20th. Luke Jackson
Which Vic club does he play for?
I concur with your sentiment. You can't fault Butters. But Gulden's kicking, running, versatility, etc. just make him a better player for me.
JUH doesn't deserve to be in that high but I understand Talls take longer. I feel like they are adding potential with his selection while not doing it for others.
Hasnt Butters been rated pretty high in the AFL ratings for damage with ball in hand. He was certainly rated #4 from rounds 16 onwards when David King provided the stats.
Presumably has to be based on performance to date otherwise it's a fairly meaningless exercise. If so, then the Dees premier players Pickett and Jackson are too low for mine, as is Weightman who has been very strong in a good side.
Serong has to be top 3 without debate.
Nah up until the mid year point of this year I would have agreed but once Sheezel got moved into the midfield/Half-Forward role he had in the second half of the season he showed he could do so much more than just cherry picking as a loose defender. North basically weren't able to score unless he got involved.
