Opening the time capsule: 2014 pre-season predictions revisited

[jmac70]

Lets have some fun ! (borrowed from Saints board(which i borrowed from the crows board!)

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? - 5th

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? - Cloke

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? - Sidebottom, Pendles and Cloke

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? - Pendles

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? - Grundy & Freeman

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? - 15 (including 1 final)

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? - Freeman

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? - White

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? - Sidebottom (Copeland)

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? - Grundy

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? - Freo (defeating Swans)

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? - Ablett (again)

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? - Cloke

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? - Billings

 

[Gambit78]

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? Top 4

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Ben Reid

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? Pendlebury, Beams, Sidebottom

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? Pendlebury

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? Kennedy, Freeman

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 16

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Freeman

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? White and Adams

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? Taylor Adams

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? Taylor Adams

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? North Melbourne

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? Patrick Dangerfield

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? Travis Cloke

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Jesse Hogan

 

[jjsmitty8]

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish?
6th
2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014?
Trav
3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014?
Pendlebury, Swan, Cloke
4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Pendlebury
5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations?
Nathan Freeman
6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014?
13/14
7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Nathan Freeman
8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Taylor Adams
9. Who do you think will have a break out season?
Josh Thomas or Alex Fasolo
10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014?
Jamie Elliott
11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership?
Sydney
12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Dangerfield
13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal?
Trav
14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award?
Jack Martin

 

[Ketchup]

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? 10th

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? Beams, Pendles, Sidey

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? Beams

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? Grundy (if not already done), Shazza, Kennedy (if not already done)

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 11

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Freeman

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? White and Adams (equal)

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? I don't think anyone will outside of first year players. So to put an answer here ill say Witts or Kennedy

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? Adams

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? Sydney

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? Dangerfield

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? Cloke

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Jack Martin

 

[medhurstISGOD]

1) 4th
2) Cloke 78
3) 1. Pendlebury 2. Cloke 3. Beams (Swan 4th)
4) Pendlebury
5) Grundy, Freeman, Scharenberg, Broomhead
6) 14-16
7) Freeman (14 games)
8) Adams (25 games)
9) Keeffe
10) See 9
11) Fremantle
12) Ablett
13) Cloke
14) Grundy

 

[suspect footskills]

Lots of people tipping Cloke for the Coleman here and I definitely agree. With the new marking guidelines allowing players to be more physical in out-bodying their opponents, Cloke will have a big year. Also having more support in form of White won't hurt either. Brody for rising star.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Other supporters probably think we are biased having Pendlebury winning the brownlow, Cloke winning the Coleman and Grundy winning the rising star.. But all are a huge chance? Has a team had a coleman, brownlow and rising star winner on the same side?

 

[TheFreshBanana]

Other supporters probably think we are biased having Pendlebury winning the brownlow, Cloke winning the Coleman and Grundy winning the rising star.. But all are a huge chance? Has a team had a coleman, brownlow and rising star winner on the same side?

What's the point of being a passionate supporter if you can't be biased?

 

[HappyRed]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish?
4th
2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014?
Cloke
3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014?
Dayne Beams
4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Scott Pendlebury
5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations?
Grundy
6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014?
a lot
7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Scharenberg
8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Jesse White

9. Who do you think will have a break out season?
Jamie Elliot
10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014?
Marley Williams
11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership?
Collingwood
12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Dane Swan or Pendlebury
13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal?
Travis Cloke
14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Brodie Grundy

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Lets have some fun ! (borrowed from Saints board(which i borrowed from the crows board!)

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? Seedsman

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014?Seedsman

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014?Seedsman

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal?Seedsman

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations?Seedsman

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014?Seedsman

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?Seedsman

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014?

9. Who do you think will have a break out season?Seedsman

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014?Seedsman

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership?Seedsman

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal?Seedsman

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal?Seedsman

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award?Seedsman

 

[carnthepies19]

Questions:
1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish?
3rd

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014?
Trav Cloke

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014?
In order - Pendlebury, Beams and Grundy

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Pendles

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations?
Grundy, Scharenberg and Broomhead

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014?
17

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Scharenberg if fit

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Taylor Adams and Jesse White will play in each game

9. Who do you think will have a break out season?
Brodie Grundy however I suppose you could say he's already broken out so Marley Williams

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014?
Josh Thomas, Brodie Grundy and Ben Kennedy

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership?
Sydney

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Dan Hannebery from Scott Pendlebury and Tom Liberatore

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal?
Trav Cloke

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award?
Jack Martin marginally over Grundy and Hogan

 

[_Stinger_]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? 2nd

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke 63

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? Pendles, Swan, Beams

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? Pendles - WIN

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? Freeman, Broomhead, can Grundy get nominated again?

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 21

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Freeman

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Adams / White

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? Williams

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? Thomas

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? Collingwood

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? Pendles

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? Cloke

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Grundy

 

[Chilli Con Incarnate]

Only one prediction for 2014: You will FEEL THE STEELE!

