Is Gary Rohan the worst finals player of all time?

Remove this Banner Ad

What is?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com


Your inherent need to bring up Gary Ablett Sr in every discussion you have.
The fact that no one buys your trolling bullshit
The idea that you need to misquote former players to try and support your argument
The sheer weight of evidence that disagrees with the rubbish you post

It’s f**king hilarious 😂😂😂
 
Your inherent need to bring up Gary Ablett Sr in every discussion you have.
The fact that no one buys your trolling bullshit
The idea that you need to misquote former players to try and support your argument
The sheer weight of evidence that disagrees with the rubbish you post

It’s f**king hilarious

Yeah GAS’s finals record is hilarious for sure. Biggest choker in AFL/VFL history. This is factual, it doesn’t matter what people think. Just cope mate. Selwood is your clubs best player since GAJ ditched and played his peak at the suns. I bring him up because the delusion is real from you in regards to him just like any of your players especially Rohan. Gobsmacked you think he’s a good finals player.

Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Yeah GAS’s finals record is hilarious for sure. Biggest choker in AFL/VFL history. This is factual, it doesn’t matter what people think. Just cope mate. Selwood is your clubs best player since GAJ ditched and played his peak at the suns. I bring him up because the delusion is real from you in regards to him just like any of your players especially Rohan. Gobsmacked you think he’s a good finals player.

Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

🤣🤣🤣🤣

It’s like you’ve given up

Even your misquoting is more shithouse than normal
 

Log in to remove this ad.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

It’s like you’ve given up

Even your misquoting is more shithouse than normal

How? You keep responding to me, I obviously bother you. The variance between a players actual skill and perceived skill from cats supporters has got to be the biggest. Maybe only port comes close cause of the SANFL stuff.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
How? You keep responding to me, I obviously bother you. The variance between a players actual skill and perceived skill from cats supporters has got to be the biggest. Maybe only port comes close cause of the SANFL stuff.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com


It’s a forum.

People write, people respond. Not really sure that’s tantamount to being bothered hahahaha. What should it be, an arbitrary list of one post threads where everyone clicks ‘like’?


Where did I say I think he’s a good finals player? Quote me. I said he’s played numerous good finals thus dispelling the myth.

Just making up things and posting them isn’t clever. Even as trolling goes it’s not good quality. Meteoric Rise knows how to do it because he actually is intelligent. He can back up his ruse with knowledge.
 
It’s a forum.

People write, people respond. Not really sure that’s tantamount to being bothered hahahaha. What should it be, an arbitrary list of one post threads where everyone clicks ‘like’?


Where did I say I think he’s a good finals player? Quote me. I said he’s played numerous good finals thus dispelling the myth.

Just making up things and posting them isn’t clever. Even as trolling goes it’s not good quality. Meteoric Rise knows how to do it because he actually is intelligent. He can back up his ruse with knowledge.

Yeah he is intelligent, you should take note cause you have no idea. Can’t even calculate goal accuracy properly and you disregard stats staring you straight in the face. Do you know Rohan had a 1 disposal prelim, 1!!! This good to you buddy?, cause it’s 1 disposal off being the worst game ever played. Who else has done that? find me cause idk.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Yeah he is intelligent, you should take note cause you have no idea. Can’t even calculate goal accuracy properly and you disregard stats staring you straight in the face. Do you know Rohan had a 1 disposal prelim, 1!!! This good to you buddy?, cause it’s 1 disposal off being the worst game ever played. Who else has done that? find me cause idk.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com


Lolllll I was the only one who did any calculation. You just screenshotted a photo of a graphic from an afl.com page 😂😂😂

Total goals divided by total scoring shots is not a miscalculation it’s me literally not knowing that AFL.com has a statistical database that factors in shots that go out on the full or are rushed through for a behind or marked on the line


He had 1 disposal in a preliminary final?

Oh well that changes everything. That fact picks up an eraser and removes his good finals from the record books.


‘Find me coz I don’t know.’

Yes mate I’m aware there’s a lot you don’t know. There is literally a former Geelong three time premiership player who didn’t have a single touch in a grand final, albeit at another club.


