Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008: Part 2

[burnsda]

Erm what round did i win again?

i have the best supercoach team i got 2000 with out a captain or a vice captain

 

[Jukes]

Did anyone see how mitch farmer went? tossing up between him, salter and vespremi for a downgrade.

who do u guys reckon will play out the season????

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

Did anyone see how mitch farmer went? tossing up between him, salter and vespremi for a downgrade.

who do u guys reckon will play out the season????

Reckon Vespi's the go. Scored 95 last week with 1 goal 4 behinds. Farmer 64, and Salter 45.

 

[foxy_dal]

Looking at Sammy Fisher as a possible replacement for Shaw. Wow he has some goood consistancy. his last 5 or 6 weeks have all produced over 90 i think.

 

[foxy_dal]

Reckon Vespi's the go. Scored 95 last week with 1 goal 4 behinds. Farmer 64, and Salter 45.

Veszpremi looks good but i don't know how he will go holding his spot in the team. Maric is more likely to hold his spot i think and the 2 port boys look alright as well.

 

[hellfire]

I'm going to use one trade on Shaw to Johncock.

Can someone help me out with the second, and last trade I have:

Should I go Goodes to Hodge now, or hold on to the trade until the GF (given I have Chapman and Burgoyne too)?

Or I can wait on the Goodes->Hodge trade, but Hodge is only going up in value, and if Goodes plays and gets injured again... he will drop, and I won't be able to afford Hodge.

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

Veszpremi looks good but i don't know how he will go holding his spot in the team. Maric is more likely to hold his spot i think and the 2 port boys look alright as well.

Yeah fair call Foxy. Just noticed Moore and Malceski to come back in this week. Surely they would give vespi a few weeks but.

 

[Jukes]

Yeah, that's why I was leaning towards M.Farmer...likely to hold his place with all of Port's outs.

Anyone know where I can get the time on ground stats from the weekend?

 

[Biggie]

I call this supercoach carnage.

Or panic.

 

[Oct19]

I call this supercoach carnage.

Or panic.

Do I detect a hint of schadenfreude Big Man?

Not too many would have been hit with the dids / shaw double like me, risk mamangment for the rest of the season, my precious ranking will probably plummet.

 

[Mick_15]

Yeah, that's why I was leaning towards M.Farmer...likely to hold his place with all of Port's outs.

Anyone know where I can get the time on ground stats from the weekend?

didn't he get a week?

 

[Hawkmad]

didn't he get a week?

Your thinking of the wrong Farmer he is talking about Mitch Farmer from Port Adelaide

 

[Judd_Magic]

Help!!!!!!

Here is my dilemma.

Backline reads -

Mattner, Newman, Bradshaw, Stiffy, Taylor, Womaeamerri, Lower

Bench - C.Cornes, H.Shaw


Forward line reads -

Franklin, J.Brown, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Johnson, Valenti, Tippet

Bench - Chapman, Porpliza



I have one trade left. What is the best option?


Should I trade C.Cornes for Mcleod or someone else (not sure who)

or

Should I trade Porpliza for either Harding or Monfries (don't like any of these options to be honest)

If Tippet comes back I was thinking of maybe playing with him as my 7th forward and then waiting the week after to get Barry Hall as he is forecast for a $7,000 price drop and then I could do a straight swap from Porps to Hall.

I hopefully will have Chappy back the week after as I have the double chance.


Where is my trade best used, forward or back? Really need alot of opinions on this one as its killing me. I have $29,800 in the bank too.

Cheers!

 

[Salisbury]

Help!!!!!!

Here is my dilemma.



I have one trade left. What is the best option?


Cheers!

A stiff drink. If that doesn't work, pray to the footy gods.

 

[MrChristo]

Yeah, that's why I was leaning towards M.Farmer...likely to hold his place with all of Port's outs.

Anyone know where I can get the time on ground stats from the weekend?

Salter got whacked behind the ears in a marking contest in the second quarter...
...spent the entire second half off the ground.

Looks very likely to put up some decent numbers (he's a thumping kick, and accurate...good mark...very solid lad!)...IF he plays this week tho.

Farmer was good too. Played most of the game. (Sorry, just threw Monday's paper out! )

 

[_hyphy]

Going to upgrade Priddis this weekend, but can't work out who out of Hodge, Kirk, Cooney, Corey or Judd to get. I'm leaning towards Kirk/Hodge, Kirk's cheaper and with the Swans fighting for a top 4 spot he always delivers when needed. However Hodge has a fairly easy run home, but his run with injuries/suspensions worry me.

Any thoughts?

