Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[eugene_tomas]

gilbee or milburn or burgonye???

 

[Athomas]

Delidio or N. Brown or Lynch or O'Keefe.

And also, would you risk having three WCE backmen in Waters, Hurn and Nicoski. If i don't then I'll have Hansen starting and have enough cash for the forward above. Moving from Didak to one of those guys ^^^^^


P.S. How much time will we get in between the team lists for the Thursday Night games and the lockout?

The Thursday night game lists will be out Wednesday night.

So we will now 4 teams definitely.

The saturday and sunday games we MIGHT be able to just find them out before Lock out (Channel 10 News show it at 5:43, which leaves roughly half an hour).

 

[Spartan]

Got to love how everyone loves to ask questions but never answer them.

 

[Athomas]

gilbee or milburn or burgonye???

Lsat year I would have said Gilbee without question.

This year I am unsure, probably still Gilbee though.

 

[Athomas]

Got to love how everyone loves to ask questions but never answer them.

I agree, ridiculous.

I haven't asked many myself. Thinking about Barlow over Nicoski now, but really don't like Sydney players after thinking about it.

I love how 3 weeks ago it was all "MATTNER OR KENNELLY" and now neither have been mentioned for ages.

 

[SJ]

I agree, ridiculous.

I haven't asked many myself. Thinking about Barlow over Nicoski now, but really don't like Sydney players after thinking about it.

I love how 3 weeks ago it was all "MATTNER OR KENNELLY" and now neither have been mentioned for ages.

Yep and Johnstone was all the rage.

 

[Athomas]

Yep and Johnstone was all the rage.

haha yep. And Symes/Dyson. Although they could go ok for DT.

 

[Spartan]

I agree, ridiculous.

I haven't asked many myself. Thinking about Barlow over Nicoski now, but really don't like Sydney players after thinking about it.

I love how 3 weeks ago it was all "MATTNER OR KENNELLY" and now neither have been mentioned for ages.

lol my thinking is that it doesn't matter if you're a newbie or an expert, listening to other people's opinions puts things in a different perspective.

its funny though watching people try and bullshit to try and throw people off a particular player.

Barlow vs Nicoski is touch and go. Nico has been struggling and there are alot of Eagles pushing for selection. Barlow has had two really good games and has been considered to Adam Goodes with Roos also rating him pretty high. However I'm not sure he's a lock in the Swans team and at 220k+ could be an expensive dud. If its a backline position you might want to look at Bradshaw.

 

[sblack]

I agree, ridiculous.

I haven't asked many myself. Thinking about Barlow over Nicoski now, but really don't like Sydney players after thinking about it.

I love how 3 weeks ago it was all "MATTNER OR KENNELLY" and now neither have been mentioned for ages.

Thanks for the team list stats.

What's wrong with Sydney players. Last season they were the thri\\ird highest scoring team, and last year was a pretty bad one for Sydney. Goodes and Hall were significant downers for scores, and not many other guys steped up. So if Sydney are any beter than last year, they will continue to produce big scores.

 

[Athomas]

Thanks for the team list stats.

What's wrong with Sydney players. Last season they were the thri\\ird highest scoring team, and last year was a pretty bad one for Sydney. Goodes and Hall were significant downers for scores, and not many other guys steped up. So if Sydney are any beter than last year, they will continue to produce big scores.

You sure they were third?
They normally play a low disposal game and restrict opposition teams, so I don't like them.

 

[happy_eagle]

wow, people like to post there teams here

 

[SJ]

Yeah they were third. Remember this is SuperCoach and not Dream Team. And restricting opposition teams does no harm to your SuperCoach scores.

 

[Athomas]

Yeah they were third. Remember this is SuperCoach and not Dream Team. And restricting opposition teams does no harm to your SuperCoach scores.

Hmmm k then.
Barlow might overtake Nicoski for a spot then

 

[Gun Barrel Straight]

Sydney being 3rd might be down to the fact of their style of play. lots of tackling and short kicks. not a great deal of clangers. true?

 

[sacka]

im new to SC, how much money around about would you want in the bank after you do your side?????

 

[Athomas]

im new to SC, how much money around about would you want in the bank after you do your side?????

$0 to $20,000 IMO.

I have 75K atm, but I will make sure I use it, will have to wait for Round 1 Teams / Nab Challenge Results etc.

