- Sep 25, 2005
- 9,720
- 6,297
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Gippy Power
- Thread starter
- #251
TRADE WEEK COMES TO AN END
well played all!
well played all!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Orginal BF Draft and Trade Game - Only few teams left
- Thread starter Snoop Dog
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 25, 2005
- 9,720
- 6,297
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Gippy Power
- Thread starter
- #252
Nathan Krakouer was the only offer rec'd for Barry Hall so he is on his way to Port Power
- Sep 25, 2005
- 9,720
- 6,297
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Gippy Power
- Thread starter
- #253
COLLINGWOOD FINAL 22
Strategy - Wanted to build for a premiership side. Some strength at CHB hence recruitment of Hunter and then get some stronger bodies in middle like Waters and Lewis. Also wanted pace outside and got Young and Stanton for that.
List - Didnt trade any of my young blokes that I wanted in Swan, Pendles, Thomas, Cloke, Brown etc albeit under a lot of stress at times.
Depth - also wanted great depth to list and so with OBree, Doughty, Shirley, McCarthy etc
The one that got away - a few - WR is the hardest bloke in the world to deal with. Couldnt get Rutten having tried everything nor Thompson. Also was keen on Hasleby for the whole trade period but couldnt get it done.
Best 22
B M.Clarke, N.Brown, H.OBrien
HB N.Maxwell, A.Hunter, B.Waters
C D.Thomas, D.Swan,C.Young
HF A.Didak, T.Cloke, R.OKeefe
F P.Medhurst, A.Rocca, L.Davis
Foll J.Fraser, J.Lewis
Rov S.Pendlebury
Int B.Stanton, R.Ladson, C.Dawes, C.Bryan
Emerg OBree, Shirley, McCarthy
Depth
T.Goldsack, J.McCarthy, S.OBree, Doughty, S.Cox, A.Thomson, R.Shirley, S.Prestigiacomo, R.Cook, D.Stanley, A.Toovey, B.Dick, T.Thoolen, A.Toovey
Delist
A.Toovey
Picks 42, 66, 72, 77, 93, 109
Strategy - Wanted to build for a premiership side. Some strength at CHB hence recruitment of Hunter and then get some stronger bodies in middle like Waters and Lewis. Also wanted pace outside and got Young and Stanton for that.
List - Didnt trade any of my young blokes that I wanted in Swan, Pendles, Thomas, Cloke, Brown etc albeit under a lot of stress at times.
Depth - also wanted great depth to list and so with OBree, Doughty, Shirley, McCarthy etc
The one that got away - a few - WR is the hardest bloke in the world to deal with. Couldnt get Rutten having tried everything nor Thompson. Also was keen on Hasleby for the whole trade period but couldnt get it done.
Best 22
B M.Clarke, N.Brown, H.OBrien
HB N.Maxwell, A.Hunter, B.Waters
C D.Thomas, D.Swan,C.Young
HF A.Didak, T.Cloke, R.OKeefe
F P.Medhurst, A.Rocca, L.Davis
Foll J.Fraser, J.Lewis
Rov S.Pendlebury
Int B.Stanton, R.Ladson, C.Dawes, C.Bryan
Emerg OBree, Shirley, McCarthy
Depth
T.Goldsack, J.McCarthy, S.OBree, Doughty, S.Cox, A.Thomson, R.Shirley, S.Prestigiacomo, R.Cook, D.Stanley, A.Toovey, B.Dick, T.Thoolen, A.Toovey
Delist
A.Toovey
Picks 42, 66, 72, 77, 93, 109
Simon Wiggans
Rookie
NORTH MELBOURNE !!
Strategy = Sick of the roos always just being there..... So i went for Youth to build a side that would develop in the next few years. Got rid of old players and in with the young.
Best Feature of Team: BIG COXY!!!
