Luke Shuey or Michael Hurley

[Lance Uppercut]

two outstanding players from the 08 draft. Hurley has shown a lot of promise at both ends of the ground as a KPP; whereas Shuey, whilst overcoming significant hurdles, is an outstanding in and out midfielder.

Who would you prefer for the remainder of their careers?

 

[Bring-Back-Powell]

Hurley by the length of the Flemington straight!

 

[Lance Uppercut]

Hurley by the length of the Flemington straight!

so why did you vote for Shuey then?

 

[Igloo]

Definitely Hurley. Quality KPP, especially those that can play both ends of the ground, are damn hard to find.

Shuey is no slouch though, good player.

 

[Flinch]

No doubt Shuey is going to be a dead set gun. But I would take Hurley every time, key forwards of his quality are quite rare. Still love you Shueman

 

[Jade]

Hurley, without any doubt whatsoever.

And thats no criticism of Shuey, whom I'd love at Essendon - certainly not at the expense of Hurley though.

 

[WCEbrody]

Much like the Darling vs Heppel thread, KPP>midfielders...Shuey is a gun though.

 

[Gazza_11]

Hurley and not just because of positions. This kid is extremely talented, will be an absolute freak of a player.

 

[Rocky_Star_Pro]

Hurley is a potentially supreme KPP, I'd love Shuey in my side but KPP with this much talent you simply cannot turn down

 

[GordonBlue]

I'd take Hurley over Shuey the same way I'd take Buddy over Gaz Jnr

 

[Mattman93]

Voted Shuey because we're pretty set for KPP's, but he's our only genuine young mid who's shown he could be a deadset star.

Expect most others to vote Hurley, and rightly so.

 

[tesseract]

Voted for Shuey because it's what WC need, atm. Given a clean slate, though, KPP gun > midfield gun.

Agree with GordonBlue's reasoning.

 

[Liam Boy]

Hurley, but really just because North have enough midfielders and a KPP like him would be really useful.

 

[Dan]

Hurley I predict will be a top 10 player in a couple years and for that reason I have him ahead of Shuey.