Broken
Brownlow Medallist
In the recent non-AFL competition threads one of the most common questions is "How come people aren't voting for my design" closely followed by "I can't believe XXX is winning"
As there is a difference in talent and ideas on this board I'm curious as to why people vote for a certain design? Do people vote purely on how professional and how clean a design looks? Do people vote on the design concept even if the execution is lacking? Do people vote for their favourite designers? Something else maybe?
As a way of helping people learn and develop their skills I was wondering if people could offer their opinions on certain designs that have either underperformed or have raised questions in some of the recent non-AFL competitions (presently the ACFFL and FFL).
I will be putting forward individual designs at points in this thread and hope to get some constructive advice and reasons for and against.
As there is a difference in talent and ideas on this board I'm curious as to why people vote for a certain design? Do people vote purely on how professional and how clean a design looks? Do people vote on the design concept even if the execution is lacking? Do people vote for their favourite designers? Something else maybe?
As a way of helping people learn and develop their skills I was wondering if people could offer their opinions on certain designs that have either underperformed or have raised questions in some of the recent non-AFL competitions (presently the ACFFL and FFL).
I will be putting forward individual designs at points in this thread and hope to get some constructive advice and reasons for and against.