Review Ex Giants player watch

[BarryAglett]

Nick Haynes has had a shocker in his debut for Carlton tonight. I’m not sure he can hold his spot after this performance.

I felt a bit sorry for him. He wasn't alone, but he folded under pressure when he'd usually been so solid.

 

[Giant Strides]

I felt a bit sorry for him. He wasn't alone, but he folded under pressure when he'd usually been so solid.

I wish he had just retired at the end of last year. Would have ended his career as a Giants legend.

 

[JC100]

The really strange thing is that Blues fans seem surprised.

He has been cooked for years.

 

[orange tsunami]

Haynes was absolute cactus tonight, should’ve retired last year. He’ll definitely be out next week.

 

[Colonial]

I wish he had just retired at the end of last year. Would have ended his career as a Giants legend.

Still is but leaves a bad taste. Going in that one year too long.
Lloyd was able to leave on a high of finals and f/s games made.
Haynes, a legend, didn’t know when it was time.

 

[MelbourneGWS]

Whilst I cannot blame Haynes for taking the $, he would have retired as an inaugural one club Giant. I hope for his legacy that he turns it around at Carlton and becomes a regular starter there

 

[dlanod]

Still is but leaves a bad taste. Going in that one year too long.
Lloyd was able to leave on a high of finals and f/s games made.
Haynes, a legend, didn’t know when it was time.

IMO last year was a year too long.

And then Carlton still signed him...