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Can afford to trade Shaw for any backman. Currently have:
Newman, Gilbee, Shaw, Johncock, Birchall, Ibbotson, Head (McKenzie & Proud).

Am leaning towards Fisher, but my options are:
Fisher (ave: 97.67) $490k
Waite (ave: 97.71) $485k
Pratt (ave: 97.06) $475k
Goddard (ave: 95.44) $463k
Gram (ave: 87.11) $445k
Bradshaw (ave: 93.25) $432k

Who should I take?
EDIT: Actually, I forgot Joel Bowden (ave: 104) $557k

 

[shiny_on_top]

Can someone please help me???
Who should i go for
A) Cooney with about 70K in the bank, with the risk he may be dropped
B) Kirk with little in the bank
C) Dal Santo, ditto with Kirk
D) Someone else under 525000

 

[deasend]

Can afford to trade Shaw for any backman. Currently have:
Newman, Gilbee, Shaw, Johncock, Birchall, Ibbotson, Head (McKenzie & Proud).

Am leaning towards Fisher, but my options are:
Fisher (ave: 97.67) $490k
Waite (ave: 97.71) $485k
Pratt (ave: 97.06) $475k
Goddard (ave: 95.44) $463k
Gram (ave: 87.11) $445k
Bradshaw (ave: 93.25) $432k

Who should I take?
EDIT: Actually, I forgot Joel Bowden (ave: 104) $557k

With the run the Tigers have coming home, I'd grab Bowden.
In terms of value for money (depending how many trades/cash you have left) Fisher or Bradshaw the pick of the rest.

 

[sens]

Can afford to trade Shaw for any backman. Currently have:
Newman, Gilbee, Shaw, Johncock, Birchall, Ibbotson, Head (McKenzie & Proud).

Am leaning towards Fisher, but my options are:
Fisher (ave: 97.67) $490k
Waite (ave: 97.71) $485k
Pratt (ave: 97.06) $475k
Goddard (ave: 95.44) $463k
Gram (ave: 87.11) $445k
Bradshaw (ave: 93.25) $432k

Who should I take?
EDIT: Actually, I forgot Joel Bowden (ave: 104) $557k

I'd get Fisher. Has been ultra consistent compared to other backmen this year.

 

[sblack]

Help!!!!!!

Here is my dilemma.




Where is my trade best used, forward or back? Really need alot of opinions on this one as its killing me. I have $29,800 in the bank too.

Cheers!

Give up...start 2009.

 

[Itsblackandwhite]

Can someone please help me???
Who should i go for
A) Cooney with about 70K in the bank, with the risk he may be dropped
B) Kirk with little in the bank
C) Dal Santo, ditto with Kirk
D) Someone else under 525000

Cross is another option if you want consistency in your mids.
Judd's an option

Cooney looks outa form
Kirk's had 3 bad games now
Dal Santo is up and down (though he plays the pies saturday..biggie coming up)


Any chance you could make that 525k --> 536k and get Hodge ?
or 526k for Corey ?

 

[Itsblackandwhite]

Going to upgrade Priddis this weekend, but can't work out who out of Hodge, Kirk, Cooney, Corey or Judd to get. I'm leaning towards Kirk/Hodge, Kirk's cheaper and with the Swans fighting for a top 4 spot he always delivers when needed. However Hodge has a fairly easy run home, but his run with injuries/suspensions worry me.

Any thoughts?

In this world where Johncock gets dropped, Chapman gets injured twice in a year, Captain Ablett Brownlow favourite rolls on his own ankle, Didak and Shaw - get suspended for the whole season together and Carlton beats Collingwood twice in the same year - I wont worry too much about Hodge's "injury/suspension" record - Get him he's on a roll

 

[Itsblackandwhite]

OK my dilemna now - Shaw and Didak out - Iv just about had enough for the year - so for my final 2 trades - Which combination would you take for a back and a forward respectively ?

Waite/Newman & Murphy/Aker

Goddard & Murphy/Aker/Hall/Mcpharlin

Roughead/Mcdonald (if back) & All of the above/Brad Johnson

Birchall/Welsh(Playing midfield) & All of the above/Roughy/SJ/Gian

Mcleod & Deledio/Richo/Waite

Moran & Pav/Lloyd/N Brown

Current Backs
Shaw, Johncock, Osborne, Thornton, Bradshaw, Kennelly, Bock (SDT,Hans)
Current Forwards
Didak, Chapman, Mooney, O Keefe, Buddy, Fevola, Rioli (Valenti,Tippet)

All help appreciated.

 

[Biggie]

Mcleod and Deledio

OR

Murphy/Goddard

My favs from that bunch.