Josh Kennedy vs Tom Hawkins

[geelong_crazy26]

You seem to be one for topic derailment. As I said, masturbation over your own players belongs in Bay 13, mate. This is between Kennedy and Hawkins, nothing to do with Barry... (even though he's better than both)

Back on topic. If Hawkins wants to be in the same class as Kennedy, he needs to be a presence on the ground. If any of you Geelong nitwits watched a West Coast game, Kennedy does a lot more than camp up forward. He leads up the ground, sets up a lot of goals, has a big tank etc. He also doesn't try fluke assists like Hawkins in the prelim against the Pies. That's not even getting to the fact that he averaged more goals despite a slow start.

its not derailment too far, considering ur a bulldogs supporter, you should be used to hearing about how inferrior your club is by now, so dont get so worked up.

heres a big difference you have to realise between a club like geelong when it comes to development and recruitment and a club such as the western bulldogs, we are professionall about how we operate and run things, hawkins development along with the other young players is in the hands of exceptional staff and a stimulating culture which thrives on success, which is why our side is so good, and players such as hawkins will go on to be superstars and reach their full potential.

unlike down at footscray, we dont have a club that pins its hopes on recruiting nutcases to kick baggs of goals, players like barry hall arent accepted down at geelong, its an entirely different culture, one which breeds stars.

maybe your club should take a note from our pages if it wants to get somewhere

 

[QL 21]

when you are 197cm with one of the largest vertical leaps in the competition, and have strong hands, your a very big prescence anywhere you lead, when hawkins goes up in a pack, opposition keep a watchul eye on him, that is prescence my friend, something only very few forwards have the ability to make on the field, something only J brown has, and going back further forwards like lockett and ablett also had it, something kennedy has zero of and never will have

hawkins is a powerhouse KP forward, somewhat of a very rare type of forward that any team would kill to have.

Stating a players presence is a very flimsy way to win an argument. Especially when they're a second or third year player. Comparing Hawkins to Brown, Lockett and Ablett won't help your cause either.

 

[Inzy]

Hawkins is also as soft as butter mentally which is why JK will always be better.

 

[GrandBlue]

Stating a players presence is a very flimsy way to win an argument. Especially when they're a second or third year player. Comparing Hawkins to Brown, Lockett and Ablett won't help your cause either.

You don't have to quote his nonsence, really. Just say 'tl;dr' because that's all his posts deserve.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Stating a players presence is a very flimsy way to win an argument. Especially when they're a second or third year player. Comparing Hawkins to Brown, Lockett and Ablett won't help your cause either.

who says i am trying to convince you or anyone, i know free chat forums arent the places to go if im seeking someone of credibility intellect and knowledge to discuss with, so really what losers here think isnt of importance.

i just know it is coming, he will be one of the AFL's elite in years to come, and i just want to be the first one to come back and bump this and other threads and laugh at the morons who said otherwise, so please chuck all the " hes fat and no good" stuff this way, keep it coming.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

You don't have to quote his nonsence, really. Just say 'tl;dr' because that's all his posts deserve.

if you ever do want to know what being a success feels like and to see a premiership, then by all means quote one of my posts and ask grandblue, i would be more than happy to tell you all about it sometime before you die

 

[GrandBlue]

who says i am trying to convince you or anyone, i know free chat forums arent the places to go if im seeking someone of credibility intellect and knowledge to discuss with, so really what losers here think isnt of importance.

i just know it is coming, he will be one of the AFL's elite in years to come, and i just want to be the first one to come back and bump this and other threads and laugh at the morons who said otherwise, so please chuck all the " hes fat and no good" stuff this way, keep it coming.

Ha, how pretentious are you? Listen spud, if you think your posts have any credibility here or anywhere else, you're absolutely dreaming. Everyone knows how stupid you really are and judging by your recent posts it's starting to become a solid fact.

and no, Tom Hawkins won't be one of the AFL's elite and he'll likely always be inferior to Kennedy.

if you ever do want to know what being a success feels like and to see a premiership, then by all means quote one of my posts and ask grandblue, i would be more than happy to tell you all about it sometime before you die

Yet again, the standard Bay 13 Geelong troll comes in, so typical coming from stupid people like yourself. Well it's not such a big deal, I don't take it personally one bit. Why? because you're stupid

 

[Jeremias]

GC26 continues to provide us with some laughs.

Kennedy over Hawkins at this stage. Easily.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Ha, how pretentious are you? Listen spud, if you think your posts have any credibility here or anywhere else, you're absolutely dreaming. Everyone knows how stupid you really are and judging by your recent posts it's starting to become a solid fact.

and no, Tom Hawkins won't be one of the AFL's elite and he'll likely always be inferior to Kennedy.



Yet again, the standard Bay 13 Geelong troll comes in, so typical coming from stupid people like yourself. Well it's not such a big deal, I don't take it personally one bit. Why? because you're stupid

once again, lack of success really does damage the brain down at footscray

for me bigfootball is simply a internet forum with alot of pathetic people on it, i couldnt care one bit what anyone on here thinks, but for people who dont have much going for them in the real world such as yourself grandblue, big football is a place that "reputation" means alot. so continue on with the reputation poster stuff all you wish, but that only applies on here for people such as yourself

i have seen success from beggining to finish infront of my eyes, twice, something you wouldnt have any knowledge about, so your in no position to comment on what it looks like grandblue, and tom hawkins has got everything it takes to be the best.

when you have seen every footballing step of one of the greatest teams mold from the very beggining such as this geelong side, you catch an eye for recognizing what real star tallent looks like, but since you only are recognizable to failure, it should be that you reffrain from trying to make judgments out of your area of recognition such as analyzing true tallent such as the tommahawk.

please grand blue, only discuss what you have a clue about, and since you have grown up passionate about a club which knows only failure, dont try and come in here and tell me what success all of a sudden looks like, maybe one day when it bites your mobb on the arse you will figure it out

 

[burto]

Not sure why people are suggesting Hawkins is mentally weak/soft and crumbles under pressure. His final quarter goal in the Grand Final suggests otherwise.

