Vintage Bay FINALISTS - worst youngster in the AFL 2009

[Grandmaster_B]

Well the nominations are in, and it has come down to 5 of the biggest young potatoes in the AFL.

Make your pick.

Nick Naitanui - pick 2 in the National draft , yet cant kick, mark or bounce a football. Staggering lack of skill, is nothing but a project ruckman that should have gone late in the rookie/PSD draft or not been drafted at all.

Chris Yarran - most unskilled Aboriginal player in the comp, besides Oakley-Nichols

Tom Swift - looks like a girl, plays like a girl. There were question marks when he was drafted, and they have been vindicated.

Mitch Robinson - absolute plonker, the less said the better. Also a gutless thug who hits people behind the play.

Phil Davis - top 10 pick, but does anyone even know what he looks like or what position he plays?

EDIT - The Jack Watts option should not be there, and was added in by a manipulative moderator.

Votes for Watts will not be counted.

That's stumps


Scorecard

Nick Naitanui 37
Chris Yarran 153 Not Out
Tom Swift 16
Mitch Robinson 36
Phil Davis 18
Jack Watts 562 Not Out

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Melbourne poster elects himself queen of the poll thread in a desperate attempt to stop Naomi Watts actually winning something

 

[maryjames]

None of above. Jack Who is not there.

 

[Mentallo]

Jack Watts.

Lock the thread.

 

[Grandmaster_B]

None of above. Jack Who is not there.

Probably cos he is the best natural footballer to be drafted since the draft was introduced.

Now concentrate on the five potatoes please.

 

[Johanpetro]

Why the hell isnt Jack Watts on the list?

 

[Johanpetro]

Probably cos he is the best natural footballer to be drafted since the draft was introduced.

Now concentrate on the five potatoes please.

I was actually thinking all your previous posts have been serious, all be it deluded, but now i see your just mucking around and trying to get a rise out of everyone. You had me going for a bit.

 

[fryingpan]

How can Phil Davis be the worst youngster when he hasn't debuted yet? He is next in the pecking order to get into our team but can't beak in simply because our defence is solid enough as it is.

 

[Play by Numbers]

Jack Watts

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Looks like a moderator added Jack Watts to the poll, and manipulated the voting.


Pathetic effort.

 

[Crimson King]

Jack Watts.

/Thread.

 

[kerrazy]

BAHAHA WATTS IS SHIT! Notice G_B the moment you create the poll, everyone wants to select Jack boy? I wonder why?

 

[Ant_]

Looks like a moderator added Jack Watts to the poll, and manipulated the voting.


Pathetic effort.

Jack was added however there has been no vote manipulation.

 

[maryjames]

Probably cos he is the best natural footballer to be drafted since the draft was introduced.

Now concentrate on the five potatoes please.

Yep I just locked in my vote, the sixth potato.

 

[fryingpan]

Looks like a moderator added Jack Watts to the poll, and manipulated the voting.


Pathetic effort.

Almost as pathetic as having a go at teenagers that have played less than 10 games

 

[Mentallo]

15 mins into this post i am calling it.
The posters on Big Footy have spoken.

Congratulations Jack Watts!!!

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Jack was added however there has been no vote manipulation.

It is complete manipulation because he doesn't belong in the poll at all.


And people will now vote for him out of spite.

Pathetic to ruin a proper poll like that.

 

[wambat]

I think Hack Watts would win the 'Worst Young Player In The VFL Award'... PS - Where is the Cale 'Junk Time' Morton option?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

It is complete manipulation because he doesn't belong in the poll at all.


And people will now vote for him our of spite.

Pathetic to ruin a proper poll like that.

He got mentioned enough times in the other thread.

On what basis have you decided that Naitanui and Swift deserve to be in the poll, but no Melbourne youngsters do?

 

[Eagle 8]

It is complete manipulation because he doesn't belong in the poll at all.


And people will now vote for him out of spite.

Pathetic to ruin a proper poll like that.

Your right

should he be even classed as an AFL player?

 

[rjslcM]

Pathetic threads are becoming a trend of yours, Grandmaster_B.

Targeting the kids of the AFL, who have had limited opportunities to prove themselves, is a cowardly act.

- Naitanui looks to be a genuine star, regarless of the ignorant crap you write.
- Yarran will become a handy player down the track.
- Haven't actually watched Swift or Davis, no opinion on them.
- Robinson gives 110%, good on him.
- Watts will become a very good player. Has shown areas he needs to improve on but I believe he will end up the second-best of these players, with Naitanui the best.

If we are purely judging on their AFL performances so far and NOT their overall potential, Watts has shown the least ability.

 

[tcwaters]

At the moment, Watts is 23 votes ahead of the next person.

Says it all really.. Worst #1 pick of all time.

 

[Crimson King]

64.29% for Watts.

Take note, Melbourne flogs.

 

[Ant_]

It is complete manipulation because he doesn't belong in the poll at all.


And people will now vote for him out of spite.

Pathetic to ruin a proper poll like that.

If you wanted proper, you could've made it a public poll so everyone could see who voted for who.

 

[Mentallo]

And people will now vote for him out of spite.

No.
He is just shit.