Best 22 =
FB:.........L. Hansen.........J. Gibson........S.Watt
HB:.........S.Power...........M.Firrito.........G.Urquhart
C:.........A.Carrazzo........B.Rawlings......L.Harding
HF:..........B.Fisher............D.Petrie..........M.Osborne
FF:...........T.Boyle............D.Hale............M.Campbell
RUCK:........Dean Cox..........N. Stevens.......M. Murphy
I/C From: S. Wellingham, S. Browne, S. Grigg, D. Armfeild,
SD Thompson, M. Austin, S. Hampson, T. Goldstein
Rest Of List:
L. Greenwood
R. Tarrant
L. Adams
Ed Lower
Davies
Josh Smith
Warren
C. Garlett
N. Grima
A. Obst
J. Wilsen
De-Listings: Adam Simpson (Forced Retirment)
Leigh Brown
Blake Grima
M.Wundke [(Rookie List) mile high dude
]Draft Picks: 54, 59, 69, 75
RICHMOND Final 22-
PICKS: 8,26,37,42,44,74
Strategy Was sick of the tigers missing out by one position so we decided to bulk up the run in the team and Chuck some premiership boys into the team to lead the boys.
Very happy with the team.
Best Pickups Boomer and Goodwin And Stevens
Richmond decided to bulk up their Midfield in recruiting some excellent players example Harvey Fletcher Goodwin
Final 22:
B: Moore Thursfield McMahon
HB: McGuane Stevens Newman
C: Goodwin Tuck Tambling
HF:Cotchin Riewoldt Harvey
F: Morton Richo Fletcher
Ruck: Simmonds
RR: Deledio
Rover:Foley
Edwards Pattison Shaw Johnson
The rest:Eagleton Coughlan White Hughes Armstrong Jackson Connors King Graham Polak Polo Putt
40 Players all up
Rookies:
Cartledge
Collard
Howat
Silvestor
Retirement:
Hyde
Delistings
Tivendale
Casserly
Jarrad Oakley Nicholls
Collins
Meyer
Gourdis
Bit Harsh on a few players.
PICKS: 8,26,37,42,44,74
Strategy Was sick of the tigers missing out by one position so we decided to bulk up the run in the team and Chuck some premiership boys into the team to lead the boys.
Very happy with the team.
Best Pickups Boomer and Goodwin And Stevens
Richmond decided to bulk up their Midfield in recruiting some excellent players example Harvey Fletcher Goodwin
Final 22:
B: Moore Thursfield McMahon
HB: McGuane Stevens Newman
C: Goodwin Tuck Tambling
HF:Cotchin Riewoldt Harvey
F: Morton Richo Fletcher
Ruck: Simmonds
RR: Deledio
Rover:Foley
Edwards Pattison Shaw Johnson
The rest:Eagleton Coughlan White Hughes Armstrong Jackson Connors King Graham Polak Polo Putt
40 Players all up
Rookies:
Cartledge
Collard
Howat
Silvestor
Retirement:
Hyde
Delistings
Tivendale
Casserly
Jarrad Oakley Nicholls
Collins
Meyer
Gourdis
Bit Harsh on a few players.
Chris25
Moderator
- Oct 30, 2007
- 12,009
- 14,476
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- West End Redbacks, Cleveland Browns
- Moderator
- #256
Fremantle Dockers Final List
Strategy
I went into trade week, planning on picking up early draft picks. With all the retirings at Fremantle this year, I already had enough room for 7 draft picks. So I wasn't able to trade away too many players, or else I wouldn't have had a list. My focus was to trade away fringe players, and get into the club young WA-born players. While I didn't have a huge turn over of players like some teams, I have managed to get 4 four picks in the first 21. My final team is one of, if not the, youngest team in the AFL. And would be a serious premiership threat in about 3 years.
