POD's

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mofra said:
Can anyone let me know how many teams have Grant Birchall in there?

Thinking with Frawley on board he'll have a chance to rebound more instead of playing pure lockdown with a weight disadvantage.
Click to expand...
6.67%

a solid pick this year, should average 90+
 
Interesting that a few of these guys are POD's (so far) Less than 2.3% ownership

Barlow 2.27%
Minson 2.2%
Treloar 2.21%
Rioli 1.92%
Sidebottom 1.91%
R Henderson 1.88%
Docherty 1.88%
Westhoff 1.77%
Gibbs 1.76%
JOM 1.73%
S Martin 1.69%
M MURPHY 1.65%
SJ 1.40%
T Greene 1.36%
Devon Smith 1.29%
Prestia 1.18%
K Jack 1.06
D Swallow 0.92%
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I suspect my Clancee Pearce POD is less so with the retirement of Beau Waters.
 
Gingy said:
Interesting that a few of these guys are POD's (so far) Less than 2.3% ownership

Barlow 2.27%
Minson 2.2%
Treloar 2.21%
Rioli 1.92%
Sidebottom 1.91%
R Henderson 1.88%
Docherty 1.88%
Westhoff 1.77%
Gibbs 1.76%
JOM 1.73%
S Martin 1.69%
M MURPHY 1.65%
SJ 1.40%
T Greene 1.36%
Devon Smith 1.29%
Prestia 1.18%
K Jack 1.06
D Swallow 0.92%
Click to expand...
Wow only 1.65% for Murphy. That's surprising.

Currently have one player on that list.
 
Kadog said:
Wow only 1.65% for Murphy. That's surprising.

Currently have one player on that list.
Click to expand...

Yeah agreed.

I would have thought more people would be jumping on Murphy. Happy for know one else to take him though.

Not overly surprised with any of the others. They all fall into the 'there are better/safer options' category.
 
Kadog said:
Wow only 1.65% for Murphy. That's surprising.

Currently have one player on that list.
Click to expand...

I have Murphy, Minson, Devon & Ricky Henderson from that list.

Henderson is the most surprising at 1.88% I read an article on the Crows website yesterday that he is fit & training with the Defs & will definitely be filling a HBF role this year. Which brings me to Brodie Smith, if Jaensch & Hendo are the 2 running half backs, does that mean that Brodie will be moved up the ground onto a wing?
 
Gingy said:
I have Murphy, Minson, Devon & Ricky Henderson from that list.

Henderson is the most surprising at 1.88% I read an article on the Crows website yesterday that he is fit & training with the Defs & will definitely be filling a HBF role this year. Which brings me to Brodie Smith, if Jaensch & Hendo are the 2 running half backs, does that mean that Brodie will be moved up the ground onto a wing?
Click to expand...
Not sure. Smith got AA in his position and should stick to that role. There's still Reily & Trucks spots to cover down back. Jeansch was pushing up thru the mids and i50 abit later in the year. He might be the one best suited.
 
Kadog said:
What's your take on Minson Gingy? Have him but I'm on the fence with him.
Click to expand...

I wasn't a fan last year. I know JM traded him in at some point, but he just looked underdone for most of the season for mine. Not sure what sort of pre-season he had last year, but I suspect he wasn't really "flying" at any point. If he looks anywhere near the player he was in 2013 during NAB, he should be decent value. It's either him or Ivan for me to share ruck duties with NicNat at this stage. I just don't see enough value in the 570k+ guys at the minute, since ruck scores should dip by 5-10 points this year. You'd be better off forking out the money saved on a 600k+ mid

Having said that, if there were no salary cap, I'd be starting with Jacobs & Mumford in the ruck.
 
Kadog said:
Not sure. Smith got AA in his position and should stick to that role. There's still Reily & Trucks spots to cover down back. Jeansch was pushing up thru the mids and i50 abit later in the year. He might be the one best suited.
Click to expand...

Jaensch could be a sneaky POD Premo Def this year. Keep in mind out of the 22 games Jaensch played last year a couple of those were injury affected 38's. Discount those and his 2014 average is 94.65 from 20 non injury affected games. Priced at 89 he's decent value.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Gingy said:
I wasn't a fan last year. I know JM traded him in at some point, but he just looked underdone for most of the season for mine. Not sure what sort of pre-season he had last year, but I suspect he wasn't really "flying" at any point. If he looks anywhere near the player he was in 2013 during NAB, he should be decent value. It's either him or Ivan for me to share ruck duties with NicNat at this stage. I just don't see enough value in the 570k+ guys at the minute, since ruck scores should dip by 5-10 points this year. You'd be better off forking out the money saved on a 600k+ mid

Having said that, if there were no salary cap, I'd be starting with Jacobs & Mumford in the ruck.
Click to expand...
He had almost no pre-season last year, has done everything this year.

