Make an argument that Judd is not the dirtiest player in the game.

[Chief]

certainly not 'hysterical' to believe Judd had sinister intentions based on the evidence.

Hysterical to claim he intended to dislocate the arm and is the dirtiest player around and should be kicked out of the league... etc etc etc etc

 

[Chief]

Mate i am done with this because you do not have enough knowledge to argue about this properly, i know you think you do and that is the most frighting part.

Anywayyyyyy... SRP board or ban from main board? You decide.

 

[Max zero]

Anywayyyyyy... SRP board or ban from main board? You decide.

Can it, this topic is done. I will miss the Scientology hilarity though.

 

[Max zero]

Hysterical to claim he intended to dislocate the arm and is the dirtiest player around and should be kicked out of the league... etc etc etc etc

I think we can point to many posts on both sides that are embarrassing (eg your quote) I just object to the idea that Judd had sinister intentions (perhaps very sinister) should be dismissed out of hand.

I don't think it was an accident.

 

[Syd]

Excuse please I meant here - big footy - didn't realize I would need to make that so crystal clear, nevertheless there you go. Hope I'm clear now.

So did I: http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/forums/society-religion-and-politics.46/

didn't realize I would need to make that so crystal clear, nevertheless there you go. Hope I'm clear now.


15,000+ threads too BTW

 

[PieBeast]

Intended to cause him a bit of momentary pain or discomfort as happens in many tackles in footy, not injury. And I don't think the whole object was to cause pain, just a shade above disregard for the possibility.

In other words the same intentions to Wellingham's, the difference being only one of them chose a regular way of doing it and had the guts to admit it?
Makes your statement about me 'not getting it' even more hilarious.

 

[AngryLittleMan]

Judd says he had no intention of hurting anyone. Wellingham said he intended to harm, but not break anything. Why should we believe Wellingham but not Judd?

Take it further: If you killed someone, would it make a difference if you said you wanted to hurt someone but not kill them?

*Face palm* If he wasn't trying to hurt him then what do you think he was doing Chief?

 

[Chief]

Read my posts above.

 

[Chief]

In other words the same intentions to Wellingham's, the difference being only one of them chose a regular way of doing it and had the guts to admit it?

Only one of them sent their full weight at the other player's head, yeah?

Seems to be a bit of a mix up here - every question I pose is taken as an unshakeable conviction. Chill a bit and READ what I've said instead of letting the mist of outrage fog your glasses.

 

[PieBeast]

Only one of them sent their full weight at the other player's head, yeah?

Seems to be a bit of a mix up here - every question I pose is taken as an unshakeable conviction. Chill a bit and READ what I've said instead of letting the mist of outrage fog your glasses.

I'm calm as it gets mate, Judd's penalty was reasonably adequate IMO.
Just find it bewildering that last night you tried to use Wellingham's admission "I didn't mean to hurt him that much" to paint him as some sort of super villain when you know fully well he didn't mean to break Simpson's jaw, just like Judd didn't mean to dislocate Adams' shoulder. Wellingham was trying to make Simpson earn it and its all gone wrong while Judd was fully aware that bending defenseless player's hand backwards would hurt like hell. Both of them knew exactly what they were doing and are now paying the price but like I said before, only one of them admitted it.

 

[Biffinator]

Just re-watched Judd's disgusting chicken-wing yank on Adams. What a disgrace. These cheap, cowardly shots are a blight on his career.

 

[Righteo]

Just re-watched Judd's disgusting chicken-wing yank on Adams. What a disgrace. These cheap, cowardly shots are a blight on his career.

That's probably the least villainous out of his string of dirty acts too.

 

[Brain Power]

That's probably the least villainous out of his string of dirty acts too.

The sad thing is that the MRP would probably give this reckless, medium impact thread bump more weeks than Judd has had in his entire career.

 

[TBoyleSuperstar]

I think it's just good that Judd didn't play in the 80s, when there weren't as many cameras around. God knows what he would have got up to then

 

[Kanga87]

A champion player no doubt (especially at the eagles), speaks well in the media and is an intelligent man. But probably the dirtiest player in the modern era. The chicken wing on leigh adams was the most disgusting thing i have ever seen in 20 years of watching the sport. I have no respect for the bloke and I think a majority of football fans feel the same.

 

[Silvagnis]

Bay 13 must be down.

 

[The Joker]

Case in point.

*I thought this was the bay.

 

[Illinois Nazi]

He is certainly quite the campaigner.

 

[libsug]

Judd had the biggest heel turn outside of professional wrestling when he joined Carlton.

 

[Dugdale2Dwyer]

They showed highlights of Judd from todays vfl, good lord, he looks like a 50 year old man bald, pale and thin, but the commetators said he was crashing packs winning the footy etc, just give it away Chris.

 

[Doss]

Didn't need a bump. Closed.