Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[Syd Kennets]

Great stuff Walesy.

Is it possible to get a run through of how to work out the break evens for this week?

Edit: looks like i just need to register, I'll give it a go.

 

[Walesy]

Great stuff Walesy.

Is it possible to get a run through of how to work out the break evens for this week?

um... what do you mean? log in, find your player, look at the column that reads "break even"...



Or are you trying too steal the formula. ??

(There's a formula posted on DT Talk... not the same as I use, but fairly close.)

 

[Windas_Magic]

walesy, is tht site all ur own work?, its f****** unbelievable, where do u get the time? r u sum cpu genius, lol. it will definatly cum in handy during the week.

im thinking(its only monday dont forget)....symes out - osbourne in

fev?? i dont know why i shoce him....mayb coz im a carlton supporter. its hurts, mayb he mite get the boot for....franklin or Thompson/dew/bradshaw(money)

s.johnson...keep(melbourne this week)
stanton.....will go down in price alot if plays poorly again, but i hav faith in him as i know essendon will cum good, and for them 2 cum good he has 2 cum good

Why does this sound so disturbing?

 

[Syd Kennets]

um... what do you mean? log in, find your player, look at the column that reads "break even"...



Or are you trying too steal the formula. ??

(There's a formula posted on DT Talk... not the same as I use, but fairly close.)

It's cool, i just hadnt created a log in, so the options were limited.

Though i am getting that crazy error message a few others have posted.

 

[hellfire]

For those of you planning to trade out Stanton, who are you looking at? I honestly can't see too much value around his price.

 

[Walesy]

It's cool, i just hadnt created a log in, so the options were limited.

Though i am getting that crazy error message a few others have posted.

oh noes!! I hates that error... I have no idea what causes it.

 

[Windas_Magic]

For those of you planning to trade out Stanton, who are you looking at? I honestly can't see too much value around his price.

I for one am sticking with Stants but if you want to trade him away then you might look at guys like Priddis or Murphy (if you don't already have them).

 

[Windas_Magic]

Stuck with who i should start on the ground. Jetta or Gamble? I'm leaning towards Gamble atm

 

[Walesy]

Stuck with who i should start on the ground. Jetta or Gamble? I'm leaning towards Gamble atm

yeah, against Melbourne, that's what I'll be doing.

 

[Cats_Fan]

Which trade would be better?

IN: Dean Cox, OUT: John Meesen

IN: Nick Dal Santo, OUT: Clint Bartram

MY Current Rucks and Mids are as follows:

R: H.McIntosh, T.Simmonds (J.Meesen, M.Kreuzker)

M: S.Burgoyne, D.Cross, T.Johnstone, N.Stevens, C.Morton, R.Palmer (C.Bartram, J.Geary.)

 

[Walesy]

Which trade would be better?

IN: Dean Cox, OUT: John Meesen

IN: Nick Dal Santo, OUT: Clint Bartram

MY Current Rucks and Mids are as follows:

R: H.McIntosh, T.Simmonds (J.Meesen, M.Kreuzker)

M: S.Burgoyne, D.Cross, T.Johnstone, N.Stevens, C.Morton, R.Palmer (C.Bartram, J.Geary.)

Firstly... you have how much sitting in your bank??

Secondly, COX!!

 

[Glenno23]

Which trade would be better?

IN: Dean Cox, OUT: John Meesen

IN: Nick Dal Santo, OUT: Clint Bartram

MY Current Rucks and Mids are as follows:

R: H.McIntosh, T.Simmonds (J.Meesen, M.Kreuzker)

M: S.Burgoyne, D.Cross, T.Johnstone, N.Stevens, C.Morton, R.Palmer (C.Bartram, J.Geary.)

why would you leave Hamish, Cox and Simmonds in the same team?

wasted money on the bench

seems you have the monies, trade McIntosh out for Cox and leave Cox and Simmonds starting

Then do the other trade

 

[Walesy]

Nah, its all bad... Either you're doing a sideways trade, or you're trading to have Simmonds on the bench, or your trading Simmonds who could be a decent money maker...

All bad.

 

[Mick_15]

Can people give me some opinions on Nathan G Brown (richmond)
serisously thinking bout trading him for Porp and cash.
He just hasn't looked like it this year!

 

[Cats_Fan]

Nah, its all bad... Either you're doing a sideways trade, or you're trading to have Simmonds on the bench, or your trading Simmonds who could be a decent money maker...

All bad.

After a down trade this week I will have 500k in the bank, with 1 trade left. Rather than tell you my thoughts I'll post my side and feedback as to what I should do with my other trade would be great. I also am thinking of saving the trade, as the league win is my main aim.

