18 for Dixon pls. Carey and Lloyd were great forwards and Jeremy Cameron will be held in a similar regard once his career finishes.
Plus, Dixon deserves first dibs. He's a proven forward, whereas Toumpas is merely unfulfilled talent at the moment.
That's a bit harsh on Toumpas, state U18 Captain where as Dixon sounds like he picked up a footy at the age of 20 or so who was from a basketball background. However, Dixon has brawn and agility with excellent hand skills, Toumpas on the other hand is only missing the brawn but he has the foot skills.
If you are basing your opinion on the #18 with Carey and Lloyd doesn't quite fit as to how other view this because the #18 in Port according to many here is that you take on that number to continue on that legacy and whereby the #1 is worn by the capitano. Correct me if I am wrong, your suggestion is that they are all KPF, but your working on the lines of the world game where the #10 is THE number to wear. Is that where your coming from? If so, I get it.... but I don't think it will go down well with the AFL true die hards who have the teal coloured glasses on.
So if we go by the True Port way, Toumpas wears the #18....