Patrick Karnezis - Waste of a Senior Spot?

[Ketchup]

No great loss if he leaves

VFL team will need to find a handy replacement

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Reckon PK will offer more than a fourth round pick / rookie selection is likely to.

If the Hawks or someone want to make a decent offer, then absolutely trade, but worth retaining on the list otherwise.

 

[Pera]

Still don't rate him. One paced.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Still don't rate him. One paced.

...and it appears to me he demands of others what he is not prepared to do himself

 

[pablo disco bar]

Looked good today next year is his year.....retain

 

[TradeDraft]

Looked good today next year is his year.....retain

That horse has Bolted.

Quality around Goal but goes missing

 

[soreplums]

That horse has Bolted.

Quality around Goal but goes missing

Most half forwards/forward pockets do.

I'd be more than happy if our half forwards kicked two-three goals each game

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

That horse has Bolted.

Quality around Goal but goes missing

Has never been given the opportunity. Hope he stays.

 

[CFC2010]

Still don't rate him. One paced.

Your right he scores too many goals when he is played in his rightful position FORWARD.

We can't have that at Collingwood tackling is way more important than score board pressure

 

[TradeDraft]

Your right he scores too many goals when he is played in his rightful position FORWARD.

We can't have that at Collingwood tackling is way more important than score board pressure

He is class around the Goals but today went Missing everywhere else

 

[Nicco_jj]

Has he been trialled in a forward position at afl level with Collingwood?
Answer: no. He always ends up in the mid.
The only time he's played proper forward was the nab cup, wherein he kicked multiple goals.

Fasolo, Blair, Elliot, broom, kenno, Moore all go missing. That's the nature of playing forward.

 

[HFF]

...and it appears to me he demands of others what he is not prepared to do himself

This is a joke, right?

 

[CFC2010]

He is class around the Goals but today went Missing everywhere else

Dave he played forward IMO for most of the time today.

He should have kicked 5......he missed at least two sitters by his standard (3.3)

Not sure what else you expect from a forward???

 

[TradeDraft]

Dave he played forward IMO for most of the time today.

He should have kicked 5......he missed at least two sitters by his standard (3.3)

Not sure what else you expect from a forward???

Forward Pressure

 

[Swanny36]

Forward Pressure

Lol so over rated. He's not Cyril Rioli for christs sake.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[BEEG]

PK will leave and get a regular senior gig and become a good player

 

[Good_Old]

PK will leave her a regular senior gig and become a good player

So it's his missus holding him back?

 

[Deano_55]

I don't get all this stuff about pk think he is a decent enough player to be playing seniors he kicks goals 2-3 a game and people here saying about pressure they had a word with him at the beginning said he needs to work on it since half way through has been averaging 6 tackles a game and kicking goals lol

 

[Anzacday]

PK will leave and get a regular senior gig and become a good player

Yep.
He's the typical icing on the cake player.
We need him to be more than just a finisher.

 

[PieBeast]

Yep.
He's the typical icing on the cake player.
We need him to be more than just a finisher.

So he'd be good enough for better sides but has to carry the can for the inadequacies of our side???

 

[Anzacday]

So he'd be good enough for better sides but has to carry the can for the inadequacies of our side???

Compare him to Fas, are you happy for Fas to just kick goals.
Or are you happier that he now tackles and chases, (still needs to improve) more?

 

[PieBeast]

Compare him to Fas, are you happy for Fas to just kick goals.
Or are you happier that he now tackles and chases, (still needs to improve) more?

I'm happy for the so called icings on the cake to be exactly what they're meant to be - making a great side even better.

What I'm not happy with is when they're expected to sacrifice their flair and fit it with the rest of the strugglers that tackle and chase but run out of puff half way through the year and are as useless as **** on a bull most of the time when it comes to score contribution....

i.e. if he's good enough to contribute for the better sides he should be good enough for our young but nevertheless fairly average side.

 

[Anzacday]

I'm happy for the so called icings on the cake to be exactly what they're meant to be - making a great side even better.

What I'm not happy with is when they're expected to sacrifice their flair and fit it with the rest of the strugglers that tackle and chase but run out of puff half way through the year and are as useless as **** on a bull most of the time when it comes to score contribution....

i.e. if he's good enough to contribute for the better sides he should be good enough for our young but nevertheless fairly average side.

You make a valid point Beast.
Funnily enough Billy was the opposite, he was a tackling machine and then became an excitement machine.
Now he and I are not sure what he is.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Allegedly Patty's brother.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[jmac70]

View attachment 170819

Allegedly Patty's brother.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

So PK was given an opportunity and turned it down? If that is true then good riddance.