Hawkins has proven himself under pressure. As of yet, Kennedy hasn't had a chance to.

 

[GrandBlue]

once again, lack of success really does damage the brain down at footscray

for me bigfootball is simply a internet forum with alot of pathetic people on it, i couldnt care one bit what anyone on here thinks, but for people who dont have much going for them in the real world such as yourself grandblue, big football is a place that "reputation" means alot. so continue on with the reputation poster stuff all you wish, but that only applies on here for people such as yourself

i have seen success from beggining to finish infront of my eyes, twice, something you wouldnt have any knowledge about, so your in no position to comment on what it looks like grandblue, and tom hawkins has got everything it takes to be the best.

when you have seen every footballing step of one of the greatest teams mold from the very beggining such as this geelong side, you catch an eye for recognizing what real star tallent looks like, but since you only are recognizable to failure, it should be that you reffrain from trying to make judgments out of your area of recognition such as analyzing true tallent such as the tommahawk.

please grand blue, only discuss what you have a clue about, and since you have grown up passionate about a club which knows only failure, dont try and come in here and tell me what success all of a sudden looks like, maybe one day when it bites your mobb on the arse you will figure it out

Sorry, I didn't read this. I'd read it if it were made by any other poster, but you're the most stupid user on this forum and reading your rubbish would waste my time.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Powerful stuff GrandBlue.

'You're stupid, big stupid-head'

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Oh hey! Well if it isn't the stupid **** from the polls board.

You're definitely stupid

Yet again, the standard Bay 13 Geelong troll comes in, so typical coming from stupid people like yourself. Well it's not such a big deal, I don't take it personally one bit. Why? because you're stupid

Stupid media.

Aren't you that idiot who votes Geelong no matter what circumstance in the poll board? Gee, no wonder, you really are stupid.

You're a Geelong Supporter, stupid opinions like yours don't count when you think Gary Handball's the best player in the comp.

The Gamecube has Pokemon Colosseum and Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness. Both are pretty much 3D open world pokemon games. I found them enjoyable and are extremely underrated IMO.

Time to expand your vocabulary, genius.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Sorry, I didn't read this. I'd read it if it were made by any other poster, but you're the most stupid user on this forum and reading your rubbish would waste my time.

sorry, i cant help it that i support a side that is better than yours, face the fact grandblue, you are anti geelong because this bulldogs team is the best you have ever had,and its not good enough to compete against this geelong outfit.

 

[GrandBlue]

Time to expand your vocabulary, genius.

Haha, you put in all that effort just so you could troll me.

You're stupid

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Haha, you put in all that effort just so you could troll me.

You're stupid

And you're a waste of bandwidth.

 

[GrandBlue]

And you're a waste of bandwidth.

No, u.

Quit trying too hard.

 

[QL 21]

who says i am trying to convince you or anyone, i know free chat forums arent the places to go if im seeking someone of credibility intellect and knowledge to discuss with, so really what losers here think isnt of importance.

Nice sweeping generalisation.

i just know it is coming, he will be one of the AFL's elite in years to come, and i just want to be the first one to come back and bump this and other threads and laugh at the morons who said otherwise, so please chuck all the " hes fat and no good" stuff this way, keep it coming.

How gracious of you.

 

[Hodgepodge]

Wonder if the Geelong fans will still argue Hawkins is ahead?

Hawkins 2 games at FF in winning sides. 2 goals.

Kennedy 2 games at CHF in losing sides. 6 goals.

 

[BONG RIPS MKII]

kennedy is ahead, but he has been in the system longer, and hasn't had injuries as severe as hawkins

also, hawkins has been playing chf this year hodgepodge

 

[WCE9II9406]

kennedy is ahead, but he has been in the system longer, and hasn't had injuries as severe as hawkins

also, hawkins has been playing chf this year hodgepodge

Hawkins was never 'carltoned' though.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

If Hawkins was the number 1 target I'm sure he'd have kicked a few more goals. As it is we go to Mooney and Johnson first.

and lol at Hawkins being FF, nice one podgey.

 

[EagleMan87]

If Hawkins was the number 1 target I'm sure he'd have kicked a few more goals. As it is we go to Mooney and Johnson first.

and lol at Hawkins being FF, nice one podgey.

If West Coast's midfield could actually hit a target I'm sure Kennedy would have kicked more goals.

 

[Hodgepodge]

If Hawkins was the number 1 target I'm sure he'd have kicked a few more goals. As it is we go to Mooney and Johnson first.

Same goes with Kennedy. LeCras would be the No.1 target at West Coast.

Hawkins is pretty much a FF, although he does switch with Mooney occasionally.

Been disappointing this year after the Cat fans were hyping him up over the summer.

 

[beatlesmith]

its amazing how much damage lack of success can do to your brain down at footscray

it is pretty much a given that he will be a 80+ full forward, dont care how many goals he has kicked to date or figures, his tallent and ability if nurtured right will get there sooner or later, simply a matter of time, if not this year then the next, but he will end up being one of the AFL's best, kennedy simply wont, he isnt as naturally gifted or tallented as tom hawkins is, doesnt have that extra ability to take it up a level further.

....Just. Like. Mcdougall.