Competition Goose's Rate the Opposition MVP

[GWS Goose]

Its back!
After Callums_Guns did his best to ruin this fine competition it became clear I needed to bring it back!

The concept is simple. All players are entitled to vote and rate the opposition's contribution to the thread in the classic 3, 2, 1 format. At the end of the round the votes will be tallied up and consolidated into a consensus vote.
For a matter of simplification. Essentially if 5 players from a team vote, those votes will be totaled with the poster with the most combined votes getting 3, second most 2 and third highest the 1.
I m adding a new aspect to this and that is I'd like voters to also vote on the thread. Give it a score 1 to 5 as well.

I'd appreciate people getting involved by posting there votes each week. The more voters the more reflective this is of the views of the SFA.

 

[DenieD]

Vs Ophidian Old Boys FFC

3- Tigerturbulance
2- Bonz
1- Mobbs

Thread total = 4.5/5

 

[GWS Goose]

Vs The Oldboys

3. Mobbs
2. Tigerturbulance
1. Bonz

They have assembled a good list and were good fun. Thread 4 out of 5

 

[Tigerturbulance]

3 DenieD (was a maniac poster, but wore me down and grew on me)
2 Falconista (kept me company on a couple of lonely nights)
1 The Foolback (great first up appearance for a rookie, gumbies have got a good one here)

Thread total = 4

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Vs Bears

3. Electronic_Renaissance
2. Broken
1. Senor M

Thread - 3.5

 

[Chipmunk]

Vs Roys

3: Zevon
2: Elmer_Judd
1: Kabanna

Thread: 3

 

[nahnah]

Vs Bears

3. Broken
2. Cap
1. Electronic_Renaissance

Thread: 3/5

 

[Agent93]

Vs Bombers

3. Robertio
2. Kilroy
1. Jabba73

Thread: 12/20

 

[damicky]

Wonders vs Dragons

3 Votes: T2B_
2 Votes: Strigoi
0.5 Votes: DragoDelph
0.5 Votes: Braklet

MIA: serial_thrilla

Thread 3.75/ 5

 

[Falconista]

vs OOB:
3. Tigerturbulance
2. Mobbs
1. Mrs Turbo
Overall: an enjoyable thread that didn't stall. 4/5

 

[thewizardmelon]

Vs Roys Round 1

Zevon
Elmer_Judd
TedDougChris

 

[por_please_ya]

vs Roys Rd 1

3. Zevon
2. Wosh
1. TedDougChris

Thread 4/5

 

[GWS Goose]

Vs Roys Round 1

Zevon
Elmer_Judd
TedDougChris

Is that 3 for Zevon and 1 for TedDougChris

 

[damicky]

Is that 3 for Zevon and 1 for TedDougChris

Surely it couldn't be 3 for TDC

 

[Tonga Bob]

Babylon

3) Robertio
2) Sun Ra
1) Jabba73
another 1) CursingFijian because I'm a captain and I'm allowed to give extra votes

HM's to Ava, Killa, BAT, the pug & Ligma for convincing Willie Nelson to come out of retirement.

Overall: 3.75/5

 

[Robertio]

V- Warriors
3. Tonga Bob
2. Dinsdale
1. Agent93
Thread 3-5/5

 

[GWS Goose]

We have votes from 8 teams, we require votes from the remaining 4.
We are on the right track.

 

[Sun Ra]

Babylon

3) Robertio
2) Sun Ra
1) Jabba73
another 1) CursingFijian because I'm a captain and I'm allowed to give extra votes

HM's to Ava, Killa, BAT, the pug & Ligma for convincing Willie Nelson to come out of retirement.

Overall: 3.75/5

Babylon ?

 

[Robertio]

Babylon ?

Just another name for superteam mate.

 

[Sun Ra]

Once Were Warriors

3. panskyle
2. Dinsdale
1. Mesc

Apologies to TongaBob and Agent93

Thread 2.1/5

 

[T2B_]

vs Wet Toast Wonders

3. Brenton Davy
2. damicky
1. AnUltimateRessie

Thread 3/5

 

[Tonga Bob]

We have votes from 8 teams, we require votes from the remaining 4.
We are on the right track.

We lost a team already? NO MORE BYES!!

 

[Tonga Bob]

Once Were Warriors

3. panskyle
2. Dinsdale
1. Mesc

Apologies to TongaBob and Agent93

Thread 2.1/5

Cook me some eggs.

 

[Agent93]

We lost a team already? NO MORE BYES!!

Clearly no-one cares about that team.

 

[sante]

Swampies

3 - Firestarter - poor bloke is stuck in a back pocket
2 - ShaunDuggan
1 - philreich