If the league started over which players would i draft.....

[Cuneyt]

1. Barry Hall
2. Byron Pickett
3. Brent Guerra
4. Richie Van Den Berg
5. Johnathon Brown

Try and beat that 5, I dare you. Every club in the league would be absolutely terrified. Funnily enough, all 5 are actually decent players too.

 

[Moo://_Cow]

You would not take Judd at number one..good teams are based around KPP.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

You would not take Judd at number one..good teams are based around KPP.

Agreed

 

[eddiesmith]

1. Tredrea
2. Scarlett
3. Judd
4. Akermanis
5. Lloyd

Hird? Not a chance to even get close.

I picked Aker instead of a ruckman because the rest of them have no personality and it would be quite boring around the club without Aker

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Three midfielders! Sure your not Terry Wallet?

I wouldnt mind having terry,s wallet
Well someone has to kick it to Revolt and Bazza dont you think?

cheers!

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

1.Tredrea
2.Judd
3.Hall
4.Black
5.Goodes

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I wouldnt mind having terry,s wallet
Well someone has to kick it to Revolt and Bazza dont you think?

cheers!

Your right, they do but I'd rather get the pick of the KPP's then worry about midfielders. As someone said earlier, you build your team around KPP's. If Judd wasn't such a freak I would have used all 5 picks on KPP's.

 

[WestCat]

1-Reiwoldt
2-Scarlett
3-Judd
4-Riccutio
5-David Clarke

Is that for his sublime kicking skills or his outstanding footy brain?

 

[nic_rox13]

1. Judd - best midfielder in comp and at his age how can you not
2. Tredrea - best chf in comp.
3. J.Brown - tough, rough chf all side need.
4. Scarlett - best defender in comp by a mile
5. Black - one of the best midielders in the comp.

from my team lloyd would be up there. best FF by a mile. and still young.
Hird would be in the top 5 in the AFL but if your thinking long term you probably wouldnt pick him cause of how long he has left.

also hall is massive, powerful and a great teacher for younger players emerging, + vandenberg is a tough guy but wouldn't come close, decent...

 

[jo172]

2/-Revolt:History shows you need a champion CHF to win a flag.

Like Mathew Robran

 

[Yze_Magic]

1. Jonathan Brown
2. Jared Rivers
3. Nick Riewoldt
4. Chris Judd
5. Simon Black

 

[Longy413]

Hird wuldn't be top 5.

In skill level? Certainly.

Game changing ability? Sure.

But he doesn't consistently play as well as any of these:

Tredrea
Riewoldt
Judd
Scarlett
Lloyd

and there's probably at least another 5 before I'd get to Hird.

Can't help yourself can you?

 

[rick James]

Can't help yourself can you?

wtf are you talking about?

Someone talked about Hird being easily top 5, that's why I made a post suggesting otherwise.

Don't cry about it dorothy, reply to it or stfu.

 

[Longy413]

wtf are you talking about?

Someone talked about Hird being easily top 5, that's why I made a post suggesting otherwise.

Don't cry about it dorothy, reply to it or stfu.

No they didn't.

Someone said that Hird is (on form) in the best 5 players in the comp, but wouldn't draft him because of age. I thought that was a accurate comment.

 

[chipsticks]

1. Riewoldt
2. Judd
3. Ball
4. Mc Pharlin
5. Franklin

 

[Cro_Pavo]

1 Chris Judd
2 Simon Black
3 Jonathan Brown
4 Matthew Scarlett
5 Brendan Fevola