Injuries....Bad luck or something else?

Remove this Banner Ad

lukiuslion said:
This is a bit dated in relation to this convo. The thread was initiated given a further 5 players are now on that list - giving us a total injury list of 20 players. It was already high but now we are up there with GC as the worst hit in the league. We have generally been league leaders in injury statistics the last 2 years too (from memory, I don't wish to produce pie graphs and stats to support this). Even without the 5 extra players, most other teams have normal, manageable injury lists, we still look particularly bad.
Click to expand...

Yeah - nah... a bit like the ocean all of the above clubs numbers are fluid week to week/month to month and year to year - geez it was only two months ago that the saints had a list of soft tissue player injuries the length of the Nepean Highway.

AND...

So players the players below - 53% out of the last week 'out of date' listed post, never had injuries until they were managed by Burton?

  • Cian Hanley - Knee - Season
  • Pearce Hanley - Hip - 1-2 Weeks
  • Matt Maguire - Concussion - Indefinite
  • Luke McGuane - Knee - Indefinite
  • Daniel Merrett - Hamstring - Indefinite
  • Jackson Paine - Ankle - Season
  • Brent Staker - Hamstring - 2-3 Weeks
  • Trent West - Knee - 4 Weeks

Give me a break, not saying you are but it reads like you are not thinking through what you type.
 
blynd_freddie said:
Yeah - nah... a bit like the ocean all of the above clubs numbers are fluid week to week/month to month and year to year - geez it was only two months ago that the saints had a list of soft tissue player injuries the length of the Nepean Highway.

AND...

So players the players below - 53% out of the last week 'out of date' listed post, never had injuries until they were managed by Burton?

  • Cian Hanley - Knee - Season
  • Pearce Hanley - Hip - 1-2 Weeks
  • Matt Maguire - Concussion - Indefinite
  • Luke McGuane - Knee - Indefinite
  • Daniel Merrett - Hamstring - Indefinite
  • Jackson Paine - Ankle - Season
  • Brent Staker - Hamstring - 2-3 Weeks
  • Trent West - Knee - 4 Weeks

Give me a break, not saying you are but it reads like you are not thinking through what you type.
Click to expand...

How so mate, please elaborate? I would actually say that you putting up an injury list from last week, which is not detailing an increase in our injury numbers of 25% since then, and encouraging us to compare to the rest of the league, when this thread was bought about as a result of the weekend, would be an example of you not thinking through what you type.

I don't know what you mean about the 53% part, it doesn't make sense, I assumed at first it was about players in their first or second year with the club but as Merrett, Staker and Hanley are in there, its not that - I cant respond to it.
 
Lionheart182 said:
That is actually a really good sign, assuming you haven't made a typo there.
Click to expand...
I didn't make that very clear, did I? Yeah, regular soft tissue injuries are always a red flag.
blynd_freddie said:
Looks like there should be plenty of Elite Performance Managerial positions up for grabs... every club seems to be experiencing injuries! :eek:

ADELAIDE
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)

BRISBANE LIONS
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)

CARLTON
  • Ciaran Byrne - Hamstring - 1-2 Weeks
  • Bryce Gibbs - Back - 2 Weeks
  • Cameron Giles - Foot - Indefinite
  • Lachie Henderson - Hamstring - Test
  • Michael Jamison - Calf - 1 Week
  • Chris Judd - Knee Soreness - 1 Week
  • Ciaran Sheehan - Groin - 12 Weeks
  • Andrew Walker - Knee - Test
(Updated: 27 May 2015 12pm)



COLLINGWOOD
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)



ESSENDON
(Updated: 26 May 2015 7pm)

FREMANTLE
(Updated: 26 May 2015 7pm)



GEELONG
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

(Updated 28 May 2015 8:15pm)

GOLD COAST
(Updated: 26 May 2015 1:30pm)



GWS
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)



HAWTHORN
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)


MELBOURNE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)



NORTH MELBOURNE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

PORT ADELAIDE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

RICHMOND
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)



ST KILDA
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)