The fact that you’re unaware of ‘the Leon Davis Medal’ further highlights your distance from the knowledge database of most football fans. In fact Davis himself has a better claim at this title than Rohan realistically.

Just saying something until you believe it won’t make it right mate no matter how much you want it to.
 
Lolllll I was the only one who did any calculation. You just screenshotted a photo of a graphic from an afl.com page

Total goals divided by total scoring shots is not a miscalculation it’s me literally not knowing that AFL.com has a statistical database that factors in shots that go out on the full or are rushed through for a behind or marked on the line


He had 1 disposal in a preliminary final?

Oh well that changes everything. That fact picks up an eraser and removes his good finals from the record books.


‘Find me coz I don’t know.’

Yes mate I’m aware there’s a lot you don’t know. There is literally a former Geelong three time premiership player who didn’t have a single touch in a grand final, albeit at another club.


The fact that you’re unaware of ‘the Leon Davis Medal’ further highlights your distance from the knowledge database of most football fans. In fact Davis himself has a better claim at this title than Rohan realistically.

Just saying something until you believe it won’t make it right mate no matter how much you want it to.

Pfff so you think calculating wrong is better than finding the actual stat 🤣🤣 Now I’ve heard it all, just give up buddy. Who doesn’t know out on the full counts as a shot wtf lol. Punches I understand but out of the full 🤣🤣

Yeah it does change everything. Nobody should be that bad. EVER. I’ve heard of the Leon Davis Medal. What were the stats of his worst game? He better have 0 disposals somewhere or don’t waste my time cause it’s not as bad a Rohan’s.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Nobody outside Geelong rates Rohan. Fact, he’s your average run of the mill player an on the whole abysmal in finals hence the thread. Get over it, you are beaten.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Agreed but even your average run of the mill player is capable of playing one (actually he did ok for Sydney once) blinder final when they’ve played 26 of them. 24 of those 26 finals he was nothing but one of 44 men selected. Undeniably would have to be up there with the worst premiership players of all time.
 
Pfff so you think calculating wrong is better than finding the actual stat 🤣🤣 Now I’ve heard it all, just give up buddy. Who doesn’t know out on the full counts as a shot wtf lol. Punches I understand but out of the full 🤣🤣

Yeah it does change everything. Nobody should be that bad. EVER. I’ve heard of the Leon Davis Medal. What were the stats of his worst game? He better have 0 disposals somewhere or don’t waste my time cause it’s not as bad a Rohan’s.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

In the absence of an available statistic that I was aware of, what are you suggesting I SHOULD have calculated? I don’t think anyone doesn’t know OOF shots count as shots at goal but I’m also across the fact that almost all data bases don’t record the stat. As I don’t use the AFL website I was unaware they had it. Again, I can only calculate with numbers I am aware of.

He had 0 touches in a grand final the same as a whole heap of players have. Cameron Mooney did it. Alistair Lynch did it. Beau McDonald and Aaron Shattock both did it in the same game (along with Davis). Aaron Keating did it. Troy Simmonds did it.

Hell I wouldn’t want to waste your time 😂😂😂😂
 
Agreed but even your average run of the mill player is capable of playing one (actually he did ok for Sydney once) blinder final when they’ve played 26 of them. 24 of those 26 finals he was nothing but one of 44 men selected. Undeniably would have to be up there with the worst premiership players of all time.

100% thank you for your unbiased opinion. Imo he’s pretty much tied with castanga. Rohans ceiling is higher but his floor is lower. Unless castanga has had a 1 disposal game I am unaware of. I’d only give castanga the edge cause at least he won 3 and is more consistent.

Difference is Richmond fans want Castanga delisted, Cats fans want keep resigning Rohan for some bizzare reason.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
100% thank you for your unbiased opinion. Imo he’s pretty much tied with castanga. Rohans ceiling is higher but his floor is lower. Unless castanga has had a 1 disposal game I am unaware of. I’d only give castanga the edge cause at least he won 3 and is more consistent.

Difference is Richmond fans want Castanga delisted, Cats fans want keep resigning Rohan for some bizzare reason.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
I’m hoping Rohan is completely phased out before finals next year. If a guy such as Ollie Henry for example is supposed to play for us for the next 10 years then truly, I never want to see Rohan in our hoops again.

