Eddie

DJarman · Aug 22, 2003

http://afc.com.au/default.asp?pg=insidetheclub&spg=aroundtheclubdisplay&articleid=114661

"We believe an apology from Eddie would be appropriate, and perhaps some research of the facts before launching into a tirade of misinformation may serve him better in the future."

Might be a reason to watch the show next week

lozstar · Aug 22, 2003

Wouldn't that make it seem as though he didn't know the facts and was jumping to conclusions without researching it?

He wouldn't look professional..

An apology would be asking a tad too much.

Squeak · Aug 22, 2003

If Bruce had've said it, they wouldn't bother asking for an apology.

DJarman · Aug 22, 2003

Originally posted by Squeak
If Bruce had've said it, they wouldn't bother asking for an apology.

Yeah.............Bruce would say that

stmookeyj · Aug 22, 2003

They should not have that procedure of allocating tickets in the first place.

DJarman · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by stmookeyj
They should not have that procedure of allocating tickets in the first place.

Why do you say that?

500 seats is heaps.

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Eddie is just a pathetic, bitter, little man.

He even re-hashed the urine throwing allegations. Collingwood couldn't prove them at the time, and haven't proved them since. So why bring it up again?

By far the AFL's most unprofessional club president.

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by Squeak
If Bruce had've said it, they wouldn't bother asking for an apology.

Bruce wouldn't be stupid enough to heap that sort of crap on club and ground management without checking the facts.

sp-mac · Aug 23, 2003

By far the AFL's most effectivel club president. [/B]

typo corrected

Bomber Spirit · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by DaveW
By far the AFL's most unprofessional club president.

He does a very good job as Collingwood president. But he has no credibility as a serious football journalist.

MGREG · Aug 23, 2003

Typical sore loser response by Adelaide.

Who gives a toss about Adelaide anyway?

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by Bomber Spirit
He does a very good job as Collingwood president. But he has no credibility as a serious football journalist.

But that's what I mean. He uses his role as a journalist to push his political agenda as Collingwood president.

Perhaps that makes him more of an unprofessional journalist than president as you say... *shrugs* either way...

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by MGREG
Typical sore loser response by Adelaide.

Who gives a toss about Adelaide anyway?

Seeing as the Collingwood president never misses an opportunity to stick the knife in, I'd say the answer to that question is Eddie does.

DJarman · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by MGREG
Typical sore loser response by Adelaide.

Who gives a toss about Adelaide anyway?

What's wrong with standing up for yourself?

MGREG · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by DaveW
Seeing as the Collingwood president never misses an opportunity to stick the knife in, I'd say the answer to that question is Eddie does.

Wrong. He gave a toss about North, not Adelaide.

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by MGREG
Wrong. He gave a toss about North, not Adelaide.

Rubbish. He got stuck into the Adelaide Football Club and Football Park, including bringing up the aforementioned fictional incidents.

DJarman · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by MGREG
Wrong. He gave a toss about North, not Adelaide.

Why feel sorry for the Kangas? they are the ones who stuffed up.

sp-mac · Aug 23, 2003

Istill can't believe Eddie cops crap. I can see how he might get up the nose of opposition supporters with his passion, but unprofessional?

Here's the list of presidents- (well, who I know of anyway)

Adel: ?
Bris: ?
Carl: Collins
Coll: McGUIRE
Ess: McMahon
Fre ?
Geel: Costa
Haw: Dicker
Melb: Szondy
North: Aylett
Rich: Casey
StK: Buterss
Syd: Collis
WCE: ?
WB: Smorgan

Who of this list would you pick above McGuire if you were building/ rebuilding a football club? The staff appointments, sponsorships and on- field results have spoken for themselves.

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Yes sp-mac, being host of the Footy Show and Who Wants to be a Millionaire are the defining qualities of an excellent club president.

Now, who's in line to succeed McGuire? Ray Martyn or Don Burke?

Everyone knows who they are, so they fit your criteria for a good prez.

DJarman · Aug 23, 2003

Anyone think Ed will give the AFC a apology?

wagstaff · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by Squeak
If Bruce had've said it, they wouldn't bother asking for an apology.

Considering the audience difference between Bruce's and Ed's respective shows, the question to be asked is:

If Bruce had said it, would anyone have noticed?

sp-mac · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by DaveW
Yes sp-mac, being host of the Footy Show and Who Wants to be a Millionaire are the defining qualities of an excellent club president.

Now, who's in line to succeed McGuire? Ray Martyn or Don Burke?

Everyone knows who they are, so they fit your criteria for a good prez.

Who gives a crap what he does on telly? For the first time ever a Vic team has over 40, 000 members. We went from Spicers paper as a major sponsor to having Emirates and Essondons TAC deal fighting for the sole exposure. Eddie is a lifelong Collingwood supporter he didn't just pick em, the job isn't for money, we went from shaw to Malthouse, There has not been a major scandal at the club since he arrived.........Shall I go on???

But, if you say so I guess he's just overrated and unproffesional.

sp-mac · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by DJarman
Anyone think Ed will give the AFC a apology?

What did Ed say? Why does he have to apologise?

DaveW · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by sp-mac
Who gives a crap what he does on telly? For the first time ever a Vic team has over 40, 000 members. We went from Spicers paper as a major sponsor to having Emirates and Essondons TAC deal fighting for the sole exposure. Eddie is a lifelong Collingwood supporter he didn't just pick em, the job isn't for money, we went from shaw to Malthouse, There has not been a major scandal at the club since he arrived.........Shall I go on???

But, if you say so I guess he's just overrated and unproffesional.

I couldn't give a stuff what he does for Collingwood.

But the way he conducts himself in the media is nothing short of disgraceful.

DJarman · Aug 23, 2003

Originally posted by sp-mac
What did Ed say? Why does he have to apologise?

He said nothing wrong, Eddie doesn't make mistakes.

Seriously, I do have respect for him and what he has done but he has made a mistake here and I think he will apologise.

WBBL Season 10 - Oct '24 to Dec '25

Eddie

Debutant

Premiership Player

Norm Smith Medallist

Debutant

Brownlow Medallist

Debutant

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Debutant

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Debutant

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Debutant

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Debutant

Eddie

Log In or Create New Account