Off-topic Most overated bands and singers in history- Part 1

Remove this Banner Ad

WA ROO said:
Megadeth
Dave Mustaine is a flog

OT
Things in music that should have never happened is the new Linkin Park
Click to expand...

Mustaine may be a flog, but he's a genius. Rust In Peace is my goat. I do think that with music genius and a temperamental nature can go hand in hand; Schuldiner also had a lot of turnover, but Death is the goat DM band (Leprosy and The Sound of Perseverance both in my top 20).
 
The Bee Gees, esp after one of the flog brothers (possibly Barry) had a meltdown after a comedian made a joke about his brother being in a coma at the time as "Staying' Alive'

Also all the BGs songs suck btw
 

Log in to remove this ad.

okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
 
mcgrath_truther said:
okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
Click to expand...
Yes to Mingus and Pet Sounds
 
mcgrath_truther said:
okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
Click to expand...

Appreciate the Boris and Pig Destroyer noms.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Aristotle Pickett said:
Yes to Mingus and Pet Sounds
Click to expand...
i think overall i prefer mingus x5 but black saint is probably the closest to perfection a jazz album can realistically get. simply amazing
 
mcgrath_truther said:
okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
Click to expand...
Not into Jazz myself, but one of my mates is a muso who’s into it and his old dog is called Mingus.
 
mcgrath_truther said:
very glad i got to see boris when they were in melbourne most recently, absolutely insane
Click to expand...

Yeah I was at that too. Have also caught Pig Destroyer before.
 
Jazny said:
I really like the melody of Smells like Teen Spirit. If it was in a nicer sounding song, it would be quite beautiful.
Click to expand...
 
mcgrath_truther said:
okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
Click to expand...
thoughts Jazny!!!!
 
mcgrath_truther said:
okay my top 10!!!!

All time (in no order)
1) since i left you - the avalanches (2000) [plunderphonics]
2) pet sounds - the beach boys (1966) [baroque pop]
3) amplifier worship - boris (1998) [stoner metal]
4) human = garbage - dystopia (1994) [sludge metal, crust punk]
5) untrue - burial (2007) [garage bass, dubstep]
6) 月の癒し、海の魔法 (Tsuki no iyashi, umi no mahou) - dream dolphin (1998) [acid trance]
7) loveless - my bloody valentine (1991) [shoegaze]
8) emotion - carly rae jepsen (2015) [pop]
9) velocity : comfort : design - sweet trip (2003) [idm, shoegaze]
10) the black saint and the sinner lady - charles mingus (1963) [jazz]

Last year (in no order)
1) dance tonight! revolution tomorrow - orchid (2000) [screamo]
2) solitude - lord snow (2013) [screamo]
3) the aftermath - dystopia (1999) [sludge metal, crust punk]
4) prowler in the yard - pig destroyer (2001) [grindcore]
5) quebec - ween (2003) [art pop]
6) ready and willing - viper (2006) [experimental hiphop]
7) Армагеддон-попс - Гражданская оборона (Grazhdanskaya Oborona) (1989) [noise rock, post-punk]
8) god's country - chat pile (2022) [sludge metal]
9) jane doe - converge (2001) [metalcore]
10) selftitled - dropdead (1993) [hardcore punk]

that's most of it, but it's constantly changing, the sole honourable mention is xiu xiu does the music of twin peaks, very, very good album
Click to expand...
mcgrath_truther said:
thoughts Jazny!!!!
Click to expand...
Needs more Carley Rae Jepson :eekv1:

Lots of Screamo music and metal?

But I should really try and listen to the Beach Boys, lots of people have that album in their top albums. I have only ever heard of Kokomo though. Which reminds me I should watch the movie Cocktail too.
 
Jazny said:
Needs more Carley Rae Jepson :eekv1:

Lots of Screamo music and metal?

But I should really try and listen to the Beach Boys, lots of people have that album in their top albums. I have only ever heard of Kokomo though. Which reminds me I should watch the movie Cocktail too.
Click to expand...
screamo is good, makes me remember just how much i enjoy teaching!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Off-topic Most overated bands and singers in history- Part 1

Similar threads

Aristotle Pickett
Are Chris and Brad Scott the most corrupt brothers in AFL history?
2
Replies
33
Views
699
Meteoric Rise
Meteoric Rise
Aristotle Pickett
Think Tank Is Patrick Cripps the most overated Carlton player of all time?
Replies
19
Views
412
Saveloy Rockstar
Saveloy Rockstar
catscratchfever
flggr The most embarrassing player name in AFL/VFL history: 17thmond’s Steely Green, take a bow
2
Replies
42
Views
2K
frggr
frggr
Saveloy Rockstar
  • Poll
Game Day Most egregious goal over-celebrater?
2
Replies
41
Views
1K
Saveloy Rockstar
Saveloy Rockstar
Aristotle Pickett
Think Tank Is Horse Longmire the most overated coach of the last 50 years?
2
Replies
28
Views
895
Saveloy Rockstar
Saveloy Rockstar
seasonedsainter
Famous chokes in history
Replies
19
Views
409
Saveloy Rockstar
Saveloy Rockstar
Jazny
Off-topic The Greatest Scenes in Cinematic History!
2
Replies
48
Views
835
Elmer_Hauser
Elmer_Hauser

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top