Taper
Club Legend
- Jun 9, 2023
- 1,815
- 2,278
- AFL Club
- Geelong
1999 preliminary final was a classic and then there was the Pickett vs Kennedy and Harvey vs Rockliff incidents.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Port and Brisbane, is the rivalry still there?
- Thread starter White Dogg
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Moderator
- #27
Really? I was at that game. North won by 45 points.
That's a small fry rivalry.
I assure you, nobody's main rivalry is with North Melbourne.
I see it as a fairly low level rivalry akin to ones such as Geelong Vs St Kilda, Hawthorn Vs North Melbourne or Sydney vs West Coast etc.
There is something there because of their histories, but nothing of great significance.
That's my perception of it anyway.
There is something there because of their histories, but nothing of great significance.
That's my perception of it anyway.
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,820
- 13,500
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I was there too, the first half was brilliant, agree it's not a prominent rivalry though
Essendon and North have been competing directly since football began, it's a very strong rivalry
How are Port and North Melbourne rivals? I don't see it
Elmer_Hauser
Celtics 6-1
You haven't read the last 9 months here and the various JH-F threads on both club boards and on the main board?
The hate between the two teams is real and tasty.
- Apr 24, 2022
- 3,654
- 9,987
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
how is north supporters moaning about a trade a rivalry?
i doubt any port adelaide fans or the club care about north melbourne at all
I think the rivalry is strictly limited to BF with the JHF sh1tfight. Outside that, know one cares about the games between the two.
Elmer_Hauser
Celtics 6-1
I guess I view a rivalry as being mainly based on club's onfield performances against one another.
Not to say that other factors can't add a lot of spice to it, like the trade you mentioned, or Jeff Kennett calling Geelong psychologically weak etc.
Kane Cornes and David King beg to differ, which adds spice to the rivalry
Not sure if Port fans hold Kane in the same esteem as King does with NM fans. It will never bring the additional bums on seats during game day.
Elmer_Hauser
Celtics 6-1
Apparently they came to blows in the SEN studio a few months ago over JH-F
But yeah i know most Port fans haven't got time for Kornes these days for being an apologist and puppet of Ken Hinkley
That doesn't contradict what I said. I'd like to hear from Essendon supporters whether North is their main rival.
I doubt there would be any lingering rivalry from the early 2000s. The players are different and the respective fan bases would rarely come across each other.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Taper
Club Legend
- Jun 9, 2023
- 1,815
- 2,278
- AFL Club
- Geelong
North Melbourne and Sydney have a fair bit of bad blood between them.
Viceregal
Norm Smith Medallist
I didn't enjoy losing to them in 2004 (of course) but what external animus existed was held more against V/AFL House rather then Port (who had been up and about for a bit).
That being said I kind of enjoyed the 119 point demolition at the hands of Geelong in 2007 (since we sucked and they were already playing in another GF!)
I am certainly more aware of them than I am of the Crows but I think we have more shared experiences (as non-vics) than we have rivalries.
All that being said if the Lions do win this year doing it against Pies or Port would have some nice links to the previous era but any opponent will do.
I think if you took a poll on the Lions' Board on who you would prefer to beat Pies would win but Port would have a decent showing.
That being said I kind of enjoyed the 119 point demolition at the hands of Geelong in 2007 (since we sucked and they were already playing in another GF!)
I am certainly more aware of them than I am of the Crows but I think we have more shared experiences (as non-vics) than we have rivalries.
All that being said if the Lions do win this year doing it against Pies or Port would have some nice links to the previous era but any opponent will do.
I think if you took a poll on the Lions' Board on who you would prefer to beat Pies would win but Port would have a decent showing.
But are they Sydney's main rivals?
Son of Superboot
Boot studder
Maybe in the early days, Fitzroy went out in 96 and the Power started in 97. They had 2 draws within their first three games, but was more likely media beat-up at the time. Arguably during the early 2000's there were some good tough games and both clubs were top of the tree in regards performance and players. As a supporter those games you knew the teams were evenly matched. In 02, in the final round Power beat Lions to finish on top of the ladder, but then Lions thumped them in the Prelim. This is when the media started labelling them as chokers.
In 04, Power get the GF win, and all everyone remembers is Lynchy and all of his air-swings.
There was a nice little flare-up in 2019, Rd 17, where Ken though it might be a good idea to rough-up Lachie Neale. But 5 goals down at 1/4 time and loosing by 48 pts, it didn't go in their favour.
In 04, Power get the GF win, and all everyone remembers is Lynchy and all of his air-swings.
There was a nice little flare-up in 2019, Rd 17, where Ken though it might be a good idea to rough-up Lachie Neale. But 5 goals down at 1/4 time and loosing by 48 pts, it didn't go in their favour.
Similar threads