 

[RossFC]

Didn't I hear Bucks at the end of the season say that the premiership window is pretty much shut and massive list changes will be made?
I assume by the predictions you guys have made, you are hoping Collingwood have 1 last crack at the flag before rebuilding again.

 

[Collingwood pro]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? 8th
2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke-85
3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? Pendlebury, Swan, Sidebottom
4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? Pendlebury
5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? Grundy, Marsh and Broomhead
6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 13
7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Freeman
8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? White and Adams
9. Who do you think will have a break out season? Grundy, Lynch and Kennedy
10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? Pendlebury
11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? Sydney (With Minor injuries), or Hawthorn
12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? Fyfe or Gazza, maybe Joel Selwood
13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? Jeremy Cameron
14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Aish

 

[Bard]

Didn't I hear Bucks at the end of the season say that the premiership window is pretty much shut and massive list changes will be made?
I assume by the predictions you guys have made, you are hoping Collingwood have 1 last crack at the flag before rebuilding again.

Massive list changes were made, and I'm not sure many people are seriously predicting Collingwood will win the flag?

Poor attempt

 

[RossFC]

Massive list changes were made, and I'm not sure many people are seriously predicting Collingwood will win the flag?

Poor attempt

I didn't say you will win the flag I just meant if you think you can have 1 last crack at the flag at the stage your list is in.
by "one last crack" I mean deep into the finals as at least a serious threat. Most of you guys predict 5th-8th with the odd guy saying 10th.

 

[Bard]

I didn't say you will win the flag I just meant if you think you can have 1 last crack at the flag at the stage your list is in.
by "one last crack" I mean deep into the finals as at least a serious threat. Most of you guys predict 5th-8th with the odd guy saying 10th.

Outside of the clear top teams vying for next years flag - Fremantle, Hawthorn and Sydney - a lot of lists have the capability to go all the way next year. Collingwood is one of them. The thing is, absolutely /everything/ would have to go right for it to happen. You can't say Buckley wouldn't be planning to win the flag next year - as he has to be, it's his job - but anything that happens will just be a product towards the team he's building for our real assault in a few years time.

 

[HappyRed]

Who said we don't treat other users from different teams well.. i only see nothing but politeness here.. sometimes i wonder why they call "us" the Westie Toothless scum.. If we were toothless at least we are reasonable toothless scum. haha

(I love seeing people from other clubs posting. We can all just get along!)

 

[100volt1]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? 4th

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? 1st. steele sidebottom 2nd. pendlebury 3rd. swan

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? pendlebury

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? scharenberg

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 17

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? scharenberg

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? jesse white

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? steele sidebottom

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? josh thomas

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? Fremantle

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? cotchin

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? franklin

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? -

 

[100volt1]

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke - Kick the Ton

i had a bit of a chuckle

 

[TradeDraft]

i had a bit of a chuckle

Why a Chuckle - See who is Laughing when he Kicks the Ton

 

[Bard]

Who said we don't treat other users from different teams well.. i only see nothing but politeness here.. sometimes i wonder why they call "us" the Westie Toothless scum.. If we were toothless at least we are reasonable toothless scum. haha

(I love seeing people from other clubs posting. We can all just get along!)

I hate everyone equally, no matter the club they support.

 

[nahnah]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish? 4th

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014? Cloke

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014? Beams, pendles,swan

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal? Beams

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations? Grundy, Freeman

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014? 17

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014? Scharenberg

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014? White

9. Who do you think will have a break out season? Seedsman

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014? Marley

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership? Hawks

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal? Beams

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal? Buddy

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award? Don't know

 

[nahnah]

1. Where on the 2014 ladder will Collingwood finish?
2nd

2. Who do you think will be the Pies leading goal kicker in 2014?
Reid

3. Who do you think will be Top 3 in the Collingwoods best and fairest for 2014?
Swan, Pendles, Beams

4. Who do you think will poll the most votes for Collingwood in the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Swan

5. Who from Collingwood do you think will receive rising star nominations?
Marsh, Grundy, Freeman

6. How many games do you think Collingwood will win in season 2014?
20

7. Who out of our draftees (Scharenberg, Freeman, Langdon, Marsh) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Marsh

8. Who out of our recruits (Jesse White, Taylor Adams, Patrick Karnezis ,Tony Armstrong ) do you think will play the most football in 2014?
Armstrong

9. Who do you think will have a break out season?
Armstrong, Marsh, Seedsman

10. Which young player do you think will have the biggest year in 2014?
Marsh

11. Who do you think will win the 2014 AFL Premiership?
Collingwood

12. Who do you think will win the 2014 Brownlow medal?
Dane Swan

13. Who do you think will win the 2014 Coleman Medal?
Dane Swan

14. Who do you think will win the 2014 Rising Star Award?
Marsh

are you indigenous?