Speculation Ivan Soldo

[Taylor]

His value has declined since he was traded, not increased.

Port traded #29, #41, #49, #72 for Soldo and #50

Let's pretend the #49 and #50 cancel out.

Pick #29, #41 and #72 for Soldo

A second round pick isn't more value, it's less value than he was traded for.

 

[THE_GUN]

Port traded #29, #41, #49, #72 for Soldo and #50

Let's pretend the #49 and #50 cancel out.

Pick #29, #41 and #72 for Soldo

A second round pick isn't more value, it's less value than he was traded for.

In Blair we trust - He gets it done

 

[Darrian Barnett]

Port traded #29, #41, #49, #72 for Soldo and #50

Let's pretend the #49 and #50 cancel out.

Pick #29, #41 and #72 for Soldo

A second round pick isn't more value, it's less value than he was traded for.

Yes but Port severely overpaid...

Looking back on it I can't imagine many port fans think that they won that trade

 

[jumperfan]

If he’s going to cost more then a future third I’d rather look elsewhere

 

[Rich01]

3rd rounder

 

[Taylor]

Yes but Port severely overpaid...

Looking back on it I can't imagine many port fans think that they won that trade

I can understand the idea of paying for the missing piece but their other choice ruck still had Port win the clearances, so at the time it was fine - but now it's not looking great.

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Soldo for jack hayes straight swap cheers

 

[JHF1870]

Contracted.

Be prepared to pay Saints buddies.

Exactly. Don't give us enough then he can play in the SANFL

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Welcome back at the Tigers for pick 72

 

[jackag24]

Yes but Port severely overpaid...

Looking back on it I can't imagine many port fans think that they won that trade

Not sure how you win a trade like this.. sounds more or less like we just want to get a decent pick back.. that's not even breaking even

 

[rye]

probably on decent coin at port

would be surprised if they managed to offload him for anymore than than a late third.

 

[juss]

Port traded #29, #41, #49, #72 for Soldo and #50

Let's pretend the #49 and #50 cancel out.

Pick #29, #41 and #72 for Soldo

A second round pick isn't more value, it's less value than he was traded for.

72 has effectively no value unless its a club that needs points and even then its negligible.

I can't see them getting a pick in the 20s for him now, likely in the 35-45 range, yet they may well just keep him.

 

[Tonythetiger]

The ruck merry-go-round continues... Sweet was traded for pick 50 which is looking alright.

I know it's independent from the Soldo trade but big picture:

Port traded #29, #41, #49, #72 for Soldo and #50, then traded #50 for Sweet. They've solved a need and will get something back for Soldo if a trade does go through.

It's like trading in for Temu Grundy and then shipping him back to China but only getting a partial refund.