'Insert players name" kills my club everytime!

[The Speaker]

'Al' Franklin - Three votes

 

[Topper Harley]

It's really only been since Ling retired that Mitchell has gotten off the chain against the Cats.

Former players that used to kill Geelong were Shane Crawford and Shane Woewodin.

Akermanis loved us too until he met David Johnson. No coincidence that he played his unbelievable Gabba game against us when DJ was out injured.

 

[Blues177]

L Thomas
S Milne
A Monfries
Geelong at Etihad

 

[andrew coombs]

It's really only been since Ling retired that Mitchell has gotten off the chain against the Cats.

Former players that used to kill Geelong were Shane Crawford and Shane Woewodin.

Mitchell actually averaged just under 31 possessions against Geelong in Lings last three seasons.

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Any teams 2nd best forward and resting ruck, don't have anyone left to cover them after expansion poaching and injuries.

Also Westhoff

Previously Cousins.

 

[Tas]

Ablett, he would be in the votes even if he wasn't playing that is how accustom the umpires are of him rogering us.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Mitchell actually averaged just under 31 possessions against Geelong in Lings last three seasons.

Ling used to alternate between Hodge and Mitchell. Whichever one he wasn't on invariably got loose, it wasn't unusual for him to be switched mid game to quell the other. (Perhaps they should have put him on Hodgey in '08 )

 

[gus3232]

I swear Scott Lucas saved his best games for the Eagles.

 

[shinboner spiggs]

Cyril rioli, just consistently belts us.

Pearce Hanley has won 2 games of his own boot in the last two years against us.

 

[Bulldocker]

Rioli

 

[The Scales]

If Despair can mention James Hird, I'll raise him a Brett Stanton. One elite season, the rest - a turnover demi god amongst mortals.

 

[BM123]

Thomas, Roughead, Franklin

Basically any smart forward with a few tricks and big bodied mids with clean hands.

 

[Despair]

If Despair can mention James Hird, I'll raise him a Brett Stanton. One elite season, the rest - a turnover demi god amongst mortals.

There has literally never been a person named Brett Stanton on an AFL list

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Cyril rioli, just consistently belts us.

Pearce Hanley has won 2 games of his own boot in the last two years against us.

kerridge

 

[Marmozet]

Jason Davenport. Kicked four final quarter goals in 2010, Port win by one point. He was a big reason why we won the spoon that year.
Also kicked a bag of 3 against us on another occasion to almost win the game.
28 games for his career, 29 goals, 10 of them against west coast.

EDIT: i see this has already been mentioned multiple times. Guess i'm not the only one who remembers being killed by this guy.

Yeah that was Round 2, 2011. Davenport came on as the sub, and only had 4 touches......3 of them resulted in goals to him.

I was actually a fan of J-Dav, bit sad when we de-listed him.

 

[DangerSloane]

Ayce Cordy + Tory Dixon.
Absolute spuds who for some reason kick goals against us every time.
Brad Johnson used to kill us a lot as well...



For us... NM must hate Kerridge.

 

[S120]

Anyone who has played in the midfield or on a flank for Collingwood over the last decade. Alan Didak, Steele Sidebottom, Dale Thomas, Leon Davis, Dane Swan, Dayne Beams, Scott Pendlebury. Take your ****ing pick.

Ablett between about 2007 and his move to Gold Coast seemed to have 35 touches, 2-3 goals and 3 Brownlow votes every time he played us too.

 

[Bosun]

Always some random spud from Carlton who normally can't get a kick and who even Carlton supporters want dropped (until they play us).

Duigan in the final
Mclean sometimes
Casboult somehow

Waite always kills Richmond, have no idea why. He doesn't kick huge bags but seems to take 20 odd marks and give 15 goal assists. It sucks because it gets our hopes up he can do that every week.

 

[Joffaboy]

Unfair question for a Saints supporter.

At the moment the list would be huge.

Lately it has been Junktime Jack (all four quarters are class as junktime against the Saints currently)

In the past McLeod

 

[DrLucienSanchez]

Aaron Joseph saved his best for Cyril Rioli - don't think Cyril ever got into double figures with Joseph playing on him.
Trent Sporn's games on James Hird were the stuff of legend in the early 2000s. Would dominate Hird, smash his shoulder or collarbone, come back just in time for the next Essendon game.

Ty Vickery always turns up against Carlton, then does nothing for a month.
Aaron Sandilands always smashes whatever ruckman we put out there, sometimes on one leg.
Lindsay Thomas....eughhhh....

Jordan Lewis and Brad Sewell smash us physically every time as well.

 

[andrew coombs]

The usual Geelong suspects, Selwood, Bartel, Stevie J, Enight, Taylor etc,etc...

A couple of old Kangaroos in C Jones and Pratt would have been superstars had they played against Hawthorn for a living. Ditto Fraser Gehrig when at the Eagles.