I'm a bit torn. Pretty hard to avoid the original story to make much a venture work, but the lack of originality could kill it. I recall Aliens v Predator being the flattest experience after knowing pretty much everything beforehand from the comic. It's already gorgeous visually with a huge story...how do you top it? LOTR was a book, AVP a comic, and the rest you guys have mentioned aren't sci-fi...dunno, can't bear to look yet I can't turn away...!
