Players you respect or don't mind from another club!

[Squall]

Choose a player from another club, it can be past or present.

Support: ESSENDON

ADELAIDE: Tony Modra

BRISBANE LIONS: Michael Voss

COLLINGWOOD: Peter Daicos

CARLTON: SOS

FREMANTLE: Peter Bell

GEELONG: Peter Riccardi

HAWTHORN: Gary Ayres

KANGAROOS: Saverio Rocca

MELBOURNE: Jeff White

PORT POWER: Gavin Wanganeen

RICHMOND: Wayne Campbell

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Paul Kelly

WEST COAST: Peter Matera

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Luke Darcy

 

[jourgo]

Support: West Coast

Adelaide: current: Simon Goodwin, past: Shawn Rehn
Brisbane: current: Michael Voss, past: Marcus Ashcroft
Carlton: current: Matthew Lappin, past: Craig Bradley
Collingwood: current: Simon Prestigiacomo, past: Graeme Wright
Essendon: current: Sean Wellman, past: Simon Madden
Fremantle: current: Justin Longmuir, past: Ben Allen
Geelong: current: Steve Johnson, past: Ken Hinkley
Hawthorn: current: Nathan Thompson, past: Gary Buckenara
North: current: Daniel Wells, past: Malcolm Blight
Melbourne: current: Brad Green, past: Robert Flower
Port: current: Warren Tredrea, past: ...
Richmond: current: Brad Ottens, past: Maurice Rioli
St Kilda: current: Robert Harvey, past: Stuart Lowe
Sydney: current: Brett Kirk, past: Paul Kelly
Western Bulldogs: current: Rohan Smith, past: Scott Wynd

 

[raskolnikov]

Support: ESSENDON

ADELAIDE: Nigel Smart

BRISBANE LIONS: Shaun Hart

COLLINGWOOD: Paul Licuria

CARLTON: Brett Ratten

FREMANTLE: Peter Bell

GEELONG: Barry Stoneham

HAWTHORN: Chris Langford

KANGAROOS: Anthony Stevens

MELBOURNE: Robert Flower

PORT POWER: Warren Tredrea

RICHMOND: Jim Jess

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Adam Goodes

WEST COAST: Brett Heady

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Tony Liberatore

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Currently:

Adelaide: Tyson Edwards
Brisbane: Michael Voss
Carlton: Darren Hulme
Collingwood: Scott Burns
Essendon: James Hird
Fremantle: Peter Bell
Geelong: Tom Harley
Hawthorn: Nathan Thompson
Melbourne: Jared Rivers
Port: Michael Wilson
Richmond: Andrew Kellaway
St Kilda: Robert Harvey
Sydney: Leo Barry
West Coast: Chad Morrison
Western Bulldogs: Brad Johnson

There's plenty more I respect but those are the ones I respect most at each club.

 

[blues4flag]

Go for Carlton
ADELAIDE: Andrew Mcloud

BRISBANE LIONS: Jason Akermanis

COLLINGWOOD: Bob Rose

ESSENDON: James Hird

FREMANTLE: Mathew Pavilich

GEELONG: Cameron Ling

HAWTHORN: Gary Aeres

KANGAROOS: Glenn Archer

MELBOURNE: Jeff White

PORT POWER: Warren Tredea

RICHMOND: Wayne Campbell

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Adam Goodes

WEST COAST: Glen Jackovich

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Rohan Smith

 

[BT]

Adelaide - McLeod
Brisbane - Pikey
Carlton - DeLuca
Collingwood - Burns
Essendon - Wellman
Freo - Pavlich
Geelong - Sanderson
Hawthorn - Thompson
Roos - Simpson
Port - Tredrea
Richmond - Richo
St.Kilda - Maguire
Sydney - Kennelly
West Coast - Judd
Bulldogs - Johnson

 

[BulldogMike]

ADELAIDE: Andrew Mcleod

BRISBANE LIONS: Jason Akermanis/Michael Voss

CARLTON : Stephen Kernahan

COLLINGWOOD: Nathan Buckley

ESSENDON: James Hird

FREMANTLE: Matthew Pavlich

GEELONG: Gary Ablett

HAWTHORN: Jason Dunstall

KANGAROOS: Wayne Carey

MELBOURNE: Jeff White

PORT POWER: Warren Tredea

RICHMOND: NathanBrown

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Adam Goodes

WEST COAST: Glen Jackovich

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Rohan Smith/Chris Grant/ BJohnson

