Our best player?

[RowanJones]

Bradd Dalziell was the better #18.

Well the data suggests otherwise in the winning-ness stakes:

2010 Bradd Dalziell 8 games (won 2, lost 6)
2011 Bradd Dalziell 1 game (lost 1)
2012 Bradd Dalziell 2 games (won 2)
2013 Bradd Dalziell 17 games (won 6, lost 11)
Won 8 - Lost 20.
No 18 winning-ness rating 2010-2013 = 40%

2000 Rowan Jones 20 games (won 6, drew 1, lost 13)
2001 Rowan Jones 18 games (won 3, lost 15)
2002 Rowan Jones 13 games (won 8, lost 5)
2003 Rowan Jones 23 games (won 12, drew 2, lost 9)
2004 Rowan Jones 16 games (won 10, lost 6)
2005 Rowan Jones 4 games (won 2, lost 2)
2006 Rowan Jones 23 games (won 17, lost 6)
2007 Rowan Jones 23 games (won 14, lost 9)
Won 72 - Drew 3 - Lost 65
No 18 winning-ness rating 2000-2007 = 51%

Case closed.

Interestingly RoJo also has an infinitely higher draw ratio.

 

[matt_bas]

Keys can we please merge threads? We already have multiple threads about Masten

 

[greatwhiteshark]

I think Shuey is our best footballer, poor bugger would of been a superstar if he had of been drafted to a club with a semi decent midfield around him.
Kennedy is a star full forward.

 

[paran]

NicNat. When on one of the top 5 Players inthe comp, easily capable of turning a game on its head. The franchise player.

 

[dajesmac]

1) Kennedy
2) McGovern
3) Shuey
4) Naitanui
5) Yeo
6) Gaff

 

[Keys]

Keys can we please merge threads? We already have multiple threads about Masten

I'm more likely just to delete the masten ones

 

[Eaglespur]

1) Kennedy
2) McGovern
3) Shuey
4) Naitanui
5) Yeo
6) Gaff

have to be pretty close

 

[FKASC]

Should it be based simply on recent form?

Could make strong claims for Le Cras and Mackenzie to be in the top 5 if not

 

[flyinghi64]

Hard to choose so I did the old playground team first pick.
It was a toss up between Kennedy and NN but came down to goals win games and well JK is by rights the comp leader.
So JK for me.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

JK has on average been the best forward in the game for the last 3 years.
The best player in the league in his position.
On consistency alone he is our best player.

 

[kid_a]

Should it be based simply on recent form?

Could make strong claims for Le Cras and Mackenzie to be in the top 5 if not

I meant it in the way of their recent career and importance to current team balance.

 

[former lurker]

Shuey ( should be Captain )
Nic Nat ( most influential when on )
Gov
JK ( Cant believe the voting, our midfield look for him so much and deliver to him when he is the worst option. Need to sort that )
Yeo

 

[Natho]

Gov
Jk
Nic
Shuey
Yeo