MVP Official Votes NMFC v Bulldogs (Round 9)

[Twinkletoes]

Post 'em here.......

3. Spitter
2. Ziebell
1. Grima (edited in after watching the replay)

 

[hcd199]

3 - T. Goldstein
2 - A. Swallow
1 - J. Ziebell

Unlucky: Grima, McMahon, Harvey.

 

[NiceCunnington]

3. Grima
2. Swallow
1. Goldstein

 

[Mr. Blonde]

3 - Grima
2 - Smith (was very good)
1 - Swallow

 

[Joshen]

3. Swallow
2. Grima
1. Goldstein

 

[shinboner magic]

3. grima
2. swallow
1. goldy

 

[Jonnoo]

3. Goldstein
2. Spitta
1. Grima

 

[Daveo Plonk]

3 - Grima
2 - Smith (was very good)
1 - Swallow

Are you related?

3. Grima
2. A. Swallow
1. Harvey

 

[The Zebra]

3 - Grima
2 - Goldy
1 - Swallow

highlight of the day was the Cunnington contest in the first quarter. That would hurt. he didn't show it. Ziebs did some nive things as well. Spud was good.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Thought the votes were fairly obvious today. The Zebra is spot on:

3 - Grima
2 - Goldstein
1 - Swallow

 

[Works atErrol St]

3. Swallow
2. Goldstein
1. Zeibell

 

[Morgazm]

3. Swallow
Daylight
2. Goldstein
1. Grima

 

[muttley45]

3,swallow

2,goldy

1,scotty thompson (for at least showing some joey spirit)

 

[shintemaster]

3. Swallow
2. Grima
1. Ziebell

 

[Angus1]

Tough to give votes as we were atrocious but these were the obvious standouts.

3 Swallow easily our best by a mile.
2 Grima tried and made a contest.
1 Smith presented well which is something we've lacked in the past.

 

[scottywiper]

3: Grima
2: Swallow
1: Harvey
Goldy stiff.
At the end of the day, the missed chances killed us, we played very well early but butchered chances and then we were like a pricked balloon when the Dogs got a few.
Just one of those days but we were nowhere near as dominated as the margin suggests.

 

[Paddy_Mac]

3. Grima
2. Goldstein
1. Swallow

Btw, i don't know how you can give harvey votes, was i watching the same game? that was one of the worst games he's played all season, up there with the saints match

 

[Angus1]

3. Grima
2. Goldstein
1. Swallow

Btw, i don't know how you can give harvey votes, was i watching the same game? that was one of the worst games he's played all season, up there with the saints match

Nah he was way better then Saints game but not one of his best. He's kind of working alone with Swallow and it's showing.

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

3. Swallow
2. Goldstein
1. Grima

 

[Hearts to hearts]

It's a bit of a blur and I haven't seen and won't see the replay, but:

3 Swallow
2 McMahon
1 Ziebell

McMahon might have had a terrible game for all I know, but he did do most of the (few) things that lifted me yesterday too.

 

[Mr Reliable]

....
At the end of the day, the missed chances killed us, we played very well early but butchered chances and then we were like a pricked balloon when the Dogs got a few.
Just one of those days but we were nowhere near as dominated as the margin suggests.

A perfect summation. We missed goals that were impossible to miss, professional forwards kicking for goal from virtually straight in front, in perfect weather. O'Keefe could have/should have goaled with his first kick and Josh Smith is a very ordinary kick for goal in the AFL fo some reason.

Like Hearts, I won't watch a replay and my third vote is an encouragement award based on a few things he did that I enjoyed.


3. Swallow

2. Grima

1. Bastinac - I like the way he plays -inside and outside -and, like Narni, he's never flustered.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

3. Grima (F*** this guy is good)

2. Swallow (Was admirable in the packs all afternoon)

1. Ziebell (Hurry up 2012)

Goldstein and Bastinac tried all day. Thompson gets a mention because he put Big Bad Bustling Belligerent Bald Barry Hall over the edge.

 

[Roos4eva]

3- Swallow
2- Goldstein
1- Ziebell

 

[year of the roo]

3 - Swallow (easily)
2 - Goldy
1 - Grima

Bastinac was OK, and I thought Thomas' first half was excellent. Got a heap of contested ball and was everywhere. He then vanished.

 

[blackshadow]

3 - Swallow
2 - Grima
1 - Scott Thompson - gets one for his efforts on the sook.