My best guernsey number team!

[Russian]

Started from scratch...

1. Barry Hall (SYD)
2. Chris Johnson (BRI)
3. Michael Voss (BRI)
4. Paul Hasleby (FRE)
5. James Hird (ESS)
6. Brad Johnson (WB)
7. Scott West (WB)
8. Lance Whitnall (CAR)
9. Ben Cousins (WC)
10. Paul Williams (SYD)
11. Alastair Lynch (BRI)
12. Nick Riewoldt (STK)
13. Adam Yze (MEL)
14. Luke Ball (STK)
15. Mal Michael (BRI)
16. Warren Tredrea (PTA)
17. Tadgh Kennelly (SYD)
18. Matthew Lloyd (ESS)
19. Michael O'Loughlin (SYD)
20. Simon Black (BRI)
21. Leo Barry (SYD)
22. Chris Scott (BRI)
23. Andrew McLeod (ADE)
24. Mark Coughlan (RIC)
25. Scott Lucas (ESS)
26. Ben Johnson (COL)
27. Clark Keating (BRI)
28. Kane Johnson (RIC)
29. Matthew Pavlich (FRE)
30. Matthew Scarlett (GEE)
31. Dustin Fletcher (ESS)
32. Mark Ricciuto (ADE)
33. Phillip Matera (WC)
34. Paul Medhurst (FRE)
35. Chad Cornes (PTA)
36. Simon Goodwin (ADE)
37. Adam Goodes (SYD)
38. Roger James (PTA)
39. Andrew Kellaway (RIC)
40. Chris Ladhams (ADE)
41. Brent Staker (WC)
42. Robert Haddrill (Fre)
43. Anthony Koutoufides (Car)
44. Nigel Lappin (Bri)
45. Cameron Ling (Gee)
46. Trent Carroll (WC)
47. Laurence Angwin (Car)

4 - Adelaide
8 - Brisbane
3 - Carlton
1 - Collingwood
4 - Essendon
4 - Fremantle
2 - Geelong
0 - Hawthorn
0 - Kangaroos
1 - Melbourne
3 - Port Adelaide
3 - Richmond
2 - St Kilda
6 - Sydney
4 - West Coast
2 - Western Bulldogs

 

[Lidge]

# 6 - Grant > Johnson
# 7 - Simpson > West

 

[gold cup 1996]

Originally posted by Russian
Started from scratch...

1. Barry Hall (SYD)
2. Chris Johnson (BRI)
3. Michael Voss (BRI)
4. Paul Hasleby (FRE)
5. James Hird (ESS)
6. Brad Johnson (WB)
7. Scott West (WB)
8. Lance Whitnall (CAR)
9. Ben Cousins (WC)
10. Paul Williams (SYD)
11. Alastair Lynch (BRI)
12. Nick Riewoldt (STK)
13. Adam Yze (MEL)
14. Luke Ball (STK)
15. Mal Michael (BRI)
16. Warren Tredrea (PTA)
17. Tadgh Kennelly (SYD)
18. Matthew Lloyd (ESS)
19. Michael O'Loughlin (SYD)
20. Simon Black (BRI)
21. Leo Barry (SYD)
22. Chris Scott (BRI)
23. Andrew McLeod (ADE)
24. Mark Coughlan (RIC)
25. Scott Lucas (ESS)
26. Ben Johnson (COL)
27. Clark Keating (BRI)
28. Kane Johnson (RIC)
29. Matthew Pavlich (FRE)
30. Matthew Scarlett (GEE)
31. Dustin Fletcher (ESS)
32. Mark Ricciuto (ADE)
33. Phillip Matera (WC)
34. Paul Medhurst (FRE)
35. Chad Cornes (PTA)
36. Simon Goodwin (ADE)
37. Adam Goodes (SYD)
38. Roger James (PTA)
39. Andrew Kellaway (RIC)
40. Chris Ladhams (ADE)
41. Brent Staker (WC)
42. Robert Haddrill (Fre)
43. Anthony Koutoufides (Car)
44. Nigel Lappin (Bri)
45. Cameron Ling (Gee)
46. Trent Carroll (WC)
47. Laurence Angwin (Car)

4 - Adelaide
8 - Brisbane
3 - Carlton
1 - Collingwood
4 - Essendon
4 - Fremantle
2 - Geelong
0 - Hawthorn
0 - Kangaroos
1 - Melbourne
3 - Port Adelaide
3 - Richmond
2 - St Kilda
6 - Sydney
4 - West Coast
2 - Western Bulldogs

Which team is 2nd on the ladder & has no players in this side?
This is a better side

S. Grant in for B. Johnson even though I rate Johnson highly
A. Simpson in for West
D. Wells in for Whitnall
G. Archer in for A. Lynch

 

[EssJayW]

Tarrant or Black???

