Hawthorn - Fantasy, Dreamteam, Supercoach etc discussion - please keep it all in this thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Highly likely. Don't know if Duryea and Wanganeen can play in the same side. Depends on form I guess but he should at least be able to jag half a dozen games this year. He's probably the type we would use as a sub though.

what was wanganeens form like in the vfl over the past few season? Does his last pre-season game surprise you, or is it a sign of things to come in the next few season?
 
what was wanganeens form like in the vfl over the past few season? Does his last pre-season game surprise you, or is it a sign of things to come in the next few season?

Some say his VFL finals performance saved his career... I'm not so sure but he would have been close to cut. So certainly a surprise from my point of view. That said, a lot of these fringe players have all had various injury problems over their time on the list so probably didn't get a fair run at it.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

If Langdon does play in a tagging role, how do you see him scoring compared to Suckling? If you predict a minor difference, I think it's worth saving the copious amounts of dough and picking Langdon.
 
If Langdon does play in a tagging role, how do you see him scoring compared to Suckling? If you predict a minor difference, I think it's worth saving the copious amounts of dough and picking Langdon.

I wouldn't bank on 100's from Langford, but as I just mentioned Suckling could be a risky pick early in the season.
 
Liam Sheils. Is this his breakout year?

Just came in here to enquire about this bloke.

It's absolutely ridiculous the hype around Suckling considering Shiels is a similar price.

My only query is whether he will have tagging duties & as already answered, if Langdon tags then it's a win win ...

Fingers crossed this stays under wraps & every bloke and their dog goes the Suckling route :cool:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just came in here to enquire about this bloke.

It's absolutely ridiculous the hype around Suckling considering Shiels is a similar price.

My only query is whether he will have tagging duties & as already answered, if Langdon tags then it's a win win ...

Fingers crossed this stays under wraps & every bloke and their dog goes the Suckling route :cool:

I've covered most of this in other posts, but in summary;

- Suckling might need time to find his feet. Don't expect him to roll out tons straight away.
- Langford is the reason Shiels is on the ball. Don't pick Shiels unless Langford is named.
- Langford looms as the most likely of the inexperienced players to break into the senior side.
 
Hawks fans my finger is hovering over the Select SC button for young Liam? After proving dangerous offensively in the NAB will he be permanently let off the leash or was Clarko just letting him have a bit of summer fun? Personally, I would like Sewell to get the lock-down roles but doubt he has the tank? Sewell was getting caught with the ball regularly vs North.

If young Langford can nail a run with tagging roll, Sewell's spot may be more at risk from Shiels than Hallahan?

Thoughts?
 
Hawks fans my finger is hovering over the Select SC button for young Liam? After proving dangerous offensively in the NAB will he be permanently let off the leash or was Clarko just letting him have a bit of summer fun? Personally, I would like Sewell to get the lock-down roles but doubt he has the tank? Sewell was getting caught with the ball regularly vs North.

If young Langford can nail a run with tagging roll, Sewell's spot may be more at risk from Shiels than Hallahan?

Thoughts?

It's hard to tell, it might depend on who we play. Sewell will probably be managed at times during the year where shiels should take his role, but this won't be the case all year round.
What's shiels' price? How much money are you looking to spend?
 
Hi Guys

I'm interested to know the players who are cemented in the Back 6.
Does this look right if all players are available?

B: Stratton Lake Gibbo
HB: Suckling Shoey Birchall


SC have the following listed as DEF:
Mitchell, Hodge, Birchall, Burgoyne, Lake, Suckling, Schoey, Gibbo, Stratton, Duryea, Langford

Was Mitchell put back in defence last year, due to management or Sucklings ACL?
If so, Mitchell may get more time back in the midfield?

I know Schoey has a minor injury, but when he returns, does he go back with Gibbo playing 3rd tall or go forward?
Does Schoey's position affect where Hodge plays?
 
It's hard to tell, it might depend on who we play. Sewell will probably be managed at times during the year where shiels should take his role, but this won't be the case all year round.
What's shiels' price? How much money are you looking to spend?

Shiels is $331k and I have managed to slot him in at M7 meaning I only need to find 3 midfield rookies which is easier said than done atm as apart from Polec and Ellis none of the cheaper options have knocked down the door.
 
Hi Guys

I'm interested to know the players who are cemented in the Back 6.
Does this look right if all players are available?

B: Stratton Lake Gibbo
HB: Suckling Shoey Birchall


SC have the following listed as DEF:
Mitchell, Hodge, Birchall, Burgoyne, Lake, Suckling, Schoey, Gibbo, Stratton, Duryea, Langford

Was Mitchell put back in defence last year, due to management or Sucklings ACL?
If so, Mitchell may get more time back in the midfield?

I know Schoey has a minor injury, but when he returns, does he go back with Gibbo playing 3rd tall or go forward?
Does Schoey's position affect where Hodge plays?

The only Hawk defender I would choose for SC is Mitchell. A proven scorer who gets plenty of the ball. He will probably spend time across half-back again this year, due to management like you said.

Suckling will probably be eased back in after his ACL, most likely as the sub. Would not pick.
Birchall can often be the target of a tag which restricts his output.

I think Schoey has the potential to play at both ends of the ground, depends on where we need him. I'm guessing Hodge plays mainly midfield/half-back this year, similar to Mitchell.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top