McVeigh Report

Remove this Banner Ad

^ because I am truly amazed that he would have that as his sig. as I said, people will decide not to take him seriously before they've even read what he has to say. it immediately paints him as an idiot.
 
Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite said:
^ because I am truly amazed that he would have that as his sig. as I said, people will decide not to take him seriously before they've even read what he has to say. it immediately paints him as an idiot.
Click to expand...

Take it up with him personally via a PM. We don't need to read you two bickering over bullshit.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

nohairandfair said:
McVeigh didn't even have the good sense to have a fistful of jumper when laying one on the jaw of Rivers..

Intentional Conduct (three points), High Contact (2 points), Low Impact (1 point)

A Level Two Offence, 125 demerits, and a one game suspension.
Click to expand...

I'd take that for sure. Come on guys he punched him in the jaw. No it wasn't a haymaker but it was an intentional jab. A reduced penalty to a repremand is really the best I think we can hope for. As for other incidents I think we can all agree the tribunal & MRP are an inconsistant joke.
 
Did I hear Metal Arms? how awesome are they. we need more players with Metal Arms at Essendon, like Daniel Rich. Metal Arms>everything
 
Donakebab said:
Haymakers? McVeigh was clearly trying to grab Jared Rivers' jumper and straighen up his collar. Standard argy bargey, repreimand at most.
Click to expand...

Nah there was a bee on his collar...Mark was just trying to make sure he didn't get stung and suffer potential allergy issues.

Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite said:
Ok so obviously your sig is about Carlton. Lets make direct comparisons.

When it says "without breaking the rules" you're obviously referring to the salary cap. Do you deny that Essendon themselves haven't breached the salary cap before? You guys were infact handed a record punishment at the time. So if you claim Carlton broke the rules, surely you have to then admit that Essendon too broke the rules?

Then the "buying champions" bit is clearly referring to our signing of Judd. Considering Essendon tried to sign Judd as well, how does that make you guys any different to us? We both wanted the same thing, only difference was that Judd chose our club over yours. Infact Essendon were the 3rd club (at best) that he wanted to go to.

For an Essendon supporter to be having that as their sig is probably the most hypocritical thing ive seen in a while. That sig relates just as much to Essendon as it does to Carlton.

Now obviously your temptation is going to be to reply with some random, crappy insult about Carlton in general, so I challenge you to show you have an IQ higher than that, and address the points directly (unfortunately, i'm not expecting you to be able to)
Click to expand...

I always thought that sig was highlighting possibly the only suggestion Nathan Q Brown has ever made that suggests he might have even an iota of respect for Essendon...but if you want to make it about Carlton that's your prerogative. It's always about you.
 
Re: Poll question

Who is the better player out of Rob murphy and mark williams from hawthorn, keep in mind its over there entire careers to date
 

Remove this Banner Ad

McVeigh Report

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top