Best 22
Roger Hayden - Antoni Grover - Setanta O'hAilpin
Paul Bower - Luke McPharlin - Garrick Ibbotson
Clayton Hinkley - David Mundy - Paul Haselby
Dean Solomon - Marcus Drum - Chris Mayne
Adam Campbell - Matthew Pavlich - Des Headland
Aaron Sandilands - Rhys Palmer - Ryan Crowley
Kepler Bradley - Michael Johnson - Byron Schammer - Paul Duffield
Depth
Brent Connelly - Andrew Foster - Daniel Gilmore - Josh Head - Jamie McNamara - Calib Mourish - Brock O'Brien - Luke Pratt - Matt Riggio - Chris Smith - Andrew Swallow
De-Listings
Andrew Browne - Ryley Dunn - Brett Peake - Scott Thornton
Draft Picks
3, 18, 20, 21, 40, 53, 85
Strategy
I went into trade week, planning on picking up early draft picks. With all the retirings at Fremantle this year, I already had enough room for 7 draft picks. So I wasn't able to trade away too many players, or else I wouldn't have had a list. My focus was to trade away fringe players, and get into the club young WA-born players. While I didn't have a huge turn over of players like some teams, I have managed to get 4 four picks in the first 21. My final team is one of, if not the, youngest team in the AFL. And would be a serious premiership threat in about 3 years.
Best 22
Roger Hayden - Antoni Grover - Setanta O'hAilpin
Paul Bower - Luke McPharlin - Garrick Ibbotson
Clayton Hinkley - David Mundy - Paul Haselby
Dean Solomon - Marcus Drum - Chris Mayne
Adam Campbell - Matthew Pavlich - Des Headland
Aaron Sandilands - Rhys Palmer - Ryan Crowley
Kepler Bradley - Michael Johnson - Byron Schammer - Paul Duffield
Depth
Brent Connelly - Andrew Foster - Daniel Gilmore - Josh Head - Jamie McNamara - Calib Mourish - Brock O'Brien - Luke Pratt - Matt Riggio - Chris Smith - Andrew Swallow
De-Listings
Andrew Browne - Ryley Dunn - Brett Peake - Scott Thornton
Draft Picks
3, 18, 20, 21, 40, 53, 85
PORT ADELAIDE
Strategy:
- Geelong and Hawthorn are the standout teams - must trade for a team that can compete
- Noted deficiencies
1) a lack of tough inside midfielders
2) ruckmen - Lade will retire in 1-2 years, Brogan not too long after that
3) young burly contested marking forward in which a team can be built around; Tredrea will retire in 1-3 years while Westoff has trouble putting on muscle mass.
- Noted list did play in grand final in 2007 with a fit Chad Cornes.
- Noted best chance to win premiership is with Cornes and Burgoyne boys
- To note prior to 2008 trade and draft - Port Adelaide has one of the younger lists
Aim -
To improve list by trading or drafting to improve weaknesses
Goals achieved?
1) Carr, S. Hurn, J. Kennedy
Carr older, experienced campaigner coming home. S. Hurn, SA kid, big body, rotating through midfield/crash and bash/long kick. Happy to sit on J. Kennedy who has shown a bit, willing to take a punt in terms of development here. Tried to get Kerr, Bartel and J. Lewis but no success.
2) Seaby
Seaby gives at least 5 years backup and cover in ruck when Lade and Brogan disappear in the coming years. Tried trading for young ruckmen but they were expensive.
3) Hall, Thorp, Rusling, McKinley
Hall, an absolute bonus, could be used for the right now. Thorp to be played and developed. Being outside the current 22 - Rusling can be left to recover from injuries and developed. McKinley was a bonus. Tried for T. Hawkins but no success either.
Problems?
Nil Draft picks, virtually. Concern for the future. As a result consideration given to trade established starters. Alleviated a little by most of the players traded in were young and youngish list.