SYDNEY SWANS
  • Isaac Heeney - PCL Knee - 3-5 Weeks
  • Alex Johnson - Knee - Indefinite
  • Lewis Melican - Groin - 1 Weeks
  • Lloyd Perris - Knee - 3 Weeks
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)

WEST COAST
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:50pm)



WESTERN BULLDOGS
Click to expand...
Carlton certainly can't blame the injury list.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

blynd_freddie said:
Looks like there should be plenty of Elite Performance Managerial positions up for grabs... every club seems to be experiencing injuries! :eek:

ADELAIDE
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)

BRISBANE LIONS
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)

CARLTON
  • Ciaran Byrne - Hamstring - 1-2 Weeks
  • Bryce Gibbs - Back - 2 Weeks
  • Cameron Giles - Foot - Indefinite
  • Lachie Henderson - Hamstring - Test
  • Michael Jamison - Calf - 1 Week
  • Chris Judd - Knee Soreness - 1 Week
  • Ciaran Sheehan - Groin - 12 Weeks
  • Andrew Walker - Knee - Test
(Updated: 27 May 2015 12pm)



COLLINGWOOD
(Updated: 26 May 2015 6:30pm)



ESSENDON
(Updated: 26 May 2015 7pm)

FREMANTLE
(Updated: 26 May 2015 7pm)



GEELONG
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

(Updated 28 May 2015 8:15pm)

GOLD COAST
(Updated: 26 May 2015 1:30pm)



GWS
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)



HAWTHORN
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)


MELBOURNE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)



NORTH MELBOURNE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

PORT ADELAIDE
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:30pm)

RICHMOND
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)



ST KILDA
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)



SYDNEY SWANS
  • Isaac Heeney - PCL Knee - 3-5 Weeks
  • Alex Johnson - Knee - Indefinite
  • Lewis Melican - Groin - 1 Weeks
  • Lloyd Perris - Knee - 3 Weeks
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:45pm)

WEST COAST
(Updated: 27 May 2015 1:50pm)



WESTERN BULLDOGS
Click to expand...

Sorry but not sure this proves your point. According to this list we have the highest number of injuries total, the highest number of season ending injuries and the equal highest number of indefinites. I think I'm more concerned now than I was before....
 
Didn't Burton have a 3 year plan to improve core strength, build greater resilience and be an elite running team or something similar?

A lot of the guys on our list over that period seem to have gone backwards in terms of their ability to stay on the field. A lot of the injuries are collision injuries but at some stage it stops being luck and becomes a factor of how we prepare them.
 
Quigley said:
Didn't Burton have a 3 year plan to improve core strength, build greater resilience and be an elite running team or something similar?

A lot of the guys on our list over that period seem to have gone backwards in terms of their ability to stay on the field. A lot of the injuries are collision injuries but at some stage it stops being luck and becomes a factor of how we prepare them.
Click to expand...

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that we need to look elsewhere next season. Our sluggish starts to the season fitness wise just don't cut it.
 
Bucking Beads said:
There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that we need to look elsewhere next season. Our sluggish starts to the season fitness wise just don't cut it.
Click to expand...

If we are switching hopefully it is early enough to allow the new guy/team to run the whole off-season not just pick up afterwards.
 
Quigley said:
Didn't Burton have a 3 year plan to improve core strength, build greater resilience and be an elite running team or something similar?
Click to expand...

Did he? I'm sure there's some news article or something out there that could be dug up if there was?
 
^ agree. I'm less concerned with the injuries many of which are colision based and more concerned with the hopeless starts to the season and the fact we always seem to be one of hte slowest teams in the league in gut running and transition running.
 
Quigley said:
Didn't Burton have a 3 year plan to improve core strength, build greater resilience and be an elite running team or something similar?

A lot of the guys on our list over that period seem to have gone backwards in terms of their ability to stay on the field. A lot of the injuries are collision injuries but at some stage it stops being luck and becomes a factor of how we prepare them.
Click to expand...
Who Quigs?

Who has gone backwards or has less time on ground percentages of the three years?

It's easy to sit back and throw assertions and yes just as easy for me throw back neighs.

