Duffield, Carrots, Waters, Russell, Stratton, Crameri (N.Brown, A. Moore)
Mids- Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Dal Santo, Murphy, Connors (Hardingham, McNeil)
F- D.Thomas, Dids, Douglas, Pav, Cloke, Roo, L.Jones (Dennis Lane, Griffiths)
Rucks- Mumford, Warnock (Stanley, Simpson)
Bit worried that Pav might miss again. Mumford missing makes it very difficult to upgrade anybody. I want to get Leunberger as he may have a field day against the Swans minus Mummy.
This is the side:
B-Gilbert, Duffield, Carrots, Waters, Russell, Stratton, Crameri (N.Brown, A. Moore)
Mids- Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Dal Santo, Murphy, Connors (Hardingham, McNeil)
F- D.Thomas, Dids, Douglas, Pav, Cloke, Roo, L.Jones (Dennis Lane, Griffiths)
Rucks- Mumford, Warnock (Stanley, Simpson)
Bit worried that Pav might miss again. Mumford missing makes it very difficult to upgrade anybody. I want to get Leunberger as he may have a field day against the Swans minus Mummy.
- Banned
- #647
Jolly will be taking on the Hawthorn ruck department which isn't that strong so maybe that's another option.
Me I'm waiting to see if Sandi comes back in before I make any decisions.
1 trade $ 38,000
Team
DEF: Goddard, Hodge, Gilbert, Enright, Gilbee, Malceski & Shaw (Strijk/Webberley)
MID: Swan, Ablett, Bartel, Monty, Pendles & Gibbs (Blair/Gysberts)
RUC: Sandi & Cox (Trengove/Macnamara)
FWD: Thomas, Goodes, Didak, ROK, Franklin, Rockliff & Riewoldt (Hitchcock/Playfair)
Now hopefully Sandi & ROK come back in and then I'll just make a luxury trade.
Possibly Shaw for Duffield or something similar.
No luxury trade now.
Didak prob has to be moved for someone, Chappy if you don't fear a late withdrawl
Ok My last trade
Didak to Chapman (means playing Nason as cover for hodge)
Hodge to Enright/Lake/Kelly (means playing ellard as cover for Didak)
Anyone have any ideas what to do here, This is what I have narrowed it down to.
Anyone care to give their thoughts to my situation?
Last trade, $4000 left with 3 players out: Podsiadly, Didak and Hodge. In the forwards I have cover with Fyfe and Hitchcock. In defense I have cover with Ashton Hams.
I'm thinking of benching Pods and Hodge (and using Hams and Fyfe to cover), and trading Didak since he has the most resale value. On the face of it, the most obvious player to bring in is Chapman. But as I posted in the Captains thread, in his last final game of the 2008 and 2009 Home and Away seasons, he's scored 49 and 47. Do you think he's likely to have his game time limited to ensure he's right for finals?
Is there a better option than the Chapman trade, by either trading for another forward, or trading Hodge in defense and covering for Didak with Hitchcock?
Let me know what your crystal ball says!
Last trade, $4000 left with 3 players out: Podsiadly, Didak and Hodge. In the forwards I have cover with Fyfe and Hitchcock. In defense I have cover with Ashton Hams.
I'm thinking of benching Pods and Hodge (and using Hams and Fyfe to cover), and trading Didak since he has the most resale value. On the face of it, the most obvious player to bring in is Chapman. But as I posted in the Captains thread, in his last final game of the 2008 and 2009 Home and Away seasons, he's scored 49 and 47. Do you think he's likely to have his game time limited to ensure he's right for finals?
Is there a better option than the Chapman trade, by either trading for another forward, or trading Hodge in defense and covering for Didak with Hitchcock?
Let me know what your crystal ball says!
Hey guys .. this is my team heading into round 22 grand final:
Now I have 2 trades left and $77,300 left in the bank
obvious choices would be to direct Swap Luke Hodge and Jonathon Brown
But to who?
Pav is back .. swap brown for Pav?
Hodge for who?
Any other suggestions for me to win my GF? Thanks peeps!
Now I have 2 trades left and $77,300 left in the bank
obvious choices would be to direct Swap Luke Hodge and Jonathon Brown
But to who?
Pav is back .. swap brown for Pav?
Hodge for who?
Any other suggestions for me to win my GF? Thanks peeps!
