Opinion Favourite 5 Cats of all time

[The Catt]

Gary Ablett
Joel Selwood
Jimmy Bartel
Garry Hocking
Polly Farmer

 

[muttweed]

1. Mooney
2. Bartel
3. Enright
4. Kelly
5. Whiskers

 

[Vitruvian]

1. Garry Hocking
2. Gary Ablett, Sr.
3. Jimmy Bartel
4. Cameron Ling
5. Max Rooke

 

[Natho]

1. Jimmmmmy
2. Chapman
3. Ronnie
4. Kelly
5. H.Taylor

 

[HappyChappy35]

1. Paul Chapman
2. Gary Ablett Snr.
3. Jimmy Bartel
4. Billy Brownless
5. Paul Couch

 

[rimdog]

Exell
Breuer
Tanner
Handley
Drum

Honerable mentions to Jacko, Malakellis, Sean Simpson and Tudor

 

[efyfseo123]

1. Billy Brownless
2. Ronnie
3. Enright
4. Ablett Jnr.
5. Bill Brownless

Foot Comfort

 

[RedmanWasHere]

01, Joel Selwood.
02, Fos.
03, Frothies Brownless.
04, Brad Sholl.
05, Paul Corrigan.

 

[Butts_JZZ30]

My top 5 in no order. I thought I'd throw in Bruce Lindner, I reckon a very good underated player, only played 60 odd games with the Cats though, but watching footage love the way he played.

-Linder (as above, lovely mark and nice kick a true footballer)
-Bartel (once again a footballers footballer, lovely classical player)
-Ablett Snr (The most natural talented player to play in the VFL/AFL on his day incredible)
-Matthew Scarlett (superb full back just brilliant, his reading of the play is exceptional and loyal to the absolute core)
-Brad Ottens (possibly an odd selection but I think hugely underated in his important to the Cats recent flags, dominant big man who I thought made Geelong a fantastic rather than a great side....the key ingredient they couldnt cover)

 

[Bundy_28]

I like Johnson, he's so underrated for what he produces in goal assists and scoring opportunities for Geelong every single week and his influence on matches cannot be questioned. I have him up there with best I have seen.
Buddha Hocking was awesome but Bartel has gone past him now and Selwood will end up surpassing him as well.
If Gary Jnr was still a Cat, he'd be number 2 or 3.

1. Ablett snr
2. Johnson
3. Scarlett
4. Selwood
5. Bartel

 

[pacman]

Gaz Jnr
Andrew Bews
Arron Lord
Kent Kingsley
Leigh Colbert

 

[MightyMark]

Gaz Jnr
Andrew Bews
Arron Lord
Kent Kingsley
Leigh Colbert

What about Michael Mansfield and John Barnes?