Player Watch John Noble

[Kappa]

Sounds like pick 12 will be the equivalent of a much numbered pick next year.

Noble, future first and third rounder for 12 and future second.

What happens when we slide down the ladder next year due to having a very old list and we end up with pick 6 but it's traded out... AGAIN

 

[stormskye]

What happens when we slide down the ladder next year due to having a very old list and we end up with pick 6 but it's traded out... AGAIN

 

[manicpie]

What happens when we slide down the ladder next year due to having a very old list and we end up with pick 6 but it's traded out... AGAIN

We'll just take Mcguane, he's worth pick 6 anyway

 

[sr36]

What happens when we slide down the ladder next year due to having a very old list and we end up with pick 6 but it's traded out... AGAIN

You'll use words like disaster and catastrophe with some big adjectives in front of it.

Meanwhile, the bloke picked at 12 in a strong draft is probably rated similarly to the bloke we would have gotten at 6 in a weaker draft - which we may not have have picked anyway due to trading it into the future draft - another unknown risk as that team might end up having a good year. So ultimately we would have gotten very minor unders for Noble.

Now if we don't crash down the ladder .. and heaven forbid go well ...you work out the rest ...

 

[manicpie]

You use words like disaster and catastrophe with some big adjectives in front of it.

Meanwhile, the bloke picked at 12 in a strong draft is probably rated similarly to the bloke we would have gotten at 6 in a weaker draft - which we may not have have picked anyway due to trading it into the future draft - another unknown risk as that team might end up having a good year. So ultimately we would have gotten very minor unders for Noble.

Now if we don't crash down the ladder .. and heaven forbid go well ...you work out the rest ...

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

What happens when we slide down the ladder next year due to having a very old list and we end up with pick 6 but it's traded out... AGAIN

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

We are Collingwood. Even if we slide down the ladder, we will be back to losing grand finals a few years after that.

 

[sr36]

I can't believe the morons who run this club didn't trade our future first at the end of 2021. We would have gotten a heap for it and only ended up with a disastrous catastrophic pick 18. Non future first trading idiots.

 

[manicpie]

We are Collingwood. Even if we slide down the ladder, we will be back to losing grand finals a few years after that.

Ouch

 

[ClaytonM]

We are Collingwood. Even if we slide down the ladder, we will be back to losing grand finals a few years after that.

I thought we won the last GF we attended or was that just a dream?

 

[Fat Jesus]

I thought we won the last GF we attended or was that just a dream?

Tell him he's dreaming.

 

[VinnieB]

Yeah I am against it because of being burnt twice now but the problem is I think this is the time to do it … IF, we are extracting a value that gives us some sort of upside and not JUST downside like the latest F1 trade.

By this I mean we need a club to be willing to bet we miss finals again and our pick will be around 6-8. And give us value representing this.

I doubt this happens though.

I suppose if it’s true this draft is strong and deep, even if we can get pick 10 would be a good result in this draft.