Review Good, Acceptable, and Putrid vs Kitty Kats

[spexau]

Coaching our forwards and they are an absolute rabble. He is a terrible, terrible coach

Roger. Agreed. Symptom of our inflexible players imo. Cameron was the glue

 

[Scorpus]

We back in the boys to the end of the earth. They dish up complacent, soft efforts knowing their place in the team is locked in.

We get what we ****ing deserve.

 

[spexau]

Although I agree we weren't great. If Brad nails that goal and we win. A lot of different opinions here. We kicked ourselves out of it imo.

 

[Rotayjay]

Seedsman possible ACL to top it off.

Season is shot and club is shot until some drastic changes happen.

We though these changes might have occurred despite the retention of personnel, but this year is almost certain to be the same as 2018, if not worse.

 

[Scorpus]

Although I agree we weren't great. If Brad nails that goal and we win. A lot of different opinions here. We kicked ourselves out of it imo.

You mustn't have seen the disgusting football we played between those misses. DISGUSTING football.

Club is a shambles right now. This squad is just about done

 

[PAFC_1870]

Although I agree we weren't great. If Brad nails that goal and we win. A lot of different opinions here. We kicked ourselves out of it imo.

100% that was huge.

Just weird after that.

 

[Cleric]

Our premiership window has closed. Back to another couple of decades of 6th to 10th finishes.

 

[mattymac]

All our assistant coaches were picked up from cheap as chips.

Ben Hart has pineapple banged our forward line.

Betts can't kick a goal to save his life.

Dmac back to his 12 disposal standard.

Worst of all that fraud Chapman is still running the scam so nothing will change.

Also the Ogilvie handjobs that get given out around here are unwarranted. Consistently recruits players with no composure. In fact we don't have a single composed player on the list. Maybe Milera, but he chose us.

 

[Dewy006]

I was under the impression Gibbs was a very good user of the football when he came over from Carlton, jeez was I mislead...

 

[Drummond]

Bryce Gibbs lol. Collecting his pay check, nothing more.

Dave Mackay lol, his usual 13 touches tonight.

So good.

 

[CH Jazz]

Went exactly how it was always going to go. Tex is a disgrace.

 

[jackster83]

The good:

I called the result, the exact margin, our forward line being the problem AND Rohan kicking multiple goals against us.

 

[Mike Smyth]

We finally had a handful of 1st round picks and in a super draft. Did we blow it?

 

[pjcrows]

Ben Hart can get ******

On pure stats volume and Inside 50s, we should not be having a lot of difficulty scoring. There is no consistency or synergy whatsoever. Random goals from random things. Sando style.

 

[mulz]

Josh ****in Jenkins. Putrid

 

[CrowBloke]

Re: Thread title ---

Good --- not much that I can think of. Hard to get excited about 1 decent quarter.
Acceptable --- nothing that I can think of, seriously.
Putrid --- yes PUTRID. Also weak, insipid, ineffective, fumbly, indecisive, poor positioning, lousy delivery to F50 and so much more.

 

[thebirdman 24]

Good
Tex, Sloane and Betts lifted in that third quarter. Shame they didn't rock up for the other 3.
ROB showed signs around the ground.
Smith tried as did Sloane.
Really struggling to think of more.

Bad - Where to begin?
Gibbs was absolutely pathetic. Jogging towards goal after a 50 metre penaltt then hoofs it 40 metres to noone. His kick in stuff was garbage too.
Dmac is back to the norm after a outlier of a game last week.
Murphy and Knight need to do more
Jenkins mostly invisible
Kelly is a hack and I have been saying it since 2016. Ever game he manages to give away a free when we have a 2 on 1 in our favour. He is such an awful kick as well he is petrified of going forwards so ruins all of our momentum in attacks.
Hartigan was useless and players bounced off him.
Talia continues to leak goals.
I have had the opinion for a while now that Laird is average. He racks it up but his disposal is rubbish and he makes critical decision making errors. He showed that he is a rookie pick tonight.
Milera quiet again.

 

[diligaf473]

Kelly absolutely putrid.

Him and Gibbs competing for the worst kicks in the AFL

 

[kulak]

Bryce Gibbs

27 disposals
8 contested
63 percent efficiency (11 turnovers)
9 pressure acts (our other kids were around 20)

He gets numbers, but what does he contribute? He doesn’t win contests, he doesn’t use the ball well, and he doesn’t apply pressure.

Needs a spell to decide how committed he is.

 

[Crowked]

Our tackling was embarrassing, as usual.

God I hate Geelong, Dangerfield, Selwood and Ablett. Shitest blokes in football.

 

[Scorpus]

Tom Lynch - Senior player. 26 touches at 57% DE. 2 goals, 3 behinds.

Brad Crouch - Senior player. Misses the match winner from point blank

Bryce Gibbs - Senior player. 63% DE playing out of the contest. 6 clangers and 11 turnovers

Eddie Betts - Senior player. 0 goals, 1 behind.

Rory Atkins - Approaching 100 games. 12 touches

David Mackay - Senior player. 13 touches with 3 turnovers

Taylor Walker - Senior player. 1 Joe the Goose goal and a miss

Josh Jenkins - Senior player. 1 goal 1 behind.

Rory Laird - Senior player. 1 touch in the first quarter.

Our SENIOR PLAYERS are costing us.

They have the biggest gold passes in the AFL and this is what they dish up. It's DISGUSTING

 

[ltdamn]

Good: B Crouch, Keath
Acceptable: M Crouch, Sloane
Putrid: Jenkins. Must be dropped for someone who will attack the ball from in front. Even Walker has realised this.

 

[diligaf473]

Pyke is Neil Mk2

 

[jackster83]

How many times can you back yourself before it becomes apparent that you've run out of ideas?

We all know how this is going to end. Campo will end up caretaker coach again at some point.

 

[ShadeyP]

See Gary and Gary laughing at Hartigan who bodied himself out of the contest ... f..k we have some thick as shit players in our team