Universal Love Footy Related Things we are still cranky about -

Remove this Banner Ad

Our decade or more of terrible drafting.

Edit: Oh man, I just went back to check my facts on Blaine Blokeblurst who in my mind personifies this period of draft/list mismanagement, and I'm angry again.

The 2014 trade period and national draft is truly the nadir of Carlton as a football club. Check out our utter squandering of draft assets, wasting of picks... in a draft where if you completely randomized the 80-odd players drafted, we should have hit on a good player or two. By my count we've had a go of 11 (****ing ELEVEN) of the players taken in this draft, at a cost of god knows how many draft picks, and have got maybe 2.5 AFL players out of it. Who, by the way, are not ones we drafted, but ones we had to buy off someone else. Meanwhile, the list of current day stars pulled early and late in this draft is extensive.

I need a lie down.

Second Edit: nothing personal against Blaine. Kudos to anyone who makes it to the top level, even for 1 game. Not his fault we were a rabble.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Getting rid of Mark Porter to get Mick McGuane. Thanks Pagan.

OK seems I needed this therapy 😀
 
The missed free kick to Andrew Walker in the final at Subi v Wet Toast back in 2013.
I've never watched the replay but there was a moment in the 2nd quarter when we were well on top where we had a west coast player holding the ball inside our 50 dead cold. Our players stopped on the assumption the umpire was definitely going to pay the free but he called play on. The whisked the ball down the ground in seconds a kicked a goal. Then they kicked a few quick goals in succession.
 
The worst free kick I’ve ever seen, Round 23 2022.
4th quarter, Jack Silvagni is pushed in the back, and gets a free paid against him, after Cripps has taken a mark to have an easy set shot at goal when we’re well on top. Lose and miss finals by 1 point.
That was the one. JSOS was shoved and copped a free kick against.. unbelievable.
 
Fev being triple teamed when on 99 goals, when Buddy already kicked his 100, had the Coleman sewn up and the game was won.

Ginni(?) putting an illegal block on Saad that allowed Elliot to kick the winning goal and keep us out of finals.

Walker's missed free in front of goals vs WC in the 2011 SF.

Walker not winning mark of the year.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes that Walker mark that wasn't the best but has been used in so many AFL promotions stuff since.
It's funny, I think I've seen that Walker mark hundreds of times
over the last 13 years on TV, yet Andrew Krakouer's
winning mark never gets shown.
Walker's mark is truely one of the greatest marks ever taken,
regardless that we barrack for the blues.
It's a travesty that wasn't given 'MOTY' in 2011.
 
Knifing Ratten and signing that con artist Malthouse - that was my personal low point - came very close to saying 'yeah nah' about Carlton and switching to my 'home' team Sydney - still angry about it actually.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Knifing Ratten and signing that con artist Malthouse - that was my personal low point - came very close to saying 'yeah nah' about Carlton and switching to my 'home' team Sydney - still angry about it actually.
My recently deceased mad Carlton supporter Dad hated Malthouse more than anything in this world. He reckoned Mcguire orchestrated it to send Carlton belly up...He almost did.

Yep this one still shits me.
 
Yes if I remember correctly we rested Greg Williams for the last match of the round with a "cold." We lost that match and gave up top spot.

On the other hand I came across for the semi final vs Crows and Madden's "run" still makes me grin.
You don't remember correctly. We beat an awful Sydney by 1 point when we needed to win by 4-5 goals to guarantee top spot.

Lost to non-finalist Essendon to miss top spot in 1994, which still irritates me.

Should've finished top three years in a row.
 
Jason Johnson hit on Kouta.
Kouta was absolutely unstoppable before then.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Universal Love Footy Related Things we are still cranky about -

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top