Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[Jabso]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads



Everyone laugh I did this as quick as I could.

 

[bizz42]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

I'd absolutely love a hand here guys, I haven't done this comp before so I'm willing to absorb absolutely any nuggets of wisdom thrown my way.
My Team:
BACKS:
Goddard
C. Cornes
Raines
Croad
Waters
J. Walker
Koschitske
Boyle
Riggio

CENTRES:
Dal Santo
Hodge
Cooney
P. Burgoyne
M. Murphy
N. Lappin
Gibbs
J. Selwood

RUCKS:
Cox
Sandilands
C. Cloke
Renouf

FORWARDS:
Hall
Pavlich
Fevola
Monfries
N. G. Brown
Franklin
Tredrea
Al. Davey
Edwards

Thanks for any help guys.

 

[travo420]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

Back C.Cornes PTA
A.Walker CAR
Birchall HAW
X.Clarke STK
Kozi STK
Hunter WCE
J.Walker Fre
Boyle HAW
Ellis HAW

Centre
Judd WCE
Griffen WBD
Foley RICH
Thomson PTA
Goodes SYD
Montagna STK
Selwood GEE
Gibbs CAR

Ruck
Cox WCE
Hudson ADL
Darcy WBD
Cloke CAR

Forward
Brown BRI
Fevola CAR
Aka WBD
Pavlich FRE
Murphy WBD
N.Brown RICH
Campbell KAN
Hawkins GEE
Davey ESS

*** Still may have Goddard instead of Cornes***

 

[travo420]

Chad Cornes, or B Goddard?????

 

[DanA]

Chad Cornes, or B Goddard?????

Chad Cornes has been a champion for years and probably missed a few cheap kicks last year because they tried him up forward. Goddard had his first good year.

Cornes easily

 

[cougarman]

1st year in the herald sun super coach and was wondering what others think of my side

BACKS
J Bowden
C Cornes
L Gilbee
A Mcleod
A Walker
J Koschitkze
L Hansen
X Ellis
T Boyle

CENTRES
C Judd
S Goodwin
S Burgoyne
N Dal Santo
N Lappin
B Gibbs
R Hadley
B Houli

RUCKS

J Fraser
L Darcy
M Bailey
P Ryder

FORWARDS

M Pavlich
W Tredrea
B Fevola
G Ablett
N Brown
L Franklin
J Kennedy
T Hawkins
Al Davey

 

[Silky]

Im pretty happy with my team at the moment with my weakness being my backline, i would appreciate a few responses on this backline:

C. Cornes
Adcock
C. Bolton
McPhee
Birchall
B. Jones
Koschitzke

Alternatively, i could have johncock who i think is a good points accumulator in supercoach (disp efficiency, groundball gets) instead of C Cornes and Mundy instead of C Bolton. Should i make this change or keep the backline as it is?

Cheers fellas

 

[Therussian]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

get on Heath grundy guys,

he's put on 4 kgs and is flying

a steal!!

 

[Buckley is ripped]

Can anybody tell me where can you find out each clubs rookie list promotions??? and the senior lists ???

 

[AndyD]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

 

[travo420]

Re: Advice

Looking to finish up my back line tossing up the last few possies in my super coach team:

C.Cornes (PTA) or Goddard (STK)

and

X.Clarke (STK) or Waters (WCE)

 

[juddy_Like]

RUCKS

J Fraser
L Darcy
M Bailey
P Ryder

Get rid of Bailey. He wont be playing a game this year. Knee Reco.
And i have grave concerns about Ryder. A year too soon IMO. But it seems to me you have picked the top 2 from every position bar the rucks.

 

[juddy_Like]

C. Cornes
Adcock
C. Bolton
McPhee
Birchall
B. Jones
Koschitzke

If youv got the extra 30K, invest in Hayden instead of B.Jones. I would seriously doubt weather BroJo would play 14+ games this year.

Hayden is the unearthed talent IMO.

 

[Kildonan]

Re: Advice

Looking to finish up my back line tossing up the last few possies in my super coach team:

C.Cornes (PTA) or Goddard (STK)

and

X.Clarke (STK) or Waters (WCE)

I would go Chad and Xavier

 

[Nath]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

Guys, give us some feedback. If I fiddle with this thing one more time - never happy

Backs
1. Jesse Smith (BAC)
2. Xavier Ellis (BAC)
3. Chad Cornes (BAC)
4. Lachlan Hansen (BAC)
5. Hustin Koschitzke (BAC)
6. Graham Johncock (BAC)
7. Adam McPhee (BAC)
8. Andrew Walker (BAC)
9. Daniel Bell (BAC)

