If you could take one player...

[ozzult]

If you could take one player from any other team in the AFL and put them in the West Coast Eagles, who would you choose?

When making your decision, take into consideration things like our strengths and weaknesses, youth, and development.


Personally, I'd be throwing up between Reiwoldt and Pavlich.

 

[carlyp]

Riewoldt or Pavlich for sure. Their great KPP players of the future!

 

[Ripper]

Thou shalt not covert thy neighbour's Pavlich nor his Polack nor his Hazelby nor his Macparlap.

 

[ozzult]

Polak and McPharlin would be gold for us.

 

[RzrBlade]

i would take riewoldt for sure, he would be a godsend to any club.

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

Just to change the trend a bit, I'd want Hamill. Having him on our HF line along with Chick in the middle would add a lot of heart into the team.

 

[RzrBlade]

Originally posted by daddy_4_eyes
Just to change the trend a bit, I'd want Hamill. Having him on our HF line along with Chick in the middle would add a lot of heart into the team.

i would probably prefer to take adam goodes over hamill.

 

[shiva25]

Would take either Tredrea or Lloyd as they lack tall forwards.

 

[Massie]

Just gatecrashing here. I'ld strongly be tempted to take Mcleod or Voss. Their skills are exquisite. Talking about KPP it would have to be Tarrant i think!?!?

 

[jod23]

Reiwoldt no question, can play CHB, CHF, FF, pretty much anywhere. Would almost solve our KPP problem.

 

[iceman]

Riewoldt

 

[Deepthroat]

If Lloyd was standing in our goalsquare on Sunday the Eagles would have got up by 10 goals. A good strong consistent finisher is what we need.

 

[The Passenger]

Brad Ottens - guy is a freak up front. Just impossible to match up on, plus he can go into the ruck and we'd have close to the 2 best rucks in the comp.

But this judgement is reserved till I see how much his injury affects him from the first half of the season. If he comes back as good as what he was before hand then I'd definetaly want him.

If not, then I'd go for Nick Riewoldt.

 

[Jabber]

Riewoldt - can play all key positions.

 

[USAEagle]

A few years ago I would have said Waterhouse. He still would be serviceable.

I was a strong proponent of us going after Wayne Carey hard. Unfortunately he has been hit and miss.

Now....

We need three strong spine players. A FB, CHB and FF. D Gaspar, Pavlich and Lloyd or Richo.

Richo because with the right coaching and environment would be 10x better than he is. Lloyd becuase he is, well....Lloyd.

If Judd wants to go back (and I don't think he will) but how about Lloyd and a draft pick from Essendon for him?

Lloyd is what, 25 or 26? Just entering his prime.

 

[RzrBlade]

Originally posted by USAEagle
A few years ago I would have said Waterhouse. He still would be serviceable.

I was a strong proponent of us going after Wayne Carey hard. Unfortunately he has been hit and miss.

Now....

We need three strong spine players. A FB, CHB and FF. D Gaspar, Pavlich and Lloyd or Richo.

Richo because with the right coaching and environment would be 10x better than he is. Lloyd becuase he is, well....Lloyd.

If Judd wants to go back (and I don't think he will) but how about Lloyd and a draft pick from Essendon for him?

Lloyd is what, 25 or 26? Just entering his prime.

no chance of the dons trading lloyd and a pick for judd, let alone lloyd himself i think. he is definately out of bounds i reckon. but it does seem good in theory. another possibility i thought of was if the dogs get picks one and 2, we get one of them plus mitchell hahn for judd. hahn has proven to be quite good this year i think, and is a kpp and would be a handy pick-up.

 

[Frodo]

LLoyd, Simon Black, Voss, Tredrea

 

[Kenny_01]

Originally posted by RzrBlade
hahn has proven to be quite good this year i think, and is a kpp and would be a handy pick-up.

Mitch Hahn is hardly a KPP. He has been playing in the midfield.

 

[Frodo]

Originally posted by Kenny_01
Mitch Hahn is hardly a KPP. He has been playing in the midfield.

So has Pav

 

[Kenny_01]

Originally posted by Frodo
So has Pav

Yep, but we have players forward and down back that can cover him. If he could play in any KP, you would think the Bulldogs would play him there because they lack height down back and up forward as well. He is not the KPP you are looking for.

 

[noodle]

Riewoldt or Black (not the St Kilda hack).

 

[mantis]

Originally posted by USAEagle
If Judd wants to go back (and I don't think he will) but how about Lloyd and a draft pick from Essendon for him?

Lloyd is what, 25 or 26? Just entering his prime.

ROFLMAO, I bet you believe in Santa Clause too.


Sorry to intrude people, but I just couldn't let this one go by without a comment.

 

[ozzult]

Originally posted by USAEagle
If Judd wants to go back (and I don't think he will) but how about Lloyd and a draft pick from Essendon for him?

Lloyd is what, 25 or 26? Just entering his prime.

Ummm... yeah.

 

[Dave]

Originally posted by USAEagle
If Judd wants to go back (and I don't think he will) but how about Lloyd and a draft pick from Essendon for him?

LOL! How about you let us have some of that hooch you've been smoking! Lloyd *and* a draft pick. ROFLMAO.

 

[Eagle_Fan]

Daniel Giansiracusa.

Oh, and for the club, probably Reiwoldt.

Look, while Juddy can do no wrong (til we get that signature anyway), let's not overrate the kid.