Golden Rivers FL

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
bernard the bipolar bear said:
Ordinary policy rejecting clearances. Everyone gets cleared eventually these days, unless contracted or owing money. All you are doing is leaving a bad taste in players mouths and reducing the chances of them returning.
Click to expand...
ordinary policy you think bernard that advice comes from years of experience organising what team was it ?on past eperience clearing lauchy bott,troy+matt coates ,luke treacy ,shawn mckenzie,greg dickson to name a few with out a fight hasn't seen them return any quicker,maybe wandella trying a different policy?
 
ruddi zarsoff said:
ordinary policy you think bernard that advice comes from years of experience organising what team was it ?on past eperience clearing lauchy bott,troy+matt coates ,luke treacy ,shawn mckenzie,greg dickson to name a few with out a fight hasn't seen them return any quicker,maybe wandella trying a different policy?
Click to expand...

If those players don't want to play at your club, why should they be made to? And why would they come back when they know they cannot ever leave? You cannot force loyalty.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

bernard the bipolar bear said:
If those players don't want to play at your club, why should they be made to? And why would they come back when they know they cannot ever leave? You cannot force loyalty.
Click to expand...
Agree that fighting for a players loyalty or trying to force them too stay is a futile exercise, but there are many more reasons why clearances are initially rejected..
i would suggest that in the majority of cases the former club is just looking for the chance to talk it over with the player is question, if they give them that curtesy and then still want to leave, then i would say 99.9% would get there clearance!!
 
Have to agree with you Sockit. Common cuortesy to talk with "your" club and let them know of your intentions rather than just have a clearence shoved in your face without a valid reason. If we dont fight for our own players we all might end up in a prediciment that Quamby, Wakool and Hay find themselves in.
 
bigtube said:
Have to agree with you Sockit. Common cuortesy to talk with "your" club and let them know of your intentions rather than just have a clearence shoved in your face without a valid reason. If we dont fight for our own players we all might end up in a prediciment that Quamby, Wakool and Hay find themselves in.
Click to expand...

I think you will find that "the players" in question at "the club" made their intentions quite clear early. Training with another club up to two months prior to the first clearence being sumbitted is a pretty good indication of what a "player" intends to do.
You would think that a "club" would be proactive in contacting the player in those months prior to the first submission and not after two or three clearances are knocked back.
 
Beez Kneez said:
I think you will find that "the players" in question at "the club" made their intentions quite clear early. Training with another club up to two months prior to the first clearence being sumbitted is a pretty good indication of what a "player" intends to do.
You would think that a "club" would be proactive in contacting the player in those months prior to the first submission and not after two or three clearances are knocked back.
Click to expand...

I think you'll will find that these players in question were contacted by club and club made its intentions clear early as well?What we are all losing site of here is that golden rivers clubs can't be used as breading ground for so called major league clubs or many more teams will struggle for numbers as wakool hay and quamby are at the present.
 
ruddi zarsoff said:
I think you'll will find that these players in question were contacted by club and club made its intentions clear early as well?What we are all losing site of here is that golden rivers clubs can't be used as breading ground for so called major league clubs or many more teams will struggle for numbers as wakool hay and quamby are at the present.
Click to expand...

Sick of this club stuff, so lets talk about who we are actually talking about.
So from what i have read....
Wandella by the sounds don't like their players going into kerang, it takes too long for them to come back.... and if they don't come back they will be like quamby, hay and wakool?
So Kerang players never go out to Wandella?
and Wandella don't pay players?
 
Looking at the draw and see that Moula take on Murrabit 1st up at Murrabit, surely Moula would be looking to get a couple of pracci matches in before hand! Not only for fitness but getting the new team to gel! Any news from the moula boys on this??
 
TEE-R-OTTER said:
Sick of this club stuff, so lets talk about who we are actually talking about.
So from what i have read....
Wandella by the sounds don't like their players going into kerang, it takes too long for them to come back.... and if they don't come back they will be like quamby, hay and wakool?
So Kerang players never go out to Wandella?
and Wandella don't pay players?
Click to expand...

you have pritty much worked it out all by yourself tee r otter execpt that wandella would pay players as every club does but the hole point is that clubs have to pay more and more players to replace the ones taken which can't be good for there futures could it?
 
I've got nothing against young guys wanting to go to a higher standard of footy to test themselves against better opposition, although I don't think CMFL is much of a step up might be better having a crack at BFL, GVFL, etc. Older guys coming to the end of there footy are the guys you would like to see a bit more loyalty from.

I think this players moving from GRFL to CMFL goes both ways though. Alot of GRFL kids will go and play in CMFL for a few years to try and better there footy and a lot of border line seniors and older guys from CMFL end up in the GRFL to get more opportunities at senior level. I think Wandella and Kerang, Macorna and Cohuna, Swan Hill clubs and Murrabit, Ultima, Nully and Quamby and Wakool with Deni and Barham have been swaping players for years, sometimes they leave, sometimes they come it just depends on the year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

roosta07 said:
For anyone that is interested, Josh Logan kicked 6 for Geelong Amateurs in the GFL but in the 2's...
Click to expand...

Roosta for your info Amateurs play BFL. 2's again?? That club is stuffed, for the world of me can't understand why he wouldn't get a game in the ones. I know most of the players there and he's better than a lot of them unless they've picked up a heap.
 
Roughhead said:
Looking at the draw and see that Moula take on Murrabit 1st up at Murrabit, surely Moula would be looking to get a couple of pracci matches in before hand! Not only for fitness but getting the new team to gel! Any news from the moula boys on this??
Click to expand...

Good call with Moula surely wanting atleast 2 praccos in before season starts. From what i've heard though nothing is organised.
 
ruddi zarsoff said:
you have pritty much worked it out all by yourself tee r otter execpt that wandella would pay players as every club does but the hole point is that clubs have to pay more and more players to replace the ones taken which can't be good for there futures could it?
Click to expand...

Im pretty sure everyone agrees the money going around isnt beneficial for any club. finding funds can be hard. so where do you reckon wandella will finish rudi? they would still make finals wouldnt they?
 
The Messenger said:
I've got nothing against young guys wanting to go to a higher standard of footy to test themselves against better opposition, although I don't think CMFL is much of a step up might be better having a crack at BFL, GVFL, etc. Older guys coming to the end of there footy are the guys you would like to see a bit more loyalty from.

I think this players moving from GRFL to CMFL goes both ways though. Alot of GRFL kids will go and play in CMFL for a few years to try and better there footy and a lot of border line seniors and older guys from CMFL end up in the GRFL to get more opportunities at senior level. I think Wandella and Kerang, Macorna and Cohuna, Swan Hill clubs and Murrabit, Ultima, Nully and Quamby and Wakool with Deni and Barham have been swaping players for years, sometimes they leave, sometimes they come it just depends on the year.
Click to expand...
Good call there messenger. Alot of cmfl players that come to grfl are either borderline players that slot into a grfl side nicely, or an older player in the twilight of there career still with smarts to match it in the grfl. Better quality cmfl players that come to the grfl are usually playing coaches or on good dollars!
 
brewery fresh said:
Im pretty sure everyone agrees the money going around isnt beneficial for any club. finding funds can be hard. so where do you reckon wandella will finish rudi? they would still make finals wouldnt they?
Click to expand...

don't know, would like to see them make finals but at what cost if every club has to keep paying lots of player just to survive what is the point ,all you would do is make footballers richer and small communitys suffer? members , supporters would soon get jack of that wouldn't they?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top