It's known we play on the hardest surface in the league. One assumes player management has evolved around this knowledge. Our soft tissue issues like quads and hammies have reduced remarkable since the Drummo and early Adcock days. Good luck or better player management? I'm thinking the later. Are the kids playing too hard, too young? Have look back at the GWS and GCS injury lists over the last 3 years and that's even with the use of high rotations and controlled game numbers per year.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I know these injuries are not really burton's fault. But when you look at our fitness, our lack of muscle and how injury ridden we have become, i don't see any reason why he should still be around. I just hope brisbane actually hires someone with decent credentials next time
 
Gravity said:
Sorry but not sure this proves your point. According to this list we have the highest number of injuries total, the highest number of season ending injuries and the equal highest number of indefinites. I think I'm more concerned now than I was before....
Click to expand...

And it doesen't include a further 6 players added over the weekend, not sure how concerned you are now? Lol
 
Haso said:
Burton should have had Aish on a solid regimen of gum chewing to strengthen up that jaw.

That broken jaw could have been avoided.

Thanks a lot Burton.
Click to expand...

Haso - let's imagine burton walks in and says "I am happy to stay on a reasonable contract but only if it's a 3 year extension" - do you think we should sign him again, or should we seek a fresh start?

Has he done enough to risk things improving under his watch? Would you be confident?

No one is blaming burton for impact injuries.
 
Haso said:
Burton should have had Aish on a solid regimen of gum chewing to strengthen up that jaw.

That broken jaw could have been avoided.

Thanks a lot Burton.
Click to expand...

Love your posts Haso.... But not this one.
The buck has to stop with someone.

I want to see my team bigger and stronger next year. Maybe we're getting more injuries because the boys bodies aren't strong enough to withstand big impacts.... So things break and tear.

The NRL boys put on a huge amount of muscle to withstand the punishment of their game.
Obviously in AFL they couldn't run all day being that big..... But I'd like to see an extra 2-3kg of muscle on our established players... 5kg on the young ones.
They should all look like Mitch Robinson.

Anything less is a failure.
 
blynd_freddie said:
Who Quigs?

Who has gone backwards or has less time on ground percentages of the three years?

It's easy to sit back and throw assertions and yes just as easy for me throw back neighs.

It's known we play on the hardest surface in the league. One assumes player management has evolved around this knowledge. Our soft tissue issues like quads and hammies have reduced remarkable since the Drummo and early Adcock days. Good luck or better player management? I'm thinking the later. Are the kids playing too hard, too young? Have look back at the GWS and GCS injury lists over the last 3 years and that's even with the use of high rotations and controlled game numbers per year.
Click to expand...

Soft tissue injuries have gone down across the board. Our numbers are still above average though.

Of the guys who have been here I would suggest that Redden is much less durable, Hanley has worn down with a hip injury, Harwood is now missing time with injury, Leuenberger has always struggled but has shown no improvement in durability similarly with Maguire, McGuane has gone from missing games because he was not good enough to missing games because he has been injured, Merrett's body seems to have packed up, Staker cannot get on the park. You can argue that many are collision injuries but a lot of hte programs are designed to minimise the chances of those collisions resulting in injury. It is never going to be completely foolproof but other teams are much more successful at avoiding these injuries.
 
Haso said:
Burton should have had Aish on a solid regimen of gum chewing to strengthen up that jaw.

That broken jaw could have been avoided.

Thanks a lot Burton.
Click to expand...

2016 preseason training

jaws.jpg
 
Quigley said:
Soft tissue injuries have gone down across the board. Our numbers are still above average though.

Of the guys who have been here I would suggest that Redden is much less durable,
Click to expand...

Sorry Quigs, I stopped there, now I know you are baiting me.

Redden played 112 games in a row from 2009 to round 15 last year. Came back for 2015 played the first 7 and is suggest he will miss 1-2 weeks with a 'back'.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Injuries....Bad luck or something else?

Similar threads

RU_
Opinion Who is your hard luck story from the 2024 Premiership?
2 3
Replies
51
Views
2K
Sproj
S
3KZ is Football
Opinion Who was the superior player Simon Black or Lachie Neale?
2
Replies
32
Views
2K
luthor
luthor

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top