 

[underthebridge]

Barry Hall Vs Michael Gardiner

Everyone seems to be picking Barry Hall ahead of Michael Gardiner......So if u were offered one of these 2 players which one would u take? which one is a better player? im just interested to see which player people would prefer, i always thought Gardiner would be rated higher than Hall.

 

[Fitzy #1]

i think daniel wells is far better than any other number 8's in the competion

 

[leonmagic]

Originally posted by Fitzy #1
i think daniel wells is far better than any other number 8's in the competion

James Clement?

 

[EssJayW]

Originally posted by leonmagic
James Clement?

 

[leonmagic]

Originally posted by Russian
17. Tadgh Kennelly (SYD)

Scott Burns is better than Tadgh Kennelly.


James Clement / Lance Whitnall / Daniel Wells is worth debate.


Simon Black has got the runs on the board against Chris Tarrant.

 

[silky-smooth]

Originally posted by gold cup 1996
Which team is 2nd on the ladder & has no players in this side?
This is a better side

S. Grant in for B. Johnson even though I rate Johnson highly
A. Simpson in for West
D. Wells in for Whitnall
G. Archer in for A. Lynch

I agree

 

[EssJayW]

Originally posted by leonmagic
Scott Burns is better than Tadgh Kennelly.

agree on that one.

 

[Stegelator]

Originally posted by Russian
Started from scratch...

1. Barry Hall (SYD)
2. Chris Johnson (BRI)
3. Michael Voss (BRI)
4. Paul Hasleby (FRE)
5. James Hird (ESS)
6. Brad Johnson (WB)
7. Scott West (WB)
8. Lance Whitnall (CAR)
9. Ben Cousins (WC)
10. Paul Williams (SYD)
11. Alastair Lynch (BRI)
12. Nick Riewoldt (STK)
13. Adam Yze (MEL)
14. Luke Ball (STK)
15. Mal Michael (BRI)
16. Warren Tredrea (PTA)
17. Tadgh Kennelly (SYD)
18. Matthew Lloyd (ESS)
19. Michael O'Loughlin (SYD)
20. Simon Black (BRI)
21. Leo Barry (SYD)
22. Chris Scott (BRI)
23. Andrew McLeod (ADE)
24. Mark Coughlan (RIC)
25. Scott Lucas (ESS)
26. Ben Johnson (COL)
27. Clark Keating (BRI)
28. Kane Johnson (RIC)
29. Matthew Pavlich (FRE)
30. Matthew Scarlett (GEE)
31. Dustin Fletcher (ESS)
32. Mark Ricciuto (ADE)
33. Phillip Matera (WC)
34. Paul Medhurst (FRE)
35. Chad Cornes (PTA)
36. Simon Goodwin (ADE)
37. Adam Goodes (SYD)
38. Roger James (PTA)
39. Andrew Kellaway (RIC)
40. Chris Ladhams (ADE)
41. Brent Staker (WC)
42. Robert Haddrill (Fre)
43. Anthony Koutoufides (Car)
44. Nigel Lappin (Bri)
45. Cameron Ling (Gee)
46. Trent Carroll (WC)
47. Laurence Angwin (Car)

Here's mine except:
Simpson in for West
archer for Lynch
Burns for Kenelly

 

[leonmagic]

Now that the no.47 is up for grabs, I'm going to nominate Justin Crow!!!




(Anyone who has seen him play will understand the laughter)

 

[Stegelator]

Originally posted by Russian
Started from scratch...