Problem is if you compare him head to head with a similar priced player (Maric) he gets far more of his points from hit-outs which may be dulled by the scoring changes this year. Maric has higher possies, marks, goals and DE yet Minson creamed him in total # of hit-outs.
Minson is durable though - played all though injury last year so really is a set & forget option.
 
Mofra said:
He had almost no pre-season last year, has done everything this year.

Problem is if you compare him head to head with a similar priced player (Maric) he gets far more of his points from hit-outs which may be dulled by the scoring changes this year. Maric has higher possies, marks, goals and DE yet Minson creamed him in total # of hit-outs.
Minson is durable though - played all though injury last year so really is a set & forget option.
Click to expand...
Good to hear he's fit. I've got my coke glasses on him during nab. Not doing much other than hitouts is a concern though particularly as taps now don't score unless to advantage. What's his % like in this area?
Gingy said:
I wasn't a fan last year. I know JM traded him in at some point, but he just looked underdone for most of the season for mine. Not sure what sort of pre-season he had last year, but I suspect he wasn't really "flying" at any point. If he looks anywhere near the player he was in 2013 during NAB, he should be decent value. It's either him or Ivan for me to share ruck duties with NicNat at this stage. I just don't see enough value in the 570k+ guys at the minute, since ruck scores should dip by 5-10 points this year. You'd be better off forking out the money saved on a 600k+ mid

Having said that, if there were no salary cap, I'd be starting with Jacobs & Mumford in the ruck.
Click to expand...
Thought you had Mummy?
I think Goldys good value too. Avg 129 in last 9 games incl finals which coincided with him getting over that shoulder issue. On that he should priced above 600k
 
Kadog said:
Good to hear he's fit. I've got my coke glasses on him during nab. Not doing much other than hitouts is a concern though particularly as taps now don't score unless to advantage. What's his % like in this area?

Thought you had Mummy?
I think Goldys good value too. Avg 129 in last 9 games incl finals which coincided with him getting over that shoulder issue. On that he should priced above 600k
Click to expand...

Whats was Goldy's hit out to adv %?
 
rocker_oz33 said:
Really the wrong thread but i have started with spud rucks (well at least one spud) last few years.This year i want good rucks and they change the rules grrrrr.
Click to expand...
+1

I have more headaches with the rucks than the backline.
 
Pretty these are last years taps to ad...>










2015 TOP-PRICED RUCKMEN

1. Sam Jacobs (Adelaide) $620,100

2. Shane Mumford (GWS Giants) $613,700

3. Stefan Martin (Brisbane) $600,200

4. Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle) $580,800

5. Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne) $574,400

6. Patrick Ryder (Port Adelaide) $543,400 fwd

7. Matthew Lobbe (Port Adelaide) $541,300

8. Ivan Maric (Richmond) $535,900

9. Will Minson (Western Bulldogs) $501,400

10. Nic Naitanui (West Coast) $488,300

HITOUTS TO ADVANTAGE LEADERS (to Round 23)

1. S. Jacobs (33%) 257

2. S. Hampson (30%) 98:eek::eek:.

3. A. Sandilands (29%) 235

4. T. Goldstein (29%) 211

5. M. Lobbe (28%) 193

6. S. Mumford (27%) 168

7. M. Pyke (26%) 115

8. W. Minson (25%) 193

9. R. Warnock (25%) 141

10. P. Ryder (25%) 135
 
Cheers rocker_oz33

Going by that, Minson avg 36 HO per game in which 25% are to adv
9x5=45 pts :eek: on top of a 12 possession avg.
Do taps count for anything else?
 
rocker_oz33 said:
Pretty these are last years taps to ad...>










2015 TOP-PRICED RUCKMEN

1. Sam Jacobs (Adelaide) $620,100

2. Shane Mumford (GWS Giants) $613,700

3. Stefan Martin (Brisbane) $600,200

4. Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle) $580,800

5. Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne) $574,400

6. Patrick Ryder (Port Adelaide) $543,400 fwd

7. Matthew Lobbe (Port Adelaide) $541,300

8. Ivan Maric (Richmond) $535,900

9. Will Minson (Western Bulldogs) $501,400

10. Nic Naitanui (West Coast) $488,300

HITOUTS TO ADVANTAGE LEADERS (to Round 23)

1. S. Jacobs (33%) 257

2. S. Hampson (30%) 98:eek::eek:.

3. A. Sandilands (29%) 235

4. T. Goldstein (29%) 211

5. M. Lobbe (28%) 193

6. S. Mumford (27%) 168

7. M. Pyke (26%) 115

8. W. Minson (25%) 193

9. R. Warnock (25%) 141

10. P. Ryder (25%) 135
Click to expand...

Lets also factor in the midfielders at all teams and who's returning to teams from injury
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

blackshadow
  • Locked
Position 2023 PODs
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
380
Views
23K
kenneyswarriors
kenneyswarriors

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top