Notice how McGuane got the KP position over Thursfield yet again...
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
I hate McGuane
- Thread starter 1980
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Good post.
I thought this kid was reasonable for you guys - he at least tried his arse off and put his heart into it; in spite of the fact your midfield and forwards left your defence open for a bumming.
McGuane is a KPP whos job is to keep his opponents impact to a minimum he doesnt really have to give too much when we have it.
King on the other hand is a small backman who has to be able to stop which he cant do and has to be able to create which his skills are not up too.
I am not being a hypocrite I am simply backing up a player who was far from our worst today.
richmond fanatic
Cancelled
- Banned
- #32
And you're a wanka 
I thought McGuane, Thursfield and Moore were best for the Tigers, considering it was coming in so regularly and with no pressure applied by the Tigers on-ballers. You guys got pantsed in the ruck and at the clearances. I'd be pointing the finger at Nathan Brown and McMahon for not earning their dollars yesterday. Richo has had a wonderful year but he was terrible yesterday.
The young defenders were the only blokes having a go and the only ones who fought the game right out despite the scoreline.
The young defenders were the only blokes having a go and the only ones who fought the game right out despite the scoreline.
The unfortunate thing for McGaune in this game was...at the end of 5 or 6 of the worst passages of play by the tiges this year...he was the poor bast ard that got the pill at the hottest point...sure quality players, keep cool under pressure and get out of these situations, but not time after time after time...i will admit i kept bagging the hell outta him at the time too but fair is fair, i thought he played a better game than 80% of the team...loving our backline at the moment...(minus mcmahon...)
)
PHX
Quarterback Style
That is true but I see that as because Thursty is the quickest of them all so he has to play on the small forward instead of a bigger forward because we have no small back pocket that can near control them. Dont even mention some of Jake Kings defensive work and positioning yesterday, I was furious at the lack of footy smarts.
If I had to point my finger at three players for being the worst it would be Richo, Brown and McMahon. Those 3 were nothing short of pathetic for senior players in our team.
- Banned
- #36
our tall backs have nothing to do with the insipid performance. They couldnt do anymore than they did in the face of a tidal wave that would build from their backline, without, and I repeat without any semblance of pressure.
TW, have you got any ****ing idea how to set up for an oppoisition kick in? I mean, there is obviously 18 v 18 players on the field isnt there? Then how does a kick in hit a crow who has not one tiger within sight, then that crow then disposes of it to where there are 2 crows and no tigers. I mean WTF!!! is going on TW? What kind of ****ing 2 bob zone are you playing fool?
TW, have you got any ****ing idea how to set up for an oppoisition kick in? I mean, there is obviously 18 v 18 players on the field isnt there? Then how does a kick in hit a crow who has not one tiger within sight, then that crow then disposes of it to where there are 2 crows and no tigers. I mean WTF!!! is going on TW? What kind of ****ing 2 bob zone are you playing fool?
Yes it was all McGuanes fault cos he is one of our defenders who didn't stop Adelaide from scoring..
how about our forward line who were as accepting of forward thrusts as a brick wall?
our midfield who....hang on wait did we have a midfield?
Our defense was poor as a result of the turnovers up the field, the numerous and costly turnovers
so yes lets blame blokes like McGuane because is he the one that let Adelaide enter their 50 a lazy 47 times
If you let a team own our forward and midfield lines then dont blame the defenders cos they couldnt staunch the bleeding
I'd blame a whole lot more blokes before McGuane
how about our forward line who were as accepting of forward thrusts as a brick wall?
our midfield who....hang on wait did we have a midfield?
Our defense was poor as a result of the turnovers up the field, the numerous and costly turnovers
so yes lets blame blokes like McGuane because is he the one that let Adelaide enter their 50 a lazy 47 times
If you let a team own our forward and midfield lines then dont blame the defenders cos they couldnt staunch the bleeding
I'd blame a whole lot more blokes before McGuane
- Thread starter
- #39
Yes it was all McGuanes fault cos he is one of our defenders who didn't stop Adelaide from scoring..
how about our forward line who were as accepting of forward thrusts as a brick wall?
our midfield who....hang on wait did we have a midfield?
Our defense was poor as a result of the turnovers up the field, the numerous and costly turnovers
so yes lets blame blokes like McGuane because is he the one that let Adelaide enter their 50 a lazy 47 times
If you let a team own our forward and midfield lines then dont blame the defenders cos they couldnt staunch the bleeding
I'd blame a whole lot more blokes before McGuane
Didnt say it was his fault we lost. Said he is a crap footballer.
No skill, no awareness, cant kick, cant punch, cant tackle, can run.
Despite our shocking team performance, Thursfield and Moore were in our best. McGuane is a country footballer compared to those 2
- Banned
- #40
get real 1980. Have you heard of the word frustration? I mean here you are, in the backline, busting your butt, and anything good that comes out of your work, turns to shit because other players who are suppose to "know" what to do, more than you do, dont have a ****ing clue. I have no problmes with any of Moore, Thurst and McGuane. They held on for dear life in the face of an unpressured barrage of inccoming attacks.
hahaha
tugga
Hall of Famer
- May 9, 2006
- 35,859
- 71,715
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tottenham,NY Rangers,Red Sox, SA Spurs
I'd be pointing the finger at the likes of McMahon who pays no respect whatsoever to his direct opponent.
When McMahon doesn't have the ball, he simply clocks off. If he were an office worker, he'd be the type that actually does an hour's work for the entire day and spends the rest of the time surfing the net (a bit like me). He is really only entitled to put his hand out for about 15% of his match payments.
When McMahon doesn't have the ball, he simply clocks off. If he were an office worker, he'd be the type that actually does an hour's work for the entire day and spends the rest of the time surfing the net (a bit like me). He is really only entitled to put his hand out for about 15% of his match payments.
- Banned
- #44
Maybe I can get a gig on the RFC list
yes you can emp. But the bounus is that you can just hang out off the contest, get the give and proceed to run around and then kick it to the opposition, and then have imbeciles here, give you votes and argue that you were one of the best, because you had it more than others. The bomus for the tigers is that you would do it for less than a $200 a week. So the club would be a long way in front.
- Dec 18, 2005
- 22,175
- 15,426
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond
I don't agree with any of this. He's not too slow, his kicking is good usually. He's young and inexperienced and is an up and coming quality defender
- Dec 18, 2005
- 22,175
- 15,426
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond
I watched the game and thought he was good. I hope you weren't watching it, because you must have problems if you think he's crap
Award for worst thread on here this week. Goes to YOU.
- Thread starter
- #50
There's plenty of threads about Mcmahon Tugga.
McGuane gets off lightly. History at this football club shows we wont ever play finals with another weak link that everyone overrates.
Similar threads