B: J Bowden, H Shaw, D Milburn, G Birchall, L Gilbee, D Bradshaw, B Symes (Pffeifer, S.Selwood)
M: D Cross, T Johnstone, S Burgoyne, N Stevens, J Geary, R Palmer (CMorton, Bartram)
R: H McIntosh, T Simmonds (JMeesen, Kreuzer)
F: J Brown, L Franklin, C Mooney, J Koschitzke, J Porplyzia, T Hawkins, C Rioli (Gamble, Tippet)

Cheers.

 

[Aussie Assault]

Goodes got offered a week by MRP

 

[eugene_tomas]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ive got 546k to spend on a backman 4 k short of mcleod..

so i was thinkin either newman or sam fisher??

or any suggestions from u guys wld be great...

what u guys think and also wld goddard have any impact on sam fisher sc scoring?

 

[Walesy]

After a down trade this week I will have 500k in the bank, with 1 trade left. Rather than tell you my thoughts I'll post my side and feedback as to what I should do with my other trade would be great. I also am thinking of saving the trade, as the league win is my main aim.

B: J Bowden, H Shaw, D Milburn, G Birchall, L Gilbee, D Bradshaw, B Symes (Pffeifer, S.Selwood)
M: D Cross, T Johnstone, S Burgoyne, N Stevens, J Geary, R Palmer (CMorton, Bartram)
R: H McIntosh, T Simmonds (JMeesen, Kreuzer)
F: J Brown, L Franklin, C Mooney, J Koschitzke, J Porplyzia, T Hawkins, C Rioli (Gamble, Tippet)

Cheers.

Just cause you have trades, doesn't mean you have to use them
no-one in that squad is really horrible, definitely not horrible enough to waste a trade on (in my opinion.)
I dunno, I'm a fan in having faith in the team you picked. ya know, you picked those guys for a reason, and surely One bad game shouldn't change that...
Just like last week, (DT #'s here), 10% of the competition picked up Nicoski last week... they would all be cursing.
Have faith in your picks.

 

[Sizza]

gday guys just wondering what ya thoughts are.

i was think of getting rid of michael johnson for michael osbourne, this will give mean i have about $165.000.

do you think with this i should trade nicoski for bock

or trade either jones or stanton for a top midfielder

other options could be lose symes for s.fisher, lose simmonds for sandilands, lose mcintosh for cox.

all suggestions welcome. thanks

 

[Walesy]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ive got 546k to spend on a backman 4 k short of mcleod..

so i was thinkin either newman or sam fisher??

or any suggestions from u guys wld be great...

what u guys think and also wld goddard have any impact on sam fisher sc scoring?

Yes... I believe so.

 

[eugene_tomas]

Yes... I believe so.

so bad idea to get sam?

 

[Cats_Fan]

Just cause you have trades, doesn't mean you have to use them
no-one in that squad is really horrible, definitely not horrible enough to waste a trade on (in my opinion.)
I dunno, I'm a fan in having faith in the team you picked. ya know, you picked those guys for a reason, and surely One bad game shouldn't change that...
Just like last week, (DT #'s here), 10% of the competition picked up Nicoski last week... they would all be cursing.
Have faith in your picks.

Yeah see I've learnt for that before, so I stayed away from NThompson, Dew and Nicoski. 1 week later Dew is injured, the other two had shockers.

The only trade I was pretty certain on was: In- Josh Hill, Out-Kosi. Massive Cash Cow and Kosi had been really dissapointing (51, 27).

 

[Sizza]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ive got 546k to spend on a backman 4 k short of mcleod..

so i was thinkin either newman or sam fisher??

or any suggestions from u guys wld be great...

what u guys think and also wld goddard have any impact on sam fisher sc scoring?

to be honest i would pick fisher. i dont think goddard will affect his scoring. he has now become a consistent sweeping backman and will not be affected by goddards play

 

[eugene_tomas]

im leaning towards fisher but its good to get ur guys opinions.. newman doing well to but he plays for richmond so dunno

 

[Frrost11]

Why would you hav simmonds on the bench! u can be spending more then 1,000,000 on ur rucks, yeh cox is a huge inclusion(shame u didnt hav him from the start...haha) but u dont wanna b havin 300+k on the bench

for my Q:

wat r ur opinions on fev?

1) he will be up against fletcher this week, correct? can he score big/ or better then previous 2 weeks?

2) worth trading for S. Grant/ franklin/ C. Jones?

or trade 4 money to dew/ thompson/ bradshaw?

or downgrade for rookie (j.hill) that is making a killing(or second yr)?need opnions if going 4 this option...already hav gamble, tippet, rioli

plz giv sum opinions, its gonna b a long week without any plan B's or C's