I’d prefer Castagna over Rohan even if you remove the premierships out of the equation.
 
I’m hoping Rohan is completely phased out before finals next year. If a guy such as Ollie Henry for example is supposed to play for us for the next 10 years then truly, I never want to see Rohan in our hoops again.

I’d prefer Castagna over Rohan even if you remove the premierships out of the equation.

Yep, hopefully you can talk some sense into your fellow cats supporters. But I doubt it.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yep, hopefully you can talk some sense into your fellow cats supporters. But I doubt it.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
About what?

The notion that a player with 8-9 genuinely decent finals performances is now the worst finals player of all time?

😂😂😂😂

Mate he’s not even the worst Geelong finals player of the last 5 years
 
About what?

The notion that a player with 8-9 genuinely decent finals performances is now the worst finals player of all time?



Mate he’s not even the worst Geelong finals player of the last 5 years

So who got 0 disposals then? Who are these players?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
So who got 0 disposals then? Who are these players?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I literally posted half a dozen of them on this page of you bother reading.

And of Geelong players Jordan Murdoch and Esava Ratugolea are both easily far worse finals players than Rohan.

Murdoch’s numbers literally drop by half in finals.

More than 20 per cent of Ratugolea’s touches are clangers in finals (so are Murdoch’s) and for a nominal key forward Ratugolea has had one final where he’s kicked more than a single goal.

You can paint it any way you like.


Trying to say that a player with 8-9 decent finals matches under his belt is the worst finals player of all time when two of his own teammates in the last 5 years have been easily worse highlights the stupidity of your argument.

Who gives a **** if he had a 1 touch game.

Alastair Lynch had a 0 touch game in a grand final.

He must be worse than Rohan using your logic 😂


I guess my criticism of two Geelong players is my bias coming through again right?
 
I literally posted half a dozen of them on this page of you bother reading.

And of Geelong players Jordan Murdoch and Esava Ratugolea are both easily far worse finals players than Rohan.

Murdoch’s numbers literally drop by half in finals.

More than 20 per cent of Ratugolea’s touches are clangers in finals (so are Murdoch’s) and for a nominal key forward Ratugolea has had one final where he’s kicked more than a single goal.

You can paint it any way you like.


Trying to say that a player with 8-9 decent finals matches under his belt is the worst finals player of all time when two of his own teammates in the last 5 years have been easily worse highlights the stupidity of your argument.

Who gives a * if he had a 1 touch game.

Alastair Lynch had a 0 touch game in a grand final.

He must be worse than Rohan using your logic

That’s why I don’t rate the Lions 01-03 team very much. What a dud, only 1 AA too. Least he got 3 flags.

I also never said he was the worst, just up there and a bad finals player.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Last edited:
Yep, hopefully you can talk some sense into your fellow cats supporters. But I doubt it.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
No thanks be like smashing my head against a brick wall. I don’t see anyone saying Rohan isn’t shit. All teams have at least one crap player even threepeats.
 
That’s why I don’t rate the Lions 01-03 team very much. What a dud, only 1 AA too. Least he got 3 flags.

I also never said he was the worst, just up there and a bad finals player.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com


You don’t rate the Lions team of 01-03 because of the performance of a player in his last ever match in the 04 grand final.

Tell the world you know nothing about football without telling the world you j know nothing about football.

Even by your standards this is poor
 
You don’t rate the Lions team of 01-03 because of the performance of a player in his last ever match in the 04 grand final.

Tell the world you know nothing about football without telling the world you j know nothing about football.

Even by your standards this is poor

Out of the 4 AFL dynasty teams I mean. I rate them the least. You’d kill them. You know he was the main KPF yeah? pretty big deal if he is ass in finals.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Yeah he is intelligent, you should take note cause you have no idea. Can’t even calculate goal accuracy properly and you disregard stats staring you straight in the face. Do you know Rohan had a 1 disposal prelim, 1!!! This good to you buddy?, cause it’s 1 disposal off being the worst game ever played. Who else has done that? find me cause idk.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Rohan suffered a hamstring injury in the PF in 2021. Check your facts before misquoting
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Is Gary Rohan the worst finals player of all time?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top