Fourth best CHF in the AFL

[Farrand]

Originally posted by Kapow!!!
umm...no!

Come on! He was the soul of our team.

 

[Schneiderman]

Ben Graham?

 

[skipper kelly]

Who I would prefer in my team

1. Hall
2. Brown
3. Reiwoldt
4. Terdrea

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

Originally posted by skipper kelly
Who I would prefer in my team

1. Hall
2. Brown
3. Reiwoldt
4. Terdrea

Although i agree with Hall but tredrea 4th is just plain wrong!

 

[melbournemartin]

Tredrae
Hall
Riedwoldt
Brown on this years form

 

[Jako]

Originally posted by melbournemartin
Tredrae
Hall
Riedwoldt
Brown on this years form

agreed

 

[xfactor23]

Chris Judd would be up there if he played CHF

 

[Thrawn]

Originally posted by dave_27
Riewoldt then probably Lucas and Rocca.

Rocca? Whitnall this year has and will be better than Rocca, on a bad year where he wouldn't break the top five, let alone perhaps the top 8. A pity too... had the football world at his feet in 2000.

 

[ClintEastwood]

Originally posted by skipper kelly
Who I would prefer in my team

1. Hall
2. Brown
3. Reiwoldt
4. Terdrea

Of course you are entitled to an opinion, but just a few stats, to inject a little objectivity:

     Name          Goals  
60-----------------------



    Tredrea/Hall  53
50-----------------------




40-----------------------

     Riewoldt      37


30-----------------------



     Brown         23
20-----------------------

That's just considering goals. Tredrea was number 1 in the comp last year for goal assists. The same stat for this season so far is not available to my knowledge.

Take your pick.

Brown and Riewoldt probably have more "presence" than Tredrea, and are probably more exciting to watch. And we all know that presence and excitement kick goals, right.