BEST TEAM
FB Hurn Carlile Chaplin
HB Cassisi C. Cornes P. Burgoyne
C Salopek K. Cornes Boak
HF Thorp Tredrea Ebert
F D. Motlop Hall McKinley
FOLL Brogan S. Burgoyne Pearce
INT Seaby Lade Carr J. Westoff
Draft Picks 70, 86, 102
Retired:
Michael Wilson
Hugh Minson
Delistings
1. Nathan Lonie
2. Greg Bentley
3. Adam Cockshell
4. Toby Thurstans
5. Tom Logan
6. Damon White
7. Ryan Willits
8. Daniel Boyle
9. Gavin Grose
10. Fabian Deluca
Strategy:
- Geelong and Hawthorn are the standout teams - must trade for a team that can compete
- Noted deficiencies
1) a lack of tough inside midfielders
2) ruckmen - Lade will retire in 1-2 years, Brogan not too long after that
3) young burly contested marking forward in which a team can be built around; Tredrea will retire in 1-3 years while Westoff has trouble putting on muscle mass.
- Noted list did play in grand final in 2007 with a fit Chad Cornes.
- Noted best chance to win premiership is with Cornes and Burgoyne boys
- To note prior to 2008 trade and draft - Port Adelaide has one of the younger lists
Aim -
To improve list by trading or drafting to improve weaknesses
Goals achieved?
1) Carr, S. Hurn, J. Kennedy
Carr older, experienced campaigner coming home. S. Hurn, SA kid, big body, rotating through midfield/crash and bash/long kick. Happy to sit on J. Kennedy who has shown a bit, willing to take a punt in terms of development here. Tried to get Kerr, Bartel and J. Lewis but no success.
2) Seaby
Seaby gives at least 5 years backup and cover in ruck when Lade and Brogan disappear in the coming years. Tried trading for young ruckmen but they were expensive.
3) Hall, Thorp, Rusling, McKinley
Hall, an absolute bonus, could be used for the right now. Thorp to be played and developed. Being outside the current 22 - Rusling can be left to recover from injuries and developed. McKinley was a bonus. Tried for T. Hawkins but no success either.
Problems?
Nil Draft picks, virtually. Concern for the future. As a result consideration given to trade established starters. Alleviated a little by most of the players traded in were young and youngish list.
BEST TEAM
FB Hurn Carlile Chaplin
HB Cassisi C. Cornes P. Burgoyne
C Salopek K. Cornes Boak
HF Thorp Tredrea Ebert
F D. Motlop Hall McKinley
FOLL Brogan S. Burgoyne Pearce
INT Seaby Lade Carr J. Westoff
Draft Picks 70, 86, 102
Retired:
Michael Wilson
Hugh Minson
Delistings
1. Nathan Lonie
2. Greg Bentley
3. Adam Cockshell
4. Toby Thurstans
5. Tom Logan
6. Damon White
7. Ryan Willits
8. Daniel Boyle
9. Gavin Grose
10. Fabian Deluca
Everyone, my mums been in a little lara bingle with her car and I have been helping her and am off again, just had to drop something home
I will start the draft organisation later on....about an hour
Sorry for the delay
I will start the draft organisation later on....about an hour
Sorry for the delay
SaintsPremiers08
Club Legend
Carlton Football Club:
B: Simon Wiggins - Darren Glass - Brett Thornton
HB: Joel Bowden - Jarrad Waite - Heath Scotland
C: Kade Simpson - Andrew Embley - Andrew Walker
HF: Nathan G.Brown - Nick Riewoldt - Corey Jones
F: Ryan Murphy - Brendan Fevola - Eddie Betts
FOLL: Hamish McIntosh - Bryce Gibbs - Chris Judd
INT: Cameron Cloke - Chris Tarrant - Farren Ray - Richard Hadley
OTHERS:
Joe Anderson
