Competition MOTW 2: Poll A

[Ochre]

gava 93

ROates

BIGDAZR

LeeARM

Muse

shanenine

craegus

cory676

Willo #6

drawza

ThunderPower 14

Liam Boy

Gibbsyspin

onyacoxy

GANTY

 

[Ochre]

PortAdelaide

Furla 81

pie machine

Paulie G

aidancdaman

 

[EBUS]

F me there are some quality designs this week, was really hard to pick but I went with LeeARM, there were easily another 5 or 6 I could've voted for.

 

[LiverpoolRed]

shanenine - takes it in my opinion created everything from scratch, what a champ, nice design.

 

[EBUS]

it's a good design but there is no WC in the jumper.

 

[LiverpoolRed]

it's a good design but there is no WC in the jumper.

Yes there is, ther is the stripe down the middle, the tiger head replacing the eagle head (the tiger head is in the same style as the eagle head), there are the wings on the back and the colours represent the WA team colours and the fact that it is using puma. You gatta look at it for what it is not what the colours are.

 

[EBUS]

Yes there is, ther is the stripe down the middle, the tiger head replacing the eagle head (the tiger head is in the same style as the eagle head), there are the wings on the back and the colours represent the WA team colours and the fact that it is using puma. You gatta look at it for what it is not what the colours are.

Firstly I wouldnt exactly call that a stripe, call me crazy but how is the tiger the same style as the eagle head?. Sure WC keep the name but imo it isnt enough to keep WC fans happy.

 

[Gibbsy]

Thunder Power for me. Just looks right with the colours and those style of guernseys.

Also coxy could you please fix up Muse's picture (split it or something) cos it's screwing up the whole orientation of the page

 

[pie_machine]

I like craegus', leearm's and onyacoxy's, but my favourite was cory's.

 

[coolknot]

Voted for Gibbsy.

 

[Gibbsy]

Voted for Gibbsy.

Cheers coolknot

 

[Willo #6]

Thunderpower for me, love Cory's though too

 

[Ochre]

Yes there is, ther is the stripe down the middle,

that doesnt say west coast

the tiger head replacing the eagle head (the tiger head is in the same style as the eagle head)

that doesnt say west coast

there are the wings on the back

barely

and the colours represent the WA team colours

that doesnt say west coast

and the fact that it is using puma.

that doesnt say west coast anymore than hawthorn or brisbane

 

[Ochre]

Also coxy could you please fix up Muse's picture (split it or something) cos it's screwing up the whole orientation of the page

huh?
its fine for me

 

[Willo #6]

Agree with all those points Coxy. It's a great design but just doesn't really seem West Coast to me.

 

[just_kick_it]

My first choice is Gibbsy but only just over onyacoxy.

Honourable mentions to aidan and cory for his away design.

 

[Smeagle]

shanenine - takes it in my opinion created everything from scratch, what a champ, nice design.

Really?

(Hamilton Tigercats - Canadian Football League)





As for my vote, this was another really hard descision.
I liked the creativity of GANTY, the simplicity of onyacoxy and the uber-coolness of craegus (probably not enough connections between the clubs for me, this time).

However, I'm going to have to go for cory again... but only by a wasp's you-know-what

 

[just_kick_it]

Really?

(Hamilton Tigercats - Canadian Football League)





As for my vote, this was another really hard descision.
I liked the creativity of GANTY, the simplicity of onyacoxy and the uber-coolness of craegus (probably not enough connections between the clubs for me, this time).

However, I'm going to have to go for cory again... but only by a wasp's you-know-what

Thanks Smeagle. I think that's what Im going to try and do for this comp, think outside the square a bit like you do.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Wow! Votes! Thanks dudes.

Voted for LeeArm, lots of solid entries though.

 

[shanenine]

Really?

(Hamilton Tigercats - Canadian Football League)





As for my vote, this was another really hard descision.
I liked the creativity of GANTY, the simplicity of onyacoxy and the uber-coolness of craegus (probably not enough connections between the clubs for me, this time).

However, I'm going to have to go for cory again... but only by a wasp's you-know-what

I never said that I did everything from scratch for the logo!!

 

[shanenine]

Agree with all those points Coxy. It's a great design but just doesn't really seem West Coast to me.

For me it does not have either previous teams elements dominate in the jumper, that's what I think merger should be like, base things on the merger and make a new jumper / logo for the future.

ie. as I originally said, black & yellow are the WA state colours and also are the richmond colours.

I would of thought that being the first club in the vfl/afl to represent WA they would jump at the opportunity to wear the state colours exclusively.

 

[Smeagle]

I never said that I did everything from scratch for the logo!!

No, I know you didn't say that - Liverpool Red did. Twice.

 

[LiverpoolRed]

No, I know you didn't say that - Liverpool Red did. Twice.

I assumed he did, because of the convo we haid in the main thread.

 

[PaulieG]

Hi Coxy,
I know it won't make any difference to the voting, but my entries in Poll A and Poll D are both the same image. Unfortunately my first entry never got to the poll. Sorry for not bringing this up earlier, but I was away on work this week and just realized the poll was on.
Cheers,
PaulieG

 

[Ochre]

Hi Coxy,
I know it won't make any difference to the voting, but my entries in Poll A and Poll D are both the same image. Unfortunately my first entry never got to the poll. Sorry for not bringing this up earlier, but I was away on work this week and just realized the poll was on.
Cheers,
PaulieG

shit sorry

will put your first entry staright into the final