 

[Thommo4pm]

Ok guys I need some opinions. To all you bastards that I have helped its time to repay the favour.

Shaping up as my final decision.

Akermanis + T.Tuck (Bench)
Hall + Selwood/Ebert (Bench)
Bradshaw + E.Barlow (Bench or playing)

Cmon people!

Akers move to the midfield has payed big dividends for his scores so far this preseason, and i cant really see him playing off HF again like last year as he was fairly useless (compared to his lofty standards) and tuck, well you can see him playing quite a few games this year due to suspensions at hawks, and well hes been in the system a couple of years now so they will give him a chance to prove himself.

Hall - well the jury is still out about him, preseason has been good, but against fairly no name defenders to be honest...but we all know what he is capable of, with Hall you may as well flip a coin. and well neither Selwood or Ebert are garaunteed they weill be getting many games this season...1st year players, cant expect too much.

Bradshaw and Barlow, well, i was after one of these 2, but i figure the upside is with Bradshaw as if hes fit, he will be in the side, and with Brissi looking set for a big year, hes going to get no shortage of feed. Barlow on the other hand, while he has had good reviews, is not certain to play all games. If hes for your bench, well hes far too expensive to be honest. Might be good to cash in someone for him down the track if he doesnt play his 3 games for a while.

IMHO. aker and tuck.
HTH Spartan.

 

[Spartan]

Akers move to the midfield has payed big dividends for his scores so far this preseason, and i cant really see him playing off HF again like last year as he was fairly useless (compared to his lofty standards) and tuck, well you can see him playing quite a few games this year due to suspensions at hawks, and well hes been in the system a couple of years now so they will give him a chance to prove himself.

Hall - well the jury is still out about him, preseason has been good, but against fairly no name defenders to be honest...but we all know what he is capable of, with Hall you may as well flip a coin. and well neither Selwood or Ebert are garaunteed they weill be getting many games this season...1st year players, cant expect too much.

Bradshaw and Barlow, well, i was after one of these 2, but i figure the upside is with Bradshaw as if hes fit, he will be in the side, and with Brissi looking set for a big year, hes going to get no shortage of feed. Barlow on the other hand, while he has had good reviews, is not certain to play all games. If hes for your bench, well hes far too expensive to be honest. Might be good to cash in someone for him down the track if he doesnt play his 3 games for a while.

IMHO. aker and tuck.
HTH Spartan.

Thanks dude. While you're thinking along exactly the same lines I am, its good to get someone else's opinion.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Hey
Few questions

K Cornes/Ablett- whos better

Cross/Thompson

Newman/Symes or Gilbee/Ellis

Deledio/Jetta or Johnson/Gamble

Thoughts on Mundy

Didak/Hall

Is it bad to have 4 players from richmond in ur team eg deledio/bowden/newman/simmonds

Thanks

 

[jtrevat]

Opinions please...


T.Kennelly or G.Johncock

C.Bird or R.Palmer

B.Houli or C.Masten/C.Morton

J.Sellar or K.Tippett

 

[Windas_Magic]

Is Stanton worth 500k? Thoughts?
Do you reckon Pavlichs' price will drop?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Opinions please...


T.Kennelly or G.Johncock Kennelly but id stay away from both

C.Bird or R.Palmer Dont know if either of them will start

B.Houli or C.Masten/C.Morton Houli

J.Sellar or K.Tippett

Tippet

 

[jtrevat]

Is it bad to have 4 players from richmond in ur team eg deledio/bowden/newman/simmonds

thats fine. try not to have to many players from the same team in the same line ie. 3 forwards for the same team.

 

[eugene_tomas]

bowden with 15k left in bank

or burgoyne with 56k in bank

 

[adam10]

Hey
Few questions

K Cornes/Ablett- whos better Toss a coin

Cross/Thompson Toss a coin

Newman/Symes or Gilbee/Ellis Gilbbe/Ellis

Deledio/Jetta or Johnson/Gamble If you need 1 more richmond Deledio

Thoughts on Mundy Will do good this year i would have him

Didak/Hall Toss a coin id go whoevers cheaper

Is it bad to have 4 players from richmond in ur team eg deledio/bowden/newman/simmonds YESSSSSSS

Thanks

First two are to hard to pick