Clint Benjamin
Darren Pfeffier
Jason Saddington
Jordon Bannister
Adam Bentick
Luke Blackwell
Ryan Houlihan
Ryan Jackson
Jordan Russell
Jake Edwards
Cain Ackland
Adam Hartlett
Delisted:
Aisake O'hAplin
Sam Jacobs (R)
Aaron Jospeh (R)
Micheal Shields (R)
Lachie Hill (R)
David Elard (R)
Picks:
56, 58, 72, 88
B: Simon Wiggins - Darren Glass - Brett Thornton
HB: Joel Bowden - Jarrad Waite - Heath Scotland
C: Kade Simpson - Andrew Embley - Andrew Walker
HF: Nathan G.Brown - Nick Riewoldt - Corey Jones
F: Ryan Murphy - Brendan Fevola - Eddie Betts
FOLL: Hamish McIntosh - Bryce Gibbs - Chris Judd
INT: Cameron Cloke - Chris Tarrant - Farren Ray - Richard Hadley
OTHERS:
Joe Anderson
Clint Benjamin
Darren Pfeffier
Jason Saddington
Jordon Bannister
Adam Bentick
Luke Blackwell
Ryan Houlihan
Ryan Jackson
Jordan Russell
Jake Edwards
Cain Ackland
Adam Hartlett
Delisted:
Aisake O'hAplin
Sam Jacobs (R)
Aaron Jospeh (R)
Micheal Shields (R)
Lachie Hill (R)
David Elard (R)
Picks:
56, 58, 72, 88
eth-dog
Tier 1 WW Player
- Essendon Bombers
Strategy:
- Geelong and Hawthorn are the standout teams - must trade for a team that can compete
- Noted deficiencies
1) a tough tall defender
2) ruckmen - need a third ruckman
3) high quality rebounder
Aim -
To improve list by trading or drafting to improve weaknesses
Goals achieved?
1) got a better midfield. lost Stanton, but got Tarkyn Lockyer and Andrew Raines, either can play HB or wing, so ended up with better players.
Problems?
Didn't get a young 2nd or 3rd ruckman, which is needed. also lacking a real quality rebounder, although Raines can play there. I also didn't get my KPB.
The Team
FB: Jackson Trengrove-Dustin Fletcher-Henry Slattery
HB: Andrew Raines-Paddy Ryder-David Myers
C: Tarkyn Lockyer-Jobe Watson-Bachar Houli
R: David Hille-Mark McVeigh-Andrew Welsh
HF: Jason Winderlich-Scott Lucas-Alwyn Davey
FF: Angus Monfries-Matthew Lloyd-Leroy Jetta
I: Jason Laycock-Sam Lonergan-Kyle Reimers-Adam McPhee
Emer: Jay Neagle-Scott Gumbleton-Jay Nash-Nathan Lovett-Murray
Delistings
HB: Andrew Raines-Paddy Ryder-David Myers
C: Tarkyn Lockyer-Jobe Watson-Bachar Houli
R: David Hille-Mark McVeigh-Andrew Welsh
HF: Jason Winderlich-Scott Lucas-Alwyn Davey
FF: Angus Monfries-Matthew Lloyd-Leroy Jetta
I: Jason Laycock-Sam Lonergan-Kyle Reimers-Adam McPhee
Emer: Jay Neagle-Scott Gumbleton-Jay Nash-Nathan Lovett-Murray
Delistings
- Ricky Dyson
- Damien Peverill
- Courtney Johns
- Andrew Lee
- Dean Dick
Retired
- Adam Ramanascus
- Jason Johnson
- Mal Michael
Adelaide Delist Kris Massie, Luke Jericho and Bryce Campbell
That have upgraded Brodie Martin from the rookie list
They have retained EdCurnow and James Moss on their rookie list
That have upgraded Brodie Martin from the rookie list
They have retained EdCurnow and James Moss on their rookie list
I only have 35 Players on my list atm, Since i delested 7
This List has the makings of a very good one before trade week, my aim was to just add alot more depth in young talent so rather then having players like Fletcher to come into the side you have guys like Whitecross or Ross etc. Also grabbing another pick in the top 10 will allow us to again improve a position we may be week in. Planning on a couple of my draftees playing league footy next season aswell.
