-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
players who have won brownlows, nabs, afl grandfinals
- Thread starter beautime
- Start date
- Tagged users None
ManWithNoName
TheBrownDog
Only player to win a Coleman and Brownlow was Lockett, and he never won a flag.
- Banned
- #4
Norm Smith is one of the main awards not the NAB rising star.
Voss, Hird, McLeod Judd and Williams have all won a brownlow, Premiership and a Norm Smith and in my opinion that is far more important than say a NAB, Premiership and Brownlow.
Chris Judd has won a Brownlow, Premiership, Norm Smith and a NAB rising star which sets the bar for all future players.
Buckley has won Rising Star, Brownlow, Norm Smith (& 5 Copeland trophys). Didn't quite get a grandfinal one but it doesn't matter...
Yeah, it might matter to him but not to me. he was still a fantastic footballer that acheived so much.
Read Snag Breac's blog about it.
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/blog.php?b=8
Leigh Matthews won the Flag and Coleman, and should have won a brownlow too
Chris Judd has won a Brownlow, Premiership, Norm Smith and a NAB rising star which sets the bar for all future players.
wow, news to me. could have sworn he only got a nomination and Riewoldt (i think..) beat him to the award.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #13
Norm Smith is one of the main awards not the NAB rising star.
Voss, Hird, McLeod Judd and Williams have all won a brownlow, Premiership and a Norm Smith and in my opinion that is far more important than say a NAB, Premiership and Brownlow.
Chris Judd has won a Brownlow, Premiership, Norm Smith and a NAB rising star which sets the bar for all future players.
the nab is an important award.
It is measure of a whole year vs one game
Blue Dawn
Norm Smith Medallist
Norm Smith is one of the main awards not the NAB rising star.
Voss, Hird, McLeod Judd and Williams have all won a brownlow, Premiership and a Norm Smith and in my opinion that is far more important than say a NAB, Premiership and Brownlow.
Chris Judd has won a Brownlow, Premiership, Norm Smith and a NAB rising star which sets the bar for all future players.
Agree with that mate. The sheer quality of that list speaks volumes for the point made too - except that McLeod hasn't won a Brownlow.
- Banned
- #15
Yes your right he was runner up to Reiwoldt.
My bad.
So it's fair to say that the list of Judd, Hird, Voss and Williams are ahead of anyone else as they have won a Brownlow, Premiership and a norm smith award.
McLeod edited out thanks to the Blues supporter...Cheers.
He did win 2 norm smiths though
future jed
All Australian
yer but id rather win the norm smith because it proves that you can play on the big stage. Plus the norm smith evokes that you are a better player and worthy of a higher title. ie Michael Gardner is never refered to as NAB rising star but Andrew Embley is always refered to as a Norm Smith Medal...
- Feb 3, 2004
- 17,999
- 24,204
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- panthers, ukraine & broncos
The problem with the nab rising star is that those that vote on it actually don't watch every game for the year, let alone all the nominees games. So how can we really gage that they did choose the best player for that year?
oh and yep McLeod has not won a brownlow as Blue Dawn stated.
- Banned
- #18
Except that the Norm Smith winner plays an integeral part in helping his team win a grand final (in almost all cases) and a premeirship is what is rated above everything else so a norm smith medal is more important than being the best kid for a season.
Bucks Boy Jett
Senior List
Norm Smith is one of the main awards not the NAB rising star.
Voss, Hird, McLeod Judd and Williams have all won a brownlow, Premiership and a Norm Smith and in my opinion that is far more important than say a NAB, Premiership and Brownlow.
Chris Judd has won a Brownlow, Premiership, Norm Smith and a NAB rising star which sets the bar for all future players.
and in what year did Judd win the rising star, and when did McLeod win his brownlow? Voss never won the Norm Smith either.
Bucks Boy Jett
Senior List
How bout you read all of the posts.
We have already established that i made an error.
well mate i started to reply before the other post were up but how about you do some research before you post?
Bucks Boy Jett
Senior List
Thanks for your imput.
So the list only comprises Hird, Judd and Williams correct?
It makes the list even more revered now, well done!
no cause simon black has done it as well
Similar threads
