Fact Or Fiction?

Remove this Banner Ad

danzan22 said:
Fact - buddy has shown this year that he has the skills to take on the chf position

F or F - will carlton make it a trio of spoons next year
Click to expand...

Fact: I really like Carlton but they have a terrible list!

Fact Or Fiction: Will Brett Deledio begin to dominate in the midfield next season?
 
Roughie said:
Fact: I really like Carlton but they have a terrible list!

Fact Or Fiction: Will Brett Deledio begin to dominate in the midfield next season?
Click to expand...

Fiction - wasnt the best midfeilder at richmond this year imo and will have to take a massive step up to become a dominant midfeilder

F or F - will collingwood make the 8 next year?
 
danzan22 said:
Fiction - wasnt the best midfeilder at richmond this year imo and will have to take a massive step up to become a dominant midfeilder

F or F - will collingwood make the 8 next year?
Click to expand...


Fact: They will not be as good next season as Rocca gets another year older, and Tarrant fails to take a grasp on a game.

Fact Or Fiction: Brisbane will finish bottom three next season?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Roughie said:
Fact: They will not be as good next season as Rocca gets another year older, and Tarrant fails to take a grasp on a game.

Fact Or Fiction: Brisbane will finish bottom three next season?
Click to expand...

Fact - with players leaving and no big talent coming through they will have to get use to losing

F or F - essendons 2000 team had the greatest season ever?
 
Fiction: Cannot be the greatest season in history when you cheat the salary cap.

F or F: Better mullet, Gary Ayers 1989 or 2006?
 
danzan22 said:
fact - proves the hawks are on the rise

F or F - chriss judd overated?
Click to expand...

Fact - No. Judd is one of the best ever, based only on his career to date. Judd on a switched-on day is very close to anyone who has ever played, and he has plenty of switched-on days.

Fact or Fiction? - Carlton would have remained an AFL powerhouse if John Elliot had never been President.
 
Mr.Likeable said:
Fact - No. Judd is one of the best ever, based only on his career to date. Judd on a switched-on day is very close to anyone who has ever played, and he has plenty of switched-on days.

Fact or Fiction? - Carlton would have remained an AFL powerhouse if John Elliot had never been President.
Click to expand...

fiction - the president cant help how talented the players are and how poor the list is, the coach needs to take responsibility for that

F or F - johnathon brown is the most intimidating player?
 
danzan22 said:
fiction - the president cant help how talented the players are and how poor the list is, the coach needs to take responsibility for that

F or F - johnathon brown is the most intimidating player?
Click to expand...

Fact - He would be the last person you would want to be backing into a pack knowing that he was bearing down and you wouldn't want to meet him pissed off in a dark alley!

F or F - Kane Petifer, Allan Didak and Leon Davis are the biggest germs in the AFL?
 
FatBoy's Wombats said:
Fact - He would be the last person you would want to be backing into a pack knowing that he was bearing down and you wouldn't want to meet him pissed off in a dark alley!
Click to expand...

Yeah especially not a dark alley in Thailand. I heard it was something other than a golden shower though.;)

F or F: After delaying the info on the Tassie Sponsorship deal by first releasing details on the 11 game MCG season could be seen as a attempt to butter the supporters up before the full news of the deal. Is there more Jeff is not telling us about Tassie?
 
blr_liquid said:
Yeah especially not a dark alley in Thailand. I heard it was something other than a golden shower though.;)

F or F: After delaying the info on the Tassie Sponsorship deal by first releasing details on the 11 game MCG season could be seen as a attempt to butter the supporters up before the full news of the deal. Is there more Jeff is not telling us about Tassie?
Click to expand...
Fiction: I doubt strongly that there is anything more to the Tassie deal. As he said we have just moved to Waverly and have arguably the best facilities in the country. That gets ignored a little when talking about us and Tassie, the fact we have just committed to the eastern suburbs. However we may not get 11 MCG games. 9 or 10 may be more realistic.

F or F: Mitchell will be our captain in 2007?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Did Parkin say something on WLF?

Edit: I love Richie but you'd think next year he'll be on the verge of selection but youngsters may put pressure on him. Surely it'd be better to avoid that pressure and make Mitchell our captain.
 
cschreuder61 said:
Fact: If we play at the MCG or Hawk (York) Park

Fiction: If we play at AS

F or F: Ellis will play 20 games next year
Click to expand...

fiction. id say about 15. providing he is injury free. we have to also bring muston into the side, i wouldnt want to see them both in our team at the same time next year. too young through the midfield, we dont need to do blood player quickly like we have needed to the last few years with roughie, buddy, young, lewis all in the same team at once

f or f; how good can someone like muston be after his injury. only asking because he was a runner and a great leap in the juniors. seems like this knee will restrict him too much to be quality
 
cschreuder61 said:
Did Parkin say something on WLF?

Edit: I love Richie but you'd think next year he'll be on the verge of selection but youngsters may put pressure on him. Surely it'd be better to avoid that pressure and make Mitchell our captain.
Click to expand...
Yeah,

He also said that he didn't expect us to play finals football next season - our window will open in 2008.
 
Fact: Muston can still become a champion. Judd seems to have no issues running through packs and marking after his shoulder problems early on.

F or F: Jonathon Hay comes back in a direct swap for Zac Dawson? (Please don't hate me)
 
Fact: Roughead is most definately suited as a power forward. Once he is allowed to settle and understand his role in the side will become a handful with his size and long arms. It'll make our forward line that much more dangerous with Franklin and Williams roaming around with Roughead a solid unit in the goal square who would need a decent backman consistently.

F or F: Crawford will play for three more years min.
 
cschreuder61 said:
Fact: Roughead is most definately suited as a power forward. Once he is allowed to settle and understand his role in the side will become a handful with his size and long arms. It'll make our forward line that much more dangerous with Franklin and Williams roaming around with Roughead a solid unit in the goal square who would need a decent backman consistently.

F or F: Crawford will play for three more years min.
Click to expand...

Fact:Did you guys see Crawfs last 6 games?

Fact or Fiction:Will Hawthorn gain Brett Thornton during trade week?
 
Fiction; The Hawks will instead opt to persevere with some of their younger players, ie Brennan, Miller, in the hopes that they can have breakout years.

Fact or Fiction; Clarkson has the coaching abilities [Not list] to win a premiership?
 
Hugshawks said:
Fiction; The Hawks will instead opt to persevere with some of their younger players, ie Brennan, Miller, in the hopes that they can have breakout years.

Fact or Fiction; Clarkson has the coaching abilities [Not list] to win a premiership?
Click to expand...


Fiction: I say fiction because he is still new in the coaching buisness, he has yet to make a move that has really changed a game. But with experience comes better tactics and decisions, and we will see over the next few seasons the improvement of our list, and our coaching staff.

Fact Or Fiction:Westcoast will win the 2006 grandfinal?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Fact Or Fiction?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top