1. Barry Hall (SYD)
2. Chris Johnson (BRI)
3. Michael Voss (BRI)
4. Paul Hasleby (FRE)
5. James Hird (ESS)
6. Brad Johnson (WB)
7. Scott West (WB)
8. Lance Whitnall (CAR)
9. Ben Cousins (WC)
10. Paul Williams (SYD)
11. Alastair Lynch (BRI)
12. Nick Riewoldt (STK)
13. Adam Yze (MEL)
14. Luke Ball (STK)
15. Mal Michael (BRI)
16. Warren Tredrea (PTA)
17. Tadgh Kennelly (SYD)
18. Matthew Lloyd (ESS)
19. Michael O'Loughlin (SYD)
20. Simon Black (BRI)
21. Leo Barry (SYD)
22. Chris Scott (BRI)
23. Andrew McLeod (ADE)
24. Mark Coughlan (RIC)
25. Scott Lucas (ESS)
26. Ben Johnson (COL)
27. Clark Keating (BRI)
28. Kane Johnson (RIC)
29. Matthew Pavlich (FRE)
30. Matthew Scarlett (GEE)
31. Dustin Fletcher (ESS)
32. Mark Ricciuto (ADE)
33. Phillip Matera (WC)
34. Paul Medhurst (FRE)
35. Chad Cornes (PTA)
36. Simon Goodwin (ADE)
37. Adam Goodes (SYD)
38. Roger James (PTA)
39. Andrew Kellaway (RIC)
40. Chris Ladhams (ADE)
41. Brent Staker (WC)
42. Robert Haddrill (Fre)
43. Anthony Koutoufides (Car)
44. Nigel Lappin (Bri)
45. Cameron Ling (Gee)
46. Trent Carroll (WC)
47. Laurence Angwin (Car)

Here's mine except:
Simpson in for West
archer for Lynch
Burns for Kenelly

 

[silky-smooth]

Like these threads

 

[jod23]

Judd unlucky because of Voss
What about Sampi at #28?

Gardiner #1
Cousins #9

 

[un_zero42]

Nathan Brown's better than West and Simpson.

 

[fugazi]

#26 - Nick Dal Santo ahead of Sav Rocca and Ben Johnson

 

[Pie 4 Life]

26# Rocca has more of a history and is a stronger more physical player with more presence in the forward line.
Nathan Brown is an off and on player where West and Simpson always perform well.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Now that we've nearly finished the whole seasopn we can pick more carefully!
Should Whitnall still be in my team, hasn't had the best of years. Any suggestions???
Any other changes???

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Kingsley ??

 

[WZA]

That list is a JOKE!

 

[Benevolent Ert]

Unlucky Ommissions: S. Black

Unlucky omission?????

Tarrant's good, but he's not THAT good!!!

 

[Yze_Magic]

This, in my opinion is the best guernsey number team.

1. Barry Hall
2. Chris Johnson
3. Michael Voss
4. Paul Haselby
5. Nathan Buckley
6. Brad Johnson
7. Scott West
8. Lance Whitnall
9. Shane Crawford
10. Paul Williams
11. Joel Smith
12. Jason Akermanis
13. Adam Yze
14. Luke Darcy
15. Byron Pickett
16. Warren Tredra
17. Wayne Campbell
18. Matthew Lloyd
19. Michael O'Loughlin
20. Chris Tarrant
21. Michael Wilson
22. Jason Saddington
23. Andrew McLeod
24. Nick Stevens
25. Brendan Fevola
26. Saverio Rocca
27. Matthew Allan
28. Jared Crouch
29. Matthew Pavlich
30. Matthew Scarlett
31. Dustin Fletcher
32. Mark Ricciuto
33. Phillip Matera
34. David King
35. Robert Harvey
36. Daniel Bradshaw
37. Adam Goodes
38. Roger James
39. Leigh Harding
40. Chris Ladhams
41. Josh Hunt
42. Robert Haddrill
43. Anthony Koutoufides
44. Nigel Lappin
45. Cameron Ling
46. Trent Carroll
47. Justin Crow
51. Steven Koops

Unlucky Ommissions: Wirrpunda, Hird, Primus, B. Harvey, Gardiner, S. Black, R. Smith, Lynch and S. Camporeale.

shocking list

Neitz is easily yhe best nuber 9, and same for Jeff WHite and the number 34

Matthew Allan numer 27.. lol.. try Jared Rivers

 

[benrey_demons]

i was just about to mention Jeff White for 34...