Opinion Favourite 5 Bombers of all time

[Private Hudson]

Peter Cransberg
Shawn Lewfatt
Matthew Banks
Rob Forster - Knight
Dwayne Armstrong

 

[The King!]

favourite

Simon Madden
Tim watson
paul salmon
peter van der harr
james hird

 

[The House]

1. Corey McGrath
2. Daniel McAlister
3. Mark Bolton
4. Henry Slattery
5. Courtney Johns

 

[The House]

the top 5 i've seen play in my short 21 year lifetime would be...

1. Hird - absolute legend of the club and game... will never forget the winning goal he kicked against west coast in 2004.

2. Fletcher - i honestly think he can break the club games record, he just doesnt slow down... would love to see him win one last premiership aswell.

3. Lloyd - sadend by the fact he didnt reach 1000 goals, 2005-07 injuries certainly didn't help, he was the last great proper full forward.

4. Ryder - He is soooo god damn reliable and flexible from Ruck to forward, can even play great defence.

5. J. Watson - He will be a great Captain, i rekon he will be the next bomber to lift the Premiership Cup.

Mine is actually very similar (even though i'm in my early 30's).

1. Hird - no contest.
2. Fletcher
3. Lloyd
4. Tim Watson
5. can't split Jobe Watson and Simon Madden.....no doubts Madden was the better player (so far) but i respect and enjoy watching Jobe a hell of a lot also.

Ps, for those who want to see the best EVER finals game by a ruckman, check out Madden in the '85 grand final - just unbelievable.

 

[rainman06]

1. James Hird
2. Matthew Lloyd
3. Mark Mercuri
4. Dustin Fletcher
5. Michael Long

 

[Catfish Alley]

I admire guys like Coleman and Reynolds but of the ones I've seen:

1. Hird
2. Madden
3. Wanganeen
4. Salmon
5. Lloyd

Apologies to Bewick, Long, T Watson, Misiti and Fletcher.

 

[Macca18]

1. James Hird
2. Dustin Fletcher
3. Matthew Lloyd
4. Darren Bewick
5. Jobe Watson

 

[napoleonsolo88]

1.D.Bewick
2.M.Lloyd
3.D.Bewick
4.M.Lloyd
5.D.Bewick/M.Lloyd

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

1.D.Bewick
2.M.Lloyd
3.D.Bewick
4.M.Lloyd
5.D.Bewick/M.Lloyd

LOL, you got any Salmon?!

 

[abers47]

Hird, Neagle, Lloyd, Solomon, Pears

 

[Zakk Wylde]

Wanganeen
Bewick
Hardwick
Thompson
Hird

 

[andon]

James Hird
Jack Clark
Scott Lucas
Dustin Fletcher
Tim Watson.......equal.....Jobe Watson....