Competitions Essendon Board Superdraft 2011/12 - Selections Thread

[doug85]

Tom Hawkins

 

[timbo3195]

James Podsiadly

 

[SirJimi05]

Whomb why did you even bother playing when you already know exactly how the game works?

 

[Kong]

I got talked into it by tt, then remembered how much I hated it last time.

 

[Towno78]

I was after a prermier KPD of the competition, not a third tall.

Glass and McPharlin were the 2 best this year.

Every team needs atleast 1 gun key tall so people better get in quick.

Scarlett and Reid are surely ahead of McPharlin...

 

[table tennis]

I got talked into it by tt, then remembered how much I hated it last time.

Weak.....

 

[SirJimi05]

I got talked into it by tt, then remembered how much I hated it last time.

Hahah fair enough.

Scarlett and Reid are surely ahead of McPharlin...

You're not being serious are you? Scarlett didn't play KP at all this year. Half the time he took smalls like Andrew Welsh and the other half of the time he took the 3rd or 4th tall.

I don't think anybody that watched both players play could seriously argue that Scarlett was as good as McPharlin as a KPB this year.

Reid hardly ever took the oppositions best forward.

I'd personally say that the best KPD's this year were Glass = McPharlin > Reid > Gibson

I'd also have Bock, Taylor, Tarrant and Fisher well ahead of Scarlett.

 

[Towno78]

Hahah fair enough.



You're not being serious are you? Scarlett didn't play KP at all this year. Half the time he took smalls like Andrew Welsh and the other half of the time he took the 3rd or 4th tall.

I don't think anybody that watched both players play could seriously argue that Scarlett was as good as McPharlin as a KPB this year.

Reid hardly ever took the oppositions best forward.

I'd personally say that the best KPD's this year were Glass = McPharlin > Reid > Gibson

I'd also have Bock, Taylor, Tarrant and Fisher well ahead of Scarlett.

Fair enough, Bock was the other one I'd have up there with McPharlin... Care to take your pick while you're here?

 

[SirJimi05]

Paul Chapman

 

[SirJimi05]

Fair enough, Bock was the other one I'd have up there with McPharlin... Care to take your pick while you're here?

McPharlin is serially underrated. Absolute gun imo. Every time I watch Freo he beats the oppositions best forward whilst also offering some nice dash.

Pick taken.

 

[Rack Watts]

Seriously, is it any of your business to suggest players?

Rofl, if people are going to be uptight twats, i'm just not keen to play TBH.

 

[carmi99]

Heath Scotland

 

[Hepps]

Heath Scotland

?? Didn't you just take Kelly?

Tom Rockliff

 

[carmi99]

?? Didn't you just take Kelly?

Tom Rockliff

yeah i did. now im taking Scotland.

 

[Hepps]

My bad, just saw your name after Jade's...

 

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Rofl, if people are going to be uptight twats, i'm just not keen to play TBH.

Look mate my post on re-reading came across more seriously than I was intending. It would have probably been better to say "Shhhh. I want Harry!!!"

I'll have Michael Jamieson

 

[table tennis]

James frawley

 

[Towno78]

Ryan Griffen

 

[eth-dog]

Oh god. Um. I'm losing track. I won't play, being stupid. Can someone please update the list? We should pause the game until we find replacements for Jade and Whomb.

 

[doug85]

Yeah this is become a bit of a farce. If you put those players back into the draft at this stage it provides a massive advantage to anyone who has picks after you put them back in.

 

[SirJimi05]

Ethan why you making this so difficult, man?

Whomb and Jade are out. The players they picked are not avialable for selection. The game continues with 2 less players.

Is it really that difficult?

 

[Childish Gambino]

This is the updated list (new picks in bold). Let me know if I've made any errors.

Pick 1: AS9-Gary Ablett Jr.
Pick 2: mark_johnson#1-Lance Franklin
Pick 3: boncer34-Joel Selwood
Pick 4: Ricky-Scott Pendlebury
Pick 5: Towno78-Dane Swan
Pick 6: table tennis-Chris Judd
Pick 7: Mr. Mojo Risin-Travis Cloke
Pick 8: carmi99-Luke Hodge
Pick 9: jade_00-Aaron Sandilands
Pick 10: Hepps-Dean Cox
Pick 11: SirJimi05-Marc Murphy
Pick 12: timbo3195-Adam Goodes
Pick 13: Doug85-Matthew Scarlett
Pick 14: Whomb-James Bartel
Pick 15: bipolarbeaR-Nick Dal Santo
Pick 16: bipolarbeaR-Brendan Goddard
Pick 17: Whomb-Josh Kennedy
Pick 18: Doug85-Drew Petrie
Pick 19: timbo3195-Sam Mitchell
Pick 20: SirJimi05-Jack Riewoldt
Pick 21: Hepps-Steve Johnson
Pick 22: jade_00-Jobe Watson
Pick 23: carmi99-Darren Glass
Pick 24: Towno78-Barry Hall
Pick 25: Mr. Mojo Risin-Shane Mumford
Pick 26: table tennis-Andrew Swallow
Pick 27: Ricky-Corey Enright
Pick 28: boncer34-Darren Jolly
Pick 29: mark_johnson#1-Dale Thomas
Pick 30: AS9-Jonathon Brown
Pick 31: AS9-Todd Goldstein
Pick 32: mark_johnson#1-Matthew Boyd
Pick 33: boncer34-Matthew Pavlich
Pick 34: Ricky - Nic Naitanui
Pick 35: Towno78-Ben Reid
Pick 36: table tennis-Nathan Fyfe
Pick 37: Mr. Mojo Risin-Scott Thompson
Pick 38: carmi99-James Kelly
Pick 39: jade_00 Brett Deledio
Pick 40: Hepps-Dustin Fletcher
Pick 41: SirJimi05-Luke McPharlin
Pick 42: timbo3195-Sam Fisher
Pick 43: Doug85-Nathan Bock
Pick 44: Whomb-Harry Taylor
Pick 45: bipolarbeaR Cyril Rioli
Pick 46: bipolarbeaR Michael Hurley
Pick 47: Whomb-Trent Cotchin
Pick 48: Doug85 Tom Hawkins
Pick 49: timbo3195 James Podsiadly
Pick 50: SirJimi05 Paul Chapman
Pick 51: Hepps Tom Rockliff
Pick 52: jade_00
Pick 53: carmi99 Heath Scotland
Pick 54: Mr. Mojo Risin Michael Jamieson
Pick 55: table tennis James frawley
Pick 56: Towno78 Ryan Griffen
Pick 57: Ricky
Pick 58: boncer34
Pick 59: mark_johnson#1
Pick 60: AS9

jade_00's picks: Aaron Sandilands, Jobe Watson, Brett Deledio
Whomb's picks: James Bartel, Josh Kennedy, Harry Taylor, Trent Cotchin

 

[boncer34]

Ethan why you making this so difficult, man?

Whomb and Jade are out. The players they picked are not avialable for selection. The game continues with 2 less players.

Is it really that difficult?

Whilst this makes the most logical sense I disagree strongly because I could very well snag a gun player with my 4th pick.

 

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Ethan why you making this so difficult, man?

Whomb and Jade are out. The players they picked are not avialable for selection. The game continues with 2 less players.

Is it really that difficult?

Agree with this

 

[Kong]

OP is yours to edit, Mojo.