 

[Macpie]

Adelaide - Edwards
Brisbane - Aker
Carlton - Scotland
Essendon - I'll get back to you - no wait Coleman!
Freo - Pavlich
Geelong - Ablett
Hawthorn - Spider
Roos - Sav
Port - Dew
Richmond - Brown
St.Kilda - Jones
Sydney - Hall
West Coast - Judd
Bulldogs - Smith

 

[skipper kelly]

Copied from a thread earlier this year.

Saints: Harvey
Adelaide: McLeod
Brisbane: Who else. Voss
Richmond: Richardson
Carlton: None, go back to Rhys Jones.
Port: None ever
Freo: Farmer
Eagles: None. Have to go back to Mainwaring.
Essendon: Father/Son rule Watsons. and Merv Neagle.
Bulldogs: None ever
Collingwood: None. Have to go back to Regan.
Melbourne: None ever. sorry, back to Farmer then A. Jakovich.
Hawks: None. Go back to Dunstall.
Geelong: Father/Son rule. The Yabletts.
North: None, back to the Krakouers then Greig

 

[Appollocreed]

Current Players
Adelade: Ben Hart, Andrew McLeod


BRISBANE LIONS: Michael Voss,(Typical Leader puts his body o the line, Helps the younger players out. Skilful and classy 100% Top Bloke), Shaun Hart


COLLINGWOOD: James Clement(underated does his job week in week out) Scott Burns(fair Dinkum Good player)

CARLTON: David Teague(love his Aggresion and 2nd efforts)

Essendon- Hate this Scum but must admit Hird is a top Act just wears the wrong jersey.

FREMANTLE: Pavlich(gonna win the Brownlow one day) Haselby( Consistant Ball winning midfielder)

GEELONG: Cameron Ling

HAWTHORN: Im a big fan but this year Matty Ball has reallly earned my respect has worker harder the anyone to get into the team and his effort and willingness to do teamwork is really impressive.

KANGAROOS: Simpson(see Haselby)Brent Harvey(excitement Machine love to watch him run through 60 and bang in a great goal.)

Melbourne: Brad Green, Aaron Davey( believed in his own ability from day 1 now everyone is realising what a player he is)

PORT POWER: Hate this scum but dont mind Wilson or Tredrea

RICHMOND- Nobody really strikes me to much but Brown is a great player and classy to boot.

ST KILDA- Max Haughton(see Clement) Aussie Jones( built his way back to prominence after so many had written him off) Reiwold(gonna be a champ one day)

SYDNEY: Adam Goodes

WEST COAST: Judd(what a player will have an influence on the game like matthews or Ablett)

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Smith,Johnson,West,Darcy all top leaders classy player give 110% everyweek.

 

[GoCatters5]

Geelong Fan

Adelaide: Ronnie Burns
Brisbane: Michael Voss
Carlton: Fev
Collingwood:Hate em all
Essendon: James Hird and Brent Stanton
Freomantle: Peter Bell
Hawthorn: Crawf
Kangaroo: Glenn Archer
Melbourne: Clint Bizzel
Port Adelaide:Mathew Primus
Richmond: David Rodan
St Kilda: Robert Harvey
Sydenyaul Williams
West Coast:Chris Judd
Western Bulldogs:Chris Grant

 

[crazy_big_al]

Go for Port
ADELAIDE: Andrew Mcleod

BRISBANE LIONS: Micheal Voss

CARLTON: Craig Bradley

COLLINGWOOD: Peter Dacios

ESSENDON: James Hird

FREMANTLE: Mathew Pavilich

GEELONG: Garry Abblett

HAWTHORN: Leigh Matthews

KANGAROOS: Wayne Carey and Glenn Archer

MELBOURNE: Garry Lyon

RICHMOND: Wayne Campbell

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Paul Kelly

WEST COAST: Glen Jackovich

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Luke Darcy

 