Centres
10. Beau Muston (CTR)
11. Lindsay Thomas (CTR)
12. Ryan Griffen (CTR)
13. David Rodan (CTR)
14. Simon Black (CTR)
15. Chris Judd (CTR)
16. Scott Thompson (CTR)
17. Luke Hodge (CTR)

Backs
18. Brent Renouf (RUC)
19. Jon Griffin (RUC)
20. Josh Fraser (RUC)
21. Peter Everitt (RUC)

Forwards
22. Aaron Edwards (FWD)
23. Matt Campbell (FWD)
24. Andrew Embley (FWD)
25. Alwyn Davey (FWD)
26. Barry Hall (FWD)
27. Brad Johnson (FWD)
28. Matt Pavlich (FWD)
29. Brett Burton (FWD)
30. Nathan Brown (FWD)

 

[magpies03]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

Backs:
Chad Cornes
Gilbee
Mcmahon
Birchill
Wirrapunda
Solomon
Hanson

Riggio
Ellis

Centers
Goodes
Hodge
Griffen
Foley
Lappin
Kerr

Gibbs
Selwood

Rucks
Cox
Sandilands

Rix
Hudson

Forwards
Pavlich
Okeefe
Yze
Brown
Pattisson
Koz****zke (bagging my own player lol)
Monfries

Alwin Davey
Hawkins

43400 left over to spend

Thoughts?

 

[borgy]

Copeland, Waters or Clarke?

If youv got the extra 30K, invest in Hayden instead of B.Jones. I would seriously doubt weather BroJo would play 14+ games this year.

Hayden is the unearthed talent IMO.

How many games do you expect Hayden to play?

 

[borgy]

Copeland, Waters or Clarke anyone?

Gee this thread is dead!!!

 

[Scruba]

Copeland, Waters or Clarke anyone?

Gee this thread is dead!!!

Waters

 

[AndyD]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

Backs:
Chad Cornes
Gilbee
Mcmahon
Birchill
Wirrapunda
Solomon
Hanson

Riggio
Ellis

Centers
Goodes
Hodge
Griffen
Foley
Lappin
Kerr

Gibbs
Selwood

Rucks
Cox
Sandilands

Rix
Hudson

Forwards
Pavlich
Okeefe
Yze
Brown
Pattisson
Koz****zke (bagging my own player lol)
Monfries

Alwin Davey
Hawkins

43400 left over to spend

Thoughts?

Yze for Fev

 

[goal sneak]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

BACKS
C.Cornes
McPhee
A.Walker
A.Raines
X.Clarke
Polak
Kosi

Boyle
Ellis

CENTRES
Judd
Kerr
M.Murphy
Wells
Tambling
N.Lappin

Gibbs
Selwood

RUCKS
Sandilands
Ottens

Hudson
Ryder

FORWARDS
Hall
Pavlich
O'Keefe
Fevola
N.Brown
Frankilin
Betts

A.Edwards
Al.Davey

 

[T-I-G-E-R-M-A-N]

ok fellas need a bit of help lol umm bryce gibbs,david rodan,andrew browne or beau muston who do u think... cheers

 

[T-I-G-E-R-M-A-N]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

hey boys and girls.. ive mentioned my side about 4 times lol just want 2 get peoples thoughts on my side.. dont care if is good or bad

Backs
A.Raines
P.Bowden
T.Kennelly
L.Mcpharlin
G.Birchall
J.Brennan
C.Johnson

T.Boyle
M.Riggio

Centre
S.West
D.Harris
K.Simpson
N.Foley
S.Thompson
N.Jones

M.Priddis
D.Rodan

Ruck
H.Mcintosh
B.Hudson

C.Cloke
Griffin

Forward
M.Pavlich
B.Ottens
B.Johnson
A.Mcdougall
G.Ablett
A.Monfries
B.Fevola

A.Edwards
Alwyn Davey

110,600 left over

 

[T-I-G-E-R-M-A-N]

Copeland, Waters or Clarke?


How many games do you expect Hayden to play?

Hayden is playing good footy borgy... i reckon for the first 8 rounds he will go alright. Either him or C.Johnson melb lol dont no which1

 

[SJ]

Re: Merged "Rate My Supercoach Team" Threads

Backs:
Chad Cornes
Gilbee
Mcmahon
Birchill
Wirrapunda
Solomon
Hanson

Riggio
Ellis

Centers
Goodes
Hodge
Griffen
Foley
Lappin
Kerr

Gibbs
Selwood

Rucks
Cox
Sandilands

Rix
Hudson

Forwards
Pavlich
Okeefe
Yze
Brown
Pattisson
Koz****zke (bagging my own player lol)
Monfries

Alwin Davey
Hawkins

43400 left over to spend

Thoughts?

Don't use Hawkins, won't play for a fair while.