Draft picks : 2,9,22,24,36,52,55,58,64,68,90
West Coast Eagles:
Mitch Brown
Mark LeCras
Daniel Kerr
Tyson Stenglein
Matt Priddis
Steven Dodd
Chris Masten
Josh Kennedy
Brad Ebert
Quinten Lynch
Travis Tuck
Brenden Whitecross
Micheal Jamieson
Matt Rosa
D.Rodan
Sam Butler
Scott Selwood
Daniel Wells
Ben Ross
Lindsay Thomas
Tony Notte
Brett Jones
Ben Reid
Brent Staker
David Wirrpanda
Warnock
Jesse Smith
Mcmahon
Courtney Dempsey
Brent Renouf
Xavier Ellis
Thomas Murphy
Rookies:
Callum Wilson
Will Sullivan
Ashley Arrowsmith
Ryan Davis
Lewis Stevenso
DELISTINGS:
E.Mackenzie
T.Houlihan
M.Spanger
W.Schofield
B.Wlikes
P.Mcginnity
J.Thomson
M.Nickoski
RETIREMENTS:
M.Braun
Best 22:
B: Wirrapanda Jamieson Murphy
HB: Je.Smith Staker Ellis
C: Wells Priddis Rodan
HF: Le Cras Kennedy Mcmahon
F: L.Thomas Lynch Reid
R: Warnock Kerr Stenglein
I/C: Tuck Ebert Renouf Masten
EMG: Dodd Butler Jones
REST: M.Brown, Rosa, Whitecross, S.Selwood, Ross, Notte, Dempsey
Picking up these guys aswell pick 9 i think has aloud for the west coast footy club to rebuild very quickly & give it best chance of succsess by 2011. Jamieson, Murphy, Je.Smith, Ellis, Wells, Rodan, Mcmahon, L.Thomas,Reid, Warnock, Tuck, Renouf, Dodd,Whitecross,Ross, Dempsey.
Our first pick is saved up for nic nat to give us 3 terrfic ruckman going forward, our second pick is likely to be used on a KPP player who has the ability to play in defence because our midfield & forward stocks are pretty good following on from there we will just draft the best player around.
Draft picks : 2,9,22,24,36,52,55,58,64,68,90
West Coast Eagles:
Mitch Brown
Mark LeCras
Daniel Kerr
Tyson Stenglein
Matt Priddis
Steven Dodd
Chris Masten
Josh Kennedy
Brad Ebert
Quinten Lynch
Travis Tuck
Brenden Whitecross
Micheal Jamieson
Matt Rosa
D.Rodan
Sam Butler
Scott Selwood
Daniel Wells
Ben Ross
Lindsay Thomas
Tony Notte
Brett Jones
Ben Reid
Brent Staker
David Wirrpanda
Warnock
Jesse Smith
Mcmahon
Courtney Dempsey
Brent Renouf
Xavier Ellis
Thomas Murphy
Rookies:
Callum Wilson
Will Sullivan
Ashley Arrowsmith
Ryan Davis
Lewis Stevenso
DELISTINGS:
E.Mackenzie
T.Houlihan
M.Spanger
W.Schofield
B.Wlikes
P.Mcginnity
J.Thomson
M.Nickoski
RETIREMENTS:
M.Braun
Best 22:
B: Wirrapanda Jamieson Murphy
HB: Je.Smith Staker Ellis
C: Wells Priddis Rodan
HF: Le Cras Kennedy Mcmahon
F: L.Thomas Lynch Reid
R: Warnock Kerr Stenglein
I/C: Tuck Ebert Renouf Masten
EMG: Dodd Butler Jones
REST: M.Brown, Rosa, Whitecross, S.Selwood, Ross, Notte, Dempsey
Picking up these guys aswell pick 9 i think has aloud for the west coast footy club to rebuild very quickly & give it best chance of succsess by 2011. Jamieson, Murphy, Je.Smith, Ellis, Wells, Rodan, Mcmahon, L.Thomas,Reid, Warnock, Tuck, Renouf, Dodd,Whitecross,Ross, Dempsey.
Our first pick is saved up for nic nat to give us 3 terrfic ruckman going forward, our second pick is likely to be used on a KPP player who has the ability to play in defence because our midfield & forward stocks are pretty good following on from there we will just draft the best player around.