[Ricketts]

adelaide ---------- mcleod
bris ----------------- aker,voss
carl ------------------- kouta
coll ----------------- clement
ess ---------------- hird
frem --------------- pavlich
geelong ----------- SUPPORT
hawks --------------- hodge, ries
kangaroos ------------ wells
melbourne ---------- bruce, BROADBRIDGE
power-----------------wilson
richmond ------------kane johnson
saints -------------- voss
swannies -------------buchanan
wbulldogs-------------west
westcoast--------------the bretter jones

 

[Farrand]

Support - Freo

Adelaide - Mark Bickley (past)
Brisbane - Jason Akermanis
Carlton - Brett Ratten (past)
Collingwood - Rhyce Shaw
Essendon - Dean Solomon
Geelong - Steven King
Hawthorn - Richard Vanderburg
Kangeroos - Adam Simpson
Melbourne - David Neitz
Port Adelaide - Josh Carr
Richmond - Wayne Campbell
St Kilda - Craig Callaghan/Heath Black
Sydney - Paul Kelly (past)
Western Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

 

[melbournemartin]

Adelaide: Riccuito
Brisbane: Brown, Voss....all great players
Carlton: Fevola
Collingwood: Buckley, Tarrant
Essendon: Hird, Lucas, Wellman
Fremantle: Bell, Haselby, Pavlich
Geelong: Garry Ablett junior + senior
Hawthorn: Mitchell, Hodge, Smith
Kangaroos: Stevens, Archer, Carey, Simpson
Melbourne: EVERYONE COZ I FOLLOW THEM
Port Power: Tredrae, Francou, The Cornes
Richmond: Knights, Stafford
Sydney Swans: Goodes, Hall, Barry
Saints: Reidwoldt, Harvey
West Coast: Judd, Cousins, Jacovich
Western Bulldogs: Smith, Hahn

 

[Johnson#26]

Support: Collingwood

ADELAIDE: Riccuto

BRISBANE LIONS: Luke Power/Simon Black

Essendon: Jason Johnson/Mark Johnson/Dean Soloman.

CARLTON: Lappin/Thorton.

FREMANTLE: Peter Bell

GEELONG: Sanderson

HAWTHORN: Crawford

KANGAROOS: Sav Rocca

MELBOURNE: Nathan Brown/Brad Green.

PORT POWER: Stewart Dew

RICHMOND: Wayne Campbell

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey/Nathan Burke/Andrew Thompson

SYDNEY: Paul Kelly/Schnider/Maxfield.

WEST COAST: Judd

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Johnson/Smith/Grant/Darcy/West.

 

[jivey]

long list

Adelaide: Riccuito, mcleod,
Brisbane: Voss, Black, lappin, aker, power,
Carlton: Fevola, lappin,
Collingwood: Buckley, Tarrant, clement, johnson,
Essendon: All of em - welsh and mcphee new favourites.
Fremantle: Bell, Haselby, Pavlich, mcphar,
Geelong: Garry Ablett junior, james kelly, josh hunt, harley
Hawthorn: Mitchell, Hodge, Smith, crawf, bateman
Kangaroos: Stevens, Archer, Simpson, wells, motlop
Melbourne: brown, green, white, miller,
Port Power: Francou, The Cornes, carr, james, primus, brogan,
Richmond: richo, coughlan, johnson,
Sydney Swans: Goodes, Hall, Barry, williams, bolton, okeefe, (like this team)
Saints: harvey, ball, dal santo, jones,
West Coast: Judd, Cousins, Jacovich, kerr, embley, wirra, fletcher, cox
Western Bulldogs: Smith, murphy, rawlings, grant, west, robbins, darcy

cbf anymore, i dont dislike many

 

[jmorg1]

Port - Robert Forster-Knight
Blues - Nick Stevens, Heath Scotland
Kangaroos - Michael Stevens
Fremantle - Josh Carr
Collingwood - Alan Didak
Sydney - The whole team (Nice job in 2003 QF)
West Coast - The ruckman Port gave their #1 pick for which was eventually used for Gardiner
Brisbane - Jonathan Brown


Essendon - Jobe Watson
Hawthorn - Peter Schwab
Geelong - Graham
Western Bulldogs - Darcy
Melbourne - Rivers
St Kilda - Hayes
Richmond - Danny Frawley (not a player I know but I can't think of anyone else)

 

[Rodion]

