![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/western_sydney.png)
- Apr 12, 2012
- 47,750
- 44,748
- AFL Club
- GWS
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
How do you know he’s peaked? Probably had his most damaging year this year, can’t see why he can’t do the same next year, or even better it.If I were GWS I’d look to cash in. He turns 28 in a couple of weeks. He’s peaked, and he’s clearly not going to learn. The pressure of finals gets to him and he can’t handle it and lashes out.
There’d be clubs out there who’d pay a decent price for him.
You really really want him at the Bombers eh?If I were GWS I’d look to cash in. He turns 28 in a couple of weeks. He’s peaked, and he’s clearly not going to learn. The pressure of finals gets to him and he can’t handle it and lashes out.
There’d be clubs out there who’d pay a decent price for him.
He's their heart & soul, and by far their best player.
Sure he's missed 2 finals through suspension, but he's kicked 20 goals in 11 finals, and been in the top handful of GWS players on 6 or 7 occasions. He would have helped in the semi final, but without him they don't make finals, let alone win the Elim final. He's quite comfortably the best medium forward in the game.
Stringer will be 28 early next season, he's just had a massive spike year, should Essendon cash in? After all, he doesn't really perform in finals, he's peaked.
He's their heart & soul, and by far their best player.
Sure he's missed 2 finals through suspension, but he's kicked 20 goals in 11 finals, and been in the top handful of GWS players on 6 or 7 occasions. He would have helped in the semi final, but without him they don't make finals, let alone win the Elim final. He's quite comfortably the best medium forward in the game.
Stringer will be 28 early next season, he's just had a massive spike year, should Essendon cash in? After all, he doesn't really perform in finals, he's peaked.
Mumford? Farking lolHe's not our best player, nor our heart and soul. Kelly is our best player and Kennedy is our heart and soul.
To be honest, I blame the club more than I blame Toby. We've let Mumford get away with with his idiotic behaviour and dumb acts for years without consequences, so it's no surprise that Toby makes dumb mistakes with role models like Mumford around. We've only got ourselves to blame.
You are not wrong he has peaked… As one of the top few players in the game. The Giants are only going as far as he will take themIf I were GWS I’d look to cash in. He turns 28 in a couple of weeks. He’s peaked, and he’s clearly not going to learn. The pressure of finals gets to him and he can’t handle it and lashes out.
There’d be clubs out there who’d pay a decent price for him.
Good example, it’s actually pretty much exactly what the Dogs did with Stringer.
Worked out well for club and player, I doubt either regret the move.
You are not wrong he has peaked… As one of the top few players in the game. The Giants are only going as far as he will take them
It isn't at all...That’s a ridiculous statement.
You really really want him at the Bombers eh?
Look I understand and it is an interesting way you have written up a thread about our star player and we should want him gone, wow, but no. Ain’t happening.
He's not our best player, nor our heart and soul. Kelly is our best player and Kennedy is our heart and soul.
To be honest, I blame the club more than I blame Toby. We've let Mumford get away with with his idiotic behaviour and dumb acts for years without consequences, so it's no surprise that Toby makes dumb mistakes with role models like Mumford around. We've only got ourselves to blame.
So surely the Bombers take this jump in trade value and run with Stringer?
He's going to be falling by the time McGrath, Cox, Perkins, Reid, Durham, this year's first etc all peak, so surely taking this peak Stringer form and trading him makes sense?
No, Stringer doesn’t have issues which see him constantly being suspended for finals.
If he did, sure.
No it isnt.That’s a ridiculous statement.
Would love King. Would not trade Greene for him.Alternatively, GWS might consider a swap for Ben King.
I would.
The problem might be getting GC to agree.