Marc Murphy or Brett Deledio?

[carn tigez]

it was still better and against better opposition that deledio's round one and round three games.

against collingwood:

Lids - 33 disp, 1 goal 94% eff

murphy - 18 disp, 0 goal 61% eff

hahahahahahahhaa

 

[brett15]

Yet to play a game as bad as Deledio in round one or three though. In his career.

and with his rd4 game we could go back and forth once more but I digress. getting pretty pointless this 1upmanship after each game.

 

[jonoman89]

Against Collingwood:

Lids - 33 Disp, 1 goal 94% eff

Murphy - 18 Disp, 0 goal 61% eff

Murphy was in the guts and had as much effectiveness as Swan, Pendles and a whole host of other elite players in a tough, contested, scrappy match with a 24 pt margin.

Deledio got a heap of kicks off half-back in a 10+ goal loss.

Terrible, terrible comparison.

 

[freq]

Battle of the downhill skiers.. this is a tough one, I picked Deledio because he has never played in a good team. (well neither has murphy)

 

[StringyDog]

Went alright tonight against quality opposition. ball use was elite

Pity he can't back it up weeke to week, based on this years form he will have another stinker next week as he has had 2 great games and 2 pathetic Tambling like games

 

[Rustof]

Murphy was in the guts and had as much effectiveness as Swan, Pendles and a whole host of other elite players in a tough, contested, scrappy match with a 24 pt margin.

Deledio got a heap of kicks off half-back in a 10+ goal loss.

Terrible, terrible comparison.

How is it a terrible comparison. Did you not read the OP?

Here it is:

Having this argument with a few Carlton fans, simply put who is a better player? Not a better midfielder or better goal scorer, but better all round player?

Deledio was the better all round player against Collingwood. Simple.

 

[theflea]

this theory of getting cheap kicks off half back is rubbish considering that with the press the pack is at the ball most of the time.

 

[Tribal]

Deledio has an elite game and all you carlflogs still find an excuse to critisize him. Poor form guys.

 

[brett15]

Murphy was in the guts and had as much effectiveness as Swan, Pendles and a whole host of other elite players in a tough, contested, scrappy match with a 24 pt margin.

way to talk out your ass, murphy last week went missing and even you said this

Tonight was Murphy's worst game in 2-3 years

 

[Hipster Doofus]

Against Collingwood:

Lids - 33 Disp, 1 goal 94% eff

Murphy - 18 Disp, 0 goal 61% eff

You don't see ownage like this anymore

 

[TheCuzEffect]

Brett Deledio Vs Collingwood 33 disposals 95% efficent. Nuff said.

 

[jonoman89]

way to talk out your ass, murphy last week went missing and even you said this

He did. I'm not defending him.

But to say Deledio is clearly better because of 33 cheap kicks on a half-back line in a 12 goal loss is something to behold then you have issues.

Guess you liked Joel Bowden as well? He did that kind of stuff regularly.

Murphy's in an under stuff today was brilliant. Kicked a clutch goal with 5 minutes left.

 

[theflea]

He did. I'm not defending him.

But to say Deledio is clearly better because of 33 cheap kicks on a half-back line in a 12 goal loss is something to behold then you have issues.

Guess you liked Joel Bowden as well? He did that kind of stuff regularly.

Murphy's in an under stuff today was brilliant. Kicked a clutch goal with 5 minutes left.

if you think thats where he got his 33p's i suggest you look at the tape again.

 

[Simmonds2Hislop]

He did. I'm not defending him.

But to say Deledio is clearly better because of 33 cheap kicks on a half-back line in a 12 goal loss is something to behold then you have issues.

Guess you liked Joel Bowden as well? He did that kind of stuff regularly.

Murphy's in an under stuff today was brilliant. Kicked a clutch goal with 5 minutes left.

Maybe just drop it this week. You clearly didn't watch the game. Go to the bigfooty medal voting board and have a look at who's getting the votes there.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Murphy was in the guts and had as much effectiveness as Swan, Pendles and a whole host of other elite players in a tough, contested, scrappy match with a 24 pt margin.

Deledio got a heap of kicks off half-back in a 10+ goal loss.

Terrible, terrible comparison.

Deledio was the main reason we got within 4 goals in the 3rd term

 

[The Edukator]

Deledio was the main reason we got within 4 goals in the 3rd term

the main reason you got within 4 goals is because collingwood stopped playing. copped a spray a 3QT and then went back to business as evident by the final scoreline.

 

[Hipster Doofus]

the main reason you got within 4 goals is because collingwood stopped playing. copped a spray a 3QT and then went back to business as evident by the final scoreline.

So, you don't think we were the main part in kicking 6 goals to 2 in the 3rd qtr???

 

[Patron]

So, you don't think we were the main part in kicking 6 goals to 2 in the 3rd qtr???

I think you were half the reason. There are two teams out there. Its irrelevant though Deledio was just very good today i don't think that's really debatable.

 

[Slattery_20]

Murphy pretty damned good for Carlton on the weekend. Didn't see the second half of Pies/Tigs but Dids was quiet to the half.

 

[theflea]

Murphy pretty damned good for Carlton on the weekend. Didn't see the second half of Pies/Tigs but Dids was quiet to the half.

lids 33p at 94%. missed a great 3rd q

 

[jonoman89]

*Regulatory weekly bump*

Murphy: 34 disposals (12 contested), 7 tackles, 6 i50s. Clear BOG.

Lovely.

 

[Blueboys7]

Yeah...can we just lock this for now?

It's getting bumped with every game played by either player.

Bump it at the middle or end of the year.

 

[The Edukator]

Yeah...can we just lock this for now?

It's getting bumped with every game played by either player.

Bump it at the middle or end of the year.

if you dont like it dont look at it. simple as that so quit complaining.

murphy VG tonight and should take the 3 votes as BOG. once again clearly demonstrating why is is superior to Deledio. the only thing missing from his game tonight was a goal

 

[Blueboys7]

if you dont like it dont look at it. simple as that so quit complaining.

murphy VG tonight and should take the 3 votes as BOG. once again clearly demonstrating why is is superior to Deledio. the only thing missing from his game tonight was a goal

You must be happy that GC won their first game?

 

[The Edukator]

You must be happy that GC won their first game?

And you obviously haven't read this entire thread.