ADELAIDE: Brent Reilly
BRISBANE: Simon Black
CARLTON: Adrain Deluca
COLLINGWOOD: Scott Burns
ESSENDON: James Hird
FREMANTLE: Paul Haselby
GEELONG: ----------------
HAWTHORN: Richie Vandenberg
MELBOURNE: Clint Bizzell
NORTH: Daniel Wells
PORT: Matty Primus
RICHMOND: Mark Coughlin
ST. KILDA: Robert Harvey
SYDNEY: Jared Crouch
WEST COAST: Darren Glass
WESTERN BULLDOGS: Scotty West

 

[topdon]

Support: ESSENDON

ADELAIDE: Tyson Edwards

BRISBANE LIONS: Simon Black

COLLINGWOOD: Scott Burns

CARLTON: Brendon Fevola

FREMANTLE: Luke McPharlin

GEELONG: James Kelly

HAWTHORN: Shane Crawford

KANGAROOS: Glenn Archer

MELBOURNE: Brad Green

PORT POWER: Warren Tredrea

RICHMOND: Joel Bowden

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Paul Williams

WEST COAST: Chris Judd

WESTERN BULLDOGS: Brad Johnson

 

[marcuz]

ADELAIDE: Mark Ricciuto
BRISBANE: Simon Black
CARLTON: Cory McGrath
COLLINGWOOD: Scott Burns
ESSENDON: -
FREMANTLE: Matthew Pavlich
GEELONG: Yyyyyaaaaablett
HAWTHORN: Tim Boyle
MELBOURNE: Nick Smith(the next Carey), Daniel Bell(future Brownlow medalist), Colin Sylvia(The next Ricciuto), Brock Mclean(the next Liegh Matthews) and any more that i wont name as there are too many to mention.
NORTH: Daniel Wells
PORT: Steven Salopek
RICHMOND: Mark Coughlin
ST. KILDA: Robert Harvey
SYDNEY: Barry Hall
WEST COAST: Chris Judd
WESTERN BULLDOGS: Scotty West

 

[liz]

Adelaide: Ricciuto, Edwards

Brisbane: Voss - tho' have to respect most of them for what they've achieved (Aker aside)

Carlton: Ratten

Collingwood: Burns

Essendon:J Johnson, Lucas

Freo: Bell, Haselby

Geelong:Kelly - maybe not 'respect' in the same way as the older citizens on this list but I really enjoy watching him play (except how he's recently been BOG so often against the Swans)

Hawthorn: Langford (plus a bit of a soft spot for Dermie, more for his media work than his football life, which was a mostly before my time)

Kangaroos: Archer

Melbourne:Thompson (see Kelly above, except the BOG part)

Port:James

Richmond: Chaffey

Saints: Harvey, Lockett, Hall ( )

Bulldogs: Johnson, Smith

WC: Embley

 

[tim_smith321]

ADELAIDE: Riccuto

BRISBANE LIONS: Voss

Essendon: Hird

CARLTON: Lappin

FREMANTLE: Peter Bell

GEELONG: Ben Graham

HAWTHORN: Crawford

KANGAROOS: Simpson

MELBOURNE: Adem Yze

PORT POWER: Josh Carr

RICHMOND: Wayne Campbell

ST KILDA: Robert Harvey

SYDNEY: Maxfield

WEST COAST: Cousins

WESTERN BULLDOGS: West

 

[lamby29]

Originally posted by marcuz

MELBOURNE: Nick Smith(the next Carey), Daniel Bell(future Brownlow medalist), Colin Sylvia(The next Ricciuto), Brock Mclean(the next Liegh Matthews) and any more that i wont name as there are too many to mention.

They have all played more senior games than Laycock though... food for thought.

 

[chelseafc8]

Support: Melbourne

ADELAIDE - Andrew McLeod
BRISBANE - Michael Voss
CARLTON - Matthew Lappin
COLLINGWOOD - can't think of one
ESSENDON - Jason Johnson
FREMANTLE - Matthew Pavlich
GEELONG - Matthew Scarlett
HAWTHORN - Sam Mitchell
KANGAROOS - Glenn Archer
MELBOURNE - Support them
PORT ADELAIDE - Gavin Wanganeen
RICHMOND - Greg Stafford
SYDNEY - Jude Bolton
ST KILDA - Nick Riewoldt
WEST COAST - Chris Judd
W/BULLDOGS: Brad Johnson