Autopsy Players we traded that are doing well at other clubs.

Remove this Banner Ad

We felt the effect of Butler and Higgins this year for sure, Maurice and Cumberland have not been able to provide that small lightning threat we now heavily lack. Not ruling out Cumbo just yet, few things to address with him and Coulthard needs more time.

Chol, a good year last year, would be handy now Jack is gone but eh, struggled this season to get a gig behind a medieval Casboult. Says enough.

The rest? Hasn't really hurt us and what we got for CCJ was highway robbery.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Aristotle Pickett said:
We had to trade these players for Salary cap reasons but some of them would be handy now.

Ellis , Chol - Gold Coast
Markov- Collingwood
Butler, Higgins- St.Kilda
Coleman-Jones - North Melbourne
Click to expand...

What do you class as doing well?

Ellis missed games this year due to form
Chol spent round 6 - 18 in the VFL
Markov plays in a role we have plenty of, went to GC and got delisted as well
Butler - Still would love him
Higgins is the only ex - Richmond player I hate with a passion
CCJ - LOL
 
Butler is a loss
Ellis left for the $$$
Chol left as free agent
Markov, ccj and Higgins all chose to leave. Mostly all left for greater opportunity.
We didn't have to trade any of them.
 
Philth said:
Spuds do not have 2 x premiership medals in the pool room at home.

Ellis was/is a good player, some of the hate for him on here was a bit embarrassing really.
Click to expand...
Seriously I'm not a hater of his but I've never considered him to be that good and especially when we had plently of others similar to him who could take over his role anyway.
 
Daka said:
We have brought in better quality & lost fringe quality

I must admit Butler would be handy though.
Click to expand...
Definitely would of been handy but I think moving him on was the right move at the time

His last season with us was absolutely putrid and we had a fair few guys playing the role at the time
 
Triggering Tiger said:
Seriously I'm not a hater of his but I've never considered him to be that good and especially when we had plently of others similar to him who could take over his role anyway.
Click to expand...
So, can we agree he's somewhere between Spud and Gun? "Role Player" maybe?

And Markov a spud too? I could always see his potential, and now it's being realised.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Philth said:
So, can we agree he's somewhere between Spud and Gun? "Role Player" maybe?

And Markov a spud too? I could always see his potential, and now it's being realised.
Click to expand...
In his early years yes but we proved we could cover him with others in 2020 by winning the cup without him
 
Philth said:
Ellis was/is a good player, some of the hate for him on here was a bit embarrassing really.
Click to expand...
I liked Ellis but it was clear his best was behind him & was no longer worth was he was on.
He had to take paycut to stay, so he had to move on been good for the Suns & they needed experience.
but has also been dropped a few times this season so... the end may be coming.
 
Daka said:
I liked Ellis but it was clear his best was behind him & was no longer worth was he was on.
He had to take paycut to stay, so he had to move on been good for the Suns & they needed experience.
but has also been dropped a few times this season so... the end may be coming.
Click to expand...
Maybe. He's 30 now.

My point was, he was never a spud.
 
Aristotle Pickett said:
We had to trade these players for Salary cap reasons but some of them would be handy now.

Ellis , Chol - Gold Coast
Markov- Collingwood
Butler, Higgins- St.Kilda
Coleman-Jones - North Melbourne
Click to expand...
All crap
 
Butler at the time made sense. Had lost his way with us.

Higgins is a campaigner and wasn’t liked at the club. Bad for culture and has hardly set the world alight. **** him.

The only problem is we give away our players. I’m not saying do a Dudoro, but especially for these two we should of got more.

It costs you in the long run.
 
lvt06 said:
What do you class as doing well?

Ellis missed games this year due to form
Chol spent round 6 - 18 in the VFL
Markov plays in a role we have plenty of, went to GC and got delisted as well
Butler - Still would love him
Higgins is the only ex - Richmond player I hate with a passion
CCJ - LOL
Click to expand...
Only one I would want back (potentially) is Butler — good player when he is not half arseing it. The rest have not done well. Chol & CCJ spent the year in the ressies, Markov got a 1 yr extension after being a bees dick away from being delisted, brain fade Ellis I was so glad to get off our list and we got compo picks in return. Higgins downhill skier

Maybe OP wants to bring up Brad Ottens ?
 
chriso11 said:
Only one I would want back (potentially) is Butler — good player when he is not half arseing it. The rest have not done well. Chol & CCJ spent the year in the ressies, Markov got a 1 yr extension after being a bees dick away from being delisted, brain fade Ellis I was so glad to get off our list and we got compo picks in return. Higgins downhill skier

Maybe OP wants to bring up Brad Ottens ?
Click to expand...
We got stitched on the ellis compo
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Players we traded that are doing well at other clubs.

Similar threads

richoplzbreed
  • Locked
Roast Welcome to (insert club other than Richmond) #69 Sam Davidson.
Replies
7
Views
912
Truetiger
Truetiger
THE THIN MAN
Analysis Winners and losers: We rank each AFL club’s trade period, and it’s not as easy as A, B or C-
2 3
Replies
58
Views
3K
captain blood 17
captain blood 17
beema limapep
  • Poll
Which key forward should we take first if all are still available at pick 10 or 11?
Replies
15
Views
551
RichoLedio
RichoLedio
Tigerbob
  • Locked
Do we need Peggy back?
Replies
2
Views
274
fargothegreat
fargothegreat
beema limapep
  • Poll
Where are you watching the draft from at 7pm on Wed night?
2 3 4
Replies
92
Views
2K
KiwiTiger
KiwiTiger
beema limapep
Are we in in for a 0 win season with <50% ?
2 3 4 5
Replies
109
Views
4K
59Stanley
5
prodigy
  • Poll
List Mgmt. Should we trade for Pick 1?
2 3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
